Mafiascum.net

Let's put this out there: Xtoxm targeted Knuckles night one, was redirected to Dong. I forget what exactly his role does, but this was what told me that Knuckles was the one targeted. Also, from my ability (I talk to someone to join my neighborhood: Limit 2 people (myself included). If scum, I die. If town, they join me), I know he's town. So basically, scum tried to NK knuckles night 1 and dong had them redirected. Scum has no knowledge of this specific redirect so they're not playing a super-weird gambit here.

I re-read the neighborhood after voting knuckles because I felt an inkling I was doing something stupid.

↑ grapes wrote:

↑ Aj The Epic wrote:Also, to reiterate: before any lynch, Starbuck MUST stump as long as it isn't mylo/lylo. Her not being apart of the living will confirm her eventually.

how?

Because if scum is 'dead' even as a treestump as the last alive, town wins.

Actually I think you claimed that day 2 already and I (plus everyone) sorta forgot.

Pretty sure it's just SK left, then. Because there's not a lot of options left. We should really let me cop vedith/firebringer just to be super sure, though. Like they're longshots as scum but I wouldn't bet the game on it.

Random and SoS had enough gadgets that it's plausible they're a two man team as well.

And I mean I guess it could be starbuck? But like her shattering and effectively hammering a buddy like that seems weird. And we can't really confirm her via stump until any potential third parties are out of the way.

Still not seeing any reason to not lynch you today and then if you aren't scum flip dave tomorrow.

The reason to not lynch me today is because I can get another clear. I'm a cop. It's the correct play.

Not even being biased.

grapes wrote:The reason to not lynch me today is because I can get another clear. I'm a cop. It's the correct play.

Not even being biased.

I'm almost tempted to take this route but then this just makes me paranoid that, if they are scum they have some tactic to win tonight.

It's not really the correct play. We have a claimed vig in the open and an openly claimed cop who admits a guilty can come up on towns, even though we have no Miller. It's written in right now that you could use this as an excuse to get a townie lynched. The vig/sk has smited scum already. The cop has too irrelevant town cops and SOMEHOW figured you would cop me N1 because i was lurking.

The correct play here would be to string you up.

Can I ask why we're all assuming only two scum? Can I also ask why grapes just happens to be SK-speccing only now when they're under pressure?

I'm not assuming 2 scum.

If I was scum I'd have given up by now. Like all I'm asking for is another clear. That cements a town win.

Literally nobody left can be scum. Dav is SK.

Like we're a few days from lylo, whoever taught you to lynch a claimed cop because their clears happen to be redundant taught you wrong. Literally how would I have known you guys were basically clear already anyway?

Aj The Epic wrote:I'm not assuming 2 scum.

↑ Aj The Epic wrote:It's not really the correct play. We have a claimed vig in the open and an openly claimed cop who admits a guilty can come up on towns, even though we have no Miller. It's written in right now that you could use this as an excuse to get a townie lynched.

The vig/sk has smited scum already.

The cop has too irrelevant town cops and SOMEHOW figured you would cop me N1 because i was lurking.

The correct play here would be to string you up.

I'm just reading "smited" as "killed all of them". Is this me being stupid again?

grapes wrote:If I was scum I'd have given up by now. Like all I'm asking for is another clear. That cements a town win.

I feel like your tactic is giving up though, just an attempt to get one more town lynch through. jsyk.

What do I gain from getting one more mislynch? I'm the last scum and people are breathing down my neck as it is.

Trust me I wouldn't have even bothered.

Game is solved anyway, though, I guess. Just wish people would realize I'm fucking obviously town.

Town:
grapes
xtoxm
aj
davsto
knuckles?

probstown
starbuck
vedith
firebringer

↑ grapes wrote:If I was scum I'd have given up by now. Like all I'm asking for is another clear. That cements a town win.

Literally nobody left can be scum.

Dav is SK.

Like we're a few days from lylo, whoever taught you to lynch a claimed cop because their clears happen to be redundant taught you wrong. Literally how would I have known you guys were basically clear already anyway?

↑ grapes wrote:Game is solved anyway, though, I guess. Just wish people would realize I'm fucking obviously town.

Town

:
grapes
xtoxm
aj

davsto

knuckles?

probstown
starbuck
vedith
firebringer

?

↑ Davsto wrote:I'm just reading "smited" as "killed all of them". Is this me being stupid again?

Killed/Smited used interchangeably.


Grapes, if we have an SK, why other than dave has their been no factional kills besides mafia? And if you're assuming this, why is dave in your town pile?

Yeah and then dave beat me to it.

third party and town are arguably indistinguishable

But you're arguing only third party left so what's the probtown category for?

when everything is basically town outside some tinfoil shit - that's when you start SK hunting - and it's probably the guy with a gun

people who aren't confirmed town by the mod

I guess 'not scum' would be more appropriate if we're nitpicking here

Why do you think there are only two Mafia?

because nothing else really makes much sense - i can be SURE of that pretty much with