Mafiascum.net

In post 1071, Thor665 wrote:What an ungodly boring set of vote counts.

Vote: Sugar Cain

@Matt - get back on this thing, we'll make it one of the biggest wagons of the day if you do.

And the scum-driven town counterwagon appears.

@NBH - Have we discussed whether its a Vig or SK even? Why are you advancing it as a Vig kill? I sort of felt both Majiffy and Trust looked pretty town during the Day 1 scramble fest. A quick scan of Trust has about the biggest scumtell leveled against the slot being 'distracting from the Stupendous Key lynch' which, y'know, in retrospect doesn't exactly speak volumes of deadly scum intent.

In post 1072, Amrun wrote:Thor -- who is scum?

Sugar Cain - why do you think I'm voting him?
I also do not think OGML or John Doe are likely scum, so let's lynch someone else.

In post 1076, Thor665 wrote:@NBH - Have we discussed whether its a Vig or SK even? Why are you advancing it as a Vig kill?

Oh now you're trying to spin JonDoe as SK?

NOT GONNA WORK

No, I suspected trust fund yesterday and pointed out a post or two I felt was scummy.
P sure I wasn't the only one.

Thor -- who is scum?!

P-edit: Why is Sugar Cain scum?

In post 1075, No Brains Here wrote:

In post 1071, Thor665 wrote:What an ungodly boring set of vote counts.

Vote: Sugar Cain

@Matt - get back on this thing, we'll make it one of the biggest wagons of the day if you do.

And the scum-driven town counterwagon appears.

If you believe that then aren't you voting the wrong player right now?
I'd like to think I'm slightly more dangerous than John Doe as far as quality of scum game goes.
I dunno, does he have an impressive scum win record?
I do.

In post 1080, Thor665 wrote:If you believe that then aren't you voting the wrong player right now?

Erm since you're scum and you're not reading the game, I've got JonDoe as town and I'm voting OMGL.

You think you're better than OGML and I should go after you instead?

In post 1079, Amrun wrote:No, I suspected trust fund yesterday and pointed out a post or two I felt was scummy.
P sure I wasn't the only one.

Judging by my Ctrl+F of your iso you're not recalling accurately.
You called them out once, sideways, on like their first post during RVS, then nothing.

In post 1079, Amrun wrote:Thor -- who is scum?!

P-edit: Why is Sugar Cain scum?

Because he had the most functional seeming wagon option to the two leading wagons.
I'll figure out a case later when he posts something, but I recall reading some of him back near Day 2 start and not being overawed.
Why, do you think the slot is town?

No, but your reasoning for voting them is incredibly odd and seems so extremely scummy I am wondering if I am actually missing something.

In post 1081, No Brains Here wrote:

In post 1080, Thor665 wrote:If you believe that then aren't you voting the wrong player right now?

Erm since you're scum and you're not reading the game, I've got JonDoe as town and I'm voting OMGL.

You think you're better than OGML and I should go after you instead?

Considering the case you've presented on him?
Yes. I would think you'd agree too, at least I'm trying to do counterwagons as opposed to random attempts to lynch obv. Vigs - which, y;know, as already pointed out, would solve itself presuming you believed what you were spewing, right?

In post 1083, Amrun wrote:No, but your reasoning for voting them is incredibly odd and seems so extremely scummy I am wondering if I am actually missing something.

How is it scummy to vote someone you don't even think is town?
I *do* think the two leading wagons are town - by definition I'm voting off of them, who was I supposed to vote?

The 'you' in the first sentence of 1085 = Amrun, natch.

In post 1085, Thor665 wrote:

In post 1083, Amrun wrote:No, but your reasoning for voting them is incredibly odd and seems so extremely scummy I am wondering if I am actually missing something.

How is it scummy to vote someone you don't even think is town?
I *do* think the two leading wagons are town - by definition I'm voting off of them, who was I supposed to vote?

You never said they were scummy when you voted them. You said they were a viable wagon that wasn't ogml or Jon doe. I asked you why and you repeated that with a little gem of "I'll make a case when they post something today." Wtf?

I don't see what's wrong with that - no one had an issue with me till I posted and didn't immediately follow the current Kool-Aid lynch plan. That's how the game works.

In post 1076, Thor665 wrote:@NBH - Have we discussed whether its a Vig or SK even? Why are you advancing it as a Vig kill?

I sort of felt both Majiffy and Trust looked pretty town during the Day 1 scramble fes

t. A quick scan of Trust has about the biggest scumtell leveled against the slot being 'distracting from the Stupendous Key lynch' which, y'know, in retrospect doesn't exactly speak volumes of deadly scum intent.

wait wat

I thought you were all over majiffy on d1 or did I imagine that

Here I isoed Sugar - here's my case;

Spent most of Day 1 voting for now proven town players, including a really lazy slide onto the eventual lynch.
Spent Day 2 setting up an elaborate and awkward word trap for Pitoli that was basically an accusation of 'didn't justify every read he had yet' even though Sugar has done basically no justification for any read *or* vote.
And it was that cruddy opening of Day 2 that I recalled, the Day 1 stuff is just sweet coincidence on top of it.

So, now you wanna lynch the scum?

In post 1089, No Brains Here wrote:I thought you were all over majiffy on d1 or did I imagine that

I don't think I managed to post during enough of Day 1 for anyone to claim a legit understanding of my reads or opinions.
I certainly was scumhunting him...y'know, during the 12 posts and rough one hour I posted during.

Yeah but you were wrong.

Can you elucidate your read progression on Majiffy for me, Thor?

In post 1091, Thor665 wrote:

In post 1089, No Brains Here wrote:I thought you were all over majiffy on d1 or did I imagine that

I don't think I managed to post during enough of Day 1 for anyone to claim a legit understanding of my reads or opinions.
I certainly was scumhunting him...y'know, during the 12 posts and rough one hour I posted during.

well considering the day round lasted somewhere around 4 hours your 1 hour of posting does stand out why are you even trying minimize this that is weird.

thor ftr I am leaning town you

In post 1092, Amrun wrote:Yeah but you were wrong.

About what?

In post 1092, Amrun wrote:Can you elucidate your read progression on Majiffy for me, Thor?

Sure.
I thought Matt's claim was obv. fake.
It bugged me that majiffy decided it was legit right off the bat.
I called him out on it and wanted answers.
He basically just sort of shrugged and was like 'whatevs'.
I went to sleep.
When I got back to thread it was locked and people were dead. I read over things and was like 'eh, that was a 'whatevs' because he basically ignored it, so it wasn't the tell I thought'
At that point he didn't look scummy to me.
So I thought he looked town.

That's about as elucidated as it can get.

Wanna vote Cain now?

In post 1094, No Brains Here wrote:thor ftr I am leaning town you

Sheep me?

I like Thor's reluctance to have anyone label him as town.

As for the flavor thing, if the host posts it, I will analyze it unless told otherwise. I have never played with this host so I figured a flavor that long had to have clues in it.

~Titus

In post 1093, No Brains Here wrote:well considering the day round lasted somewhere around 4 hours your 1 hour of posting does stand out why are you even trying minimize this that is weird.

I personally don't think Day 1 did this town any real good, so I'll go ahead and minimize the whole thing while I'm at it.
It was RVS that ended in a lynch, and now we're here.

In post 1097, Jon Doe wrote:I like Thor's reluctance to have anyone label him as town.

I always thought I was super stoked to be called town.

In any case, now that you're town reading me - wanna sheep?