Mafiascum.net

Imperium, if you're pretty sure those two are scum, feel free to put them up. I have an itching feeling KBW is scum.

Minions (Generic head), have you heard of mafia being played on a magic the gathering fan site?

That's the problem, I just don't know anymore. I need to reorient myself with the game here and talk to nacho and see what he thinks about what's happened today.

Oh and nacho feels pretty confident on kbw being town. I have no clue as I don't know how to read players like him and have only played with him once.

In post 1075, Titus wrote:Imperium, if you're pretty sure those two are scum, feel free to put them up. I have an itching feeling KBW is scum.

Minions (Generic head), have you heard of mafia being played on a magic the gathering fan site?

And I have an itching feeling that you're are wrong.

I would not be taken aback at the prospect of one scum bussing the ever living hell out of his teammates since Day 1 started to blend in more with town. Games are rarely as easy as this has come off so far. Considering we have only lost one Town player to two Scum players, I feel a few risks can probably start being taken with nominations.

In post 1078, Keybladewielder wrote:

In post 1075, Titus wrote:Imperium, if you're pretty sure those two are scum, feel free to put them up. I have an itching feeling KBW is scum.

Minions (Generic head), have you heard of mafia being played on a magic the gathering fan site?

And I have an itching feeling that you're are wrong.

HEY

YOU LIED ABOUT OUR META TOGETHER.

WHY DID YOU DO THAT????????

I did not.

Yes you did

In post 1043, Keybladewielder wrote:Let me point this out; in most of the games i have played with Desperado, he was being nice as pie ( i even hydra'd with him once ). And in most (if not all) of those games; he was town.

I've never seen him play scum, but i do tend to notice a lot of people become a little meaner when they play scum. I myself am included.

So I see Desperado's change of attitude as scummy.

The only completed game I can think of with both of us is Hell's Bottom and I was scum.

Like you totally 100% lied about everything in that post

I'm pretty sure we've played other games together. I thought you were town in Hell's Bottom. I thought that RBD was scum in there.

I looked over my completed games and saw nothing. So what was going through your head when you wrote all that?

i dunno, i guess I thought we played more games together. w/e

In post 1077, Imperium wrote:Oh and nacho feels pretty confident on kbw being town. I have no clue as I don't know how to read players like him and have only played with him once.

The only time I have played with KBW, he was scum. So that might color my read.

In post 1075, Titus wrote:Imperium, if you're pretty sure those two are scum, feel free to put them up. I have an itching feeling KBW is scum.

Minions (Generic head), have you heard of mafia being played on a magic the gathering fan site?

Don't like this post. It is too noncommittal. Why not present your opinion instead of just saying "if you are okay with this, feel free to put them up?"

It is non-committal. As you've seen in my posts today, I'm not quite sure who is scum. I shouldn't be the HoH and I've been pushing for Imperium because his reads have been right so far. I am not certain who is scum but KBW is pinging me the wrong way.

Titus, if you ever see anyone playing a 'generic' game of mafia then it's probably me

Oh and those who know me will know or learn that I never read the rules of games. I got mod killed on coloholics for missing a unique no claiming rule so I have form.

And if I really have to cop the backlash for holding off on a claim for now so be it, I'm a big boy. I once had several brothers to discuss stuff with but now you are stuck with me and the imperium hydra will know me better than most.

~ Jerry

In post 1079, Toogeloo wrote:I would not be taken aback at the prospect of one scum bussing the ever living hell out of his teammates since Day 1 started to blend in more with town. Games are rarely as easy as this has come off so far. Considering we have only lost one Town player to two Scum players, I feel a few risks can probably start being taken with nominations.

Is your theory that Imperium are scum bussing their teammates?

In post 1092, F-16_Fighting_Falcon wrote:

In post 1079, Toogeloo wrote:I would not be taken aback at the prospect of one scum bussing the ever living hell out of his teammates since Day 1 started to blend in more with town. Games are rarely as easy as this has come off so far. Considering we have only lost one Town player to two Scum players, I feel a few risks can probably start being taken with nominations.

Is your theory that Imperium are scum bussing their teammates?

No.

In post 1031, Desperado wrote: "Single post?" RBD had 8 of the first 47 posts and they were towntowntown. Especially Jake saying that he hadn't forgotten my D1 hammer on him in another game (when we were both town).

I was referring to this specifically:

In post 48, Desperado wrote:

In post 45, Jake from Rainbowdash wrote:well so far I like toasty's post so maybe there is hope for him, but it's probably cause he likes the show. don't mind me if I talk about the show during the game lol

hi desp, thanks for the vote, but don't think I haven't forgotten your day 1 hammer lol

My bad.

@ Titus: Read the message Dash relayed. They're town.

Pedit: Or that one.

Dash at that point had two posts, one of which was right before yours hence the Pedit. That means just one post on which you based your read.

Toogeloo, then what is the point of changing the HoH or taking "risks" and risking a scum player being the HoH? Can you elaborate on your thought process there?

Minions is probably scum because I doubt any town have power.

Among other reasons obv.

In post 1095, F-16_Fighting_Falcon wrote:Toogeloo, then what is the point of changing the HoH or taking "risks" and risking a scum player being the HoH? Can you elaborate on your thought process there?

I was referring to the HoH putting up nominees that might be more... questionable. We can put Imperium in the drivers seat the rest of the game for all I care. But I think scum hunting in general has pretty much gone out the window this game. Most analysis will likely come from votes for nominees, so why not put up a few riskier plays just to see where votes lie.

We've been avoiding putting up pawns because of fear that the pawn might get evicted by some scum coup d'tat type power or something, but I feel if that exists, then either A) they would have used it on Desperado Town, or B) Desperado is scum and they haven't had a need to use it yet. So... putting up riskier options might give us a bit more insight into alignments.

All I'm saying is that it feels like this game has been on auto-pilot ever since Jake died. If we have pretty much the entirety of the scum team in cross hairs, I guess it's as easy as it seems, but I hardly put stock into town pulling off perfect victories based on Day 1 auto-pilot. I think the only game I've actually seen it happen is Meta Playstyle Mafia. Scum's strategy for this game would undoubtedly be different than normal Mafia games, so I wouldn't be shocked if one of the "town bloc" players has been bussing his mates hardcore in order to skate to the end. I'm not saying THIS IS TRUE, just saying I'm not so closed minded to assume that we have this game on lock.


Also, Titus and Desp... I know KBW was in a hydra in the near 200 page [REDACTED] game.

Another interesting reaction by bbmolla this time.

Imperium, I look to you to spot the breadcrumb, several players now seem in a blind panic that I might be able to screw up the hard work they have been doing trying to look town.