A Musical Mafia! (Game over)

[SnarkySnowman]

I'm still not sure what made the replacing out part scummy. I don't feel that way at all, it seemed unrelated to the game.

[Spiffeh]

Snarky do something

[Spiffeh]

Explain in your own words why FS is still the best vote for today over anyone else on the table

[Spiffeh]

Are you trying to call 1001 an elaboration? I had trouble pinning down why you're voting Skybird.

Actually I really don't get how you still can't understand why I'm voting for Skybird after reading that post?

It's one thing to not be convinced but I don't buy that you can't pin down why I'm voting for her

when I made that post specifically to explain why I'm voting for her

[Spiffeh]

Someone talk to me so I don't have to do my homework

[Spiffeh]

Ugh I feel like I have too many townreads and someone is dogging me

I'm starting to think I townread Mala/gm too easily

[pistachi0n]

I'm still not sure what made the replacing out part scummy. I don't feel that way at all, it seemed unrelated to the game.

I don't think people are using that as a main reason for a scumread.

[beeboy]

I'm still not sure what made the replacing out part scummy. I don't feel that way at all, it seemed unrelated to the game.

I don't think people are using that as a main reason for a scumread.

What is your stance on the slot?

[Spiffeh]

That's partially why. His recent Dram push sucks too.

What is awful about his dram push?

I think it is pretty plausible for anyone unfamiliar with dram to be scum reading him.

[beeboy]

VOTE: Cakes

I want to do this now

[beeboy]

VOTE: Cakes

I want to do this now

[beeboy]

I haven't found any scum hunting from the Cakes slot that I actually like.
Discuss.

[Skybird]

Happy easter! pdodge, still think Seniors should be lynched.

Snarky, why did you come in and naked vote Seniors in post 74and are still maintaining they should be lynched in the quoted post? What's your reasoning for thinking Seniors is scummy?

[beeboy]

^ agreed.

Sheep me with a Cakes vote Snarky.

[davesaz]

Are you trying to call 1001 an elaboration? I had trouble pinning down why you're voting Skybird.

Actually I really don't get how you still can't understand why I'm voting for Skybird after reading that post?

It's one thing to not be convinced but I don't buy that you can't pin down why I'm voting for her

when I made that post specifically to explain why I'm voting for her

Plenty of inferences can be made from it, granted. I just have a preference for straightforward "Joe is scum because of X,Y,Z" type posts.

[Sakura Hana]

When does Easter end anyway, i haven't seen anything remotely useful from Snarky.

[Skybird]

I haven't found any scum hunting from the Cakes slot that I actually like.
Discuss.

Do you feel Cakez is more scummy than Seniors? If so, why?

[davesaz]

Decided I'd follow up with specific commentary, to make my point more clearly and perhaps generate discussion.
I guess the way I thought of this post was that I didn't see it directly as elaboration because one would need to know/remember your read in order to correctly interpret the post. Maybe the issue is that it only reads cleanly in context?

I'm trying to sort Ami right at the moment. I didn't like her statement in 685 because it sounds like she doesn't want to scum hunt.

And you think scum are more likely to be open about this?

Like you're not looking really in depth here and it bothers me. On the surface, Ami's comment about not scum hunting as aggressively looks a little weird, but what is the scum motivation in admitting this? You're singling this one point out because it's a little odd and harping on it even though it's not alignment indicative.

This criticizes Skybird's position but doesn't exactly call it summy.

Just noting these two posts because Podo is soft defending Ami here. Possible association?

And you're already drawing associations despite saying you were still trying to sort Ami, all to support what I assume will turn into an Ami scum read?

For instance, what's the difference between podo defending Ami and myself defending FS earlier on? Or anyone defending anyone else?

I think you're reaching really far all so you can have a unique scum read.

And I have been able to identify town!Skybird relatively well in the past so this isn't a playstyle issue.

Is drawing associations uniquely scum, or do town do that too?
Reaching is indeed seen by many as scummy
And it's possible to infer that you haven't identified town!Skybird in this case.

Yeah, it was just that I was hoping for / expecting more.

[beeboy]

I haven't found any scum hunting from the Cakes slot that I actually like.
Discuss.

Do you feel Cakez is more scummy than Seniors? If so, why?

Seniors is at least pretending to legit scum hunt.

[Sakura Hana]

Where i'm currently at is that Snarky's ISO is devoid of anything other than saying Seniors is scum (much like dram's but dram's has 3 scumreads), One of his posts was a pdodge due to Easter (If he doesn't have time due to easter has he even been reading the thread?) It is possible the lack of content is due to Easter as i recently learned that Easter's supposed to be a 4-day weekend? But many ppl have been active here despite that, so I'm unsure if the lack of activity is due to lack of time (and ergo no time to read either) or because of being scum active lurking.

[beeboy]

Cakes scum hunting literally consists of him saying people are playing objectively poorly not scummy.
He hasn't done any solid scum hunting yet and he is trying to give off the impression he is actively doing so.

[beeboy]

Chasing after Snarky isn't going to get us anywhere imo.

[davesaz]

Cakes scum hunting literally consists of him saying people are playing objectively poorly not scummy.
He hasn't done any solid scum hunting yet and he is trying to give off the impression he is actively doing so.

I hadn't gotten that impression but am open to looking at it more closely.

[davesaz]

Chasing after Snarky isn't going to get us anywhere imo.

No better than pushing Swords would have been. Can't leave those slots till late game but no use in going after them early.

[Sakura Hana]

Cakes scum hunting literally consists of him saying people are playing objectively poorly not scummy.
He hasn't done any solid scum hunting yet and he is trying to give off the impression he is actively doing so.

Just went through 1/3rd of his ISO and i didnt get that impression, unless you think him saying your waffling was scum motivated is not scum hunting... Well actually he said waffling is scummy in general. Will read the rest of the ISO after dinner.