Mafiascum.net

—

Skip to Next Vote Count

—

↑ Pine wrote:I changed my read on Andy for a very good reason that I don't feel like sharing

Then stop being an ass that think people areibd readers.

I'll back down now because I'll take it into consideration.
(And being aware of the went no where aspect)

Well say SG, victor and titus as scum.

↑ Albert B. Rampage wrote:Pine, are you a neighbor?

*twitch* Don't rolefish me when you're Town. I have good reasons. There are no threats to my Townreads, so I'm not divulging information I don't need to

Farside, I think a good reason for Pine being town is Southern Gothic interactions: he dropped some VT tells early in the game, they end up claiming a "goes nowhere" track on him later in the game: that seems like scum taking a small risk on a correct guess on a townie as opposed to dragging a scumbuddy onto a sinking ship.

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:Farside, I think a good reason for Pine being town is Southern Gothic interactions: he dropped some VT tells early in the game, they end up claiming a "goes nowhere" track on him later in the game: that seems like scum taking a small risk on a correct guess on a townie as opposed to dragging a scumbuddy onto a sinking ship.

Why is Farside Town

I need to know about that Who read eventually, but today is not the day.

You look like you're making things up as you go.

↑ Albert B. Rampage wrote:You look like you're making things up as you go.

Who's this directed to?

And aren't we all?

At you.

Of course I am. Like everyone else, I'm reading and making reads as I go

My vote be going back here! but I don't want a day-ending self-hammer yet

Hey Pine I swapped to phone posting but lets talk farside. You've played with her, right? How exactly does this match up with her scum meta?

I don't have a solid handle on her scum meta, she's too adaptable. It doesn't, however, look like her Town meta

And I guess I need a little explaining as to why what she's posting is scummy, exactly: right now all I see is a passionate and proactive player making a series of pushes that show serious scumhunting and not really much that shows opportunistic tendencies or trends towards survival or trends towards protecting scumbuddies or acting weird around them.

↑ Pine wrote:I don't have a solid handle on her scum meta, she's too adaptable. It doesn't, however, look like her Town meta

Why her play here is different from her town meta is good enough for me!

↑ Pine wrote:I don't have a solid handle on her scum meta, she's too adaptable. It doesn't, however, look like her Town meta

Ooooo lets hear based on 2 games? or is there a 3rd I can't remember for sure where I was town and then link those games to explain how I'm different.



Fyi: i'm different in certain ways in most games as town.

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:But he claimed PR, which meant there was a good possibility you would confirm him./verify claim down the road.

That didn't matter to me. Catching scum making the kill was the priority.

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:@TTH: It's also surprising you call an early claim like that null: do you generally have that approach for early claims if they can't be proven immediately after?

This is only my second closed game, so I can't answer that question with any precision.
I think it's surprising you would call claim in particular anything but null. Is there anything that indicates it's town to you and if so, what is it? It's not the fact he has a "confirmed town result" because that information can easily be counterfeited by scum. So what is it?

↑ Albert B. Rampage wrote:This is highly unlikely.

So the likelihood that an uncontested wagon on a special with no counterclaim being on scum is, what?
At this point, everyone's just being willfully ignorant.

↑ Shadowmod wrote:

—VOTE COUNT—

Andrius

(0/6) —

farside22

farside22

(0/6) —

Pine

Albert B. Rampage

(2/6)

— Andrius, VictorDeAngelo

Southern Gothic

(5/6)

— Nachomamma8, Pine, Iecerint, Albert B. Rampage, farside22

All is Who

(1/6)

— PeregrineV

Not Voting (3/11): Southern Gothic, All is Who, Titus

With 11 players still alive, 6 votes are required for a lynch, 6 to force no lynch.

Day 2 deadline is (expired on 2015-01-27 18:00:00)

There are more votes on us than votes on everyone else combined and there's no counterclaim.

Does anyone else see a problem with this or am I just cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs?

There's actually several counterclaims of various hardness. That's apparently just not how Town PRs are phrased; a Town Tracker would have been "Food Hunter" or "Food Ranger" or something like that, not a standard role name.

Sorry

You done fucked up

In all fairness, if you hadn't made a serious error, you were on track to do well. I didn't suspect you until you stumbled

I'm not sure if I should feel insulted that you think I made up that action flavor.

Should I?

No

I think it's more the Food Tracker flavor that people think has been made-up. Not the "Bloodhound/Snuggles" flavor.

^This. The dog flavor could easily be part of a scum tracker role, a provided fakeclaim, or a fabrication entirely. Certainly I've gotten that detailed with fakeclaim flavor, just check out Jurassic Park mafia, where I did actual research on studies suggesting that T Rex was a scavenger to justify my fakeclaim