Mafiascum.net

Cool?

bro/kthx, can you confirm that you each other's alignment?

Plum was the first to wonder aloud what the "weak" part of bert's claim means. If scum were informed about it, it seems much more likely that town-plum legit wondered about it than scum-plum faking it. If scum-plum had wanted to feign ignorance, I'd think she'd have made more of a show of it.

In post 1098, Kazekirimaru wrote:I need to cut back on hammers, anyway. Bad habit. Cuts down your life. Well, someone's life.

You should never want to withhold hammers. It's not even scummy play, it's just stupid.

Also Kagami, the alignment isn't confirmed, but mechanically and flavor-wise implied.

^to a high probability. Let me put it this way. In my job we use the terms possible, probable and confirmed and each is based on a certain percentage. If I were to use said percentages, I would say BRO is confirmed town (95% or higher). There is always the chance that the MOD is sadistic though so it's not 100% but close enough.

K, that's good enough. As long as it is borderline if not completely bastardly that the mod would make you opposite alignments, it's good enough.

Because I am so loving (not really, but go with it), I'm going to unvote and try to look through this game and choose between the stalemate at Lynch -2 we have here between Pasch and Plum! Sound good? Sounds good!

Gogogo.

Goddamn it, Bert.

Just skimmed their ISO's.

Plum has used less reasoning BUT has been more forceful in reads and going after players.

Paschendale seems to keep his/her options open and doesn't commit as much, but also posts more "wordy content."

In post 1107, Kazekirimaru wrote:Goddamn it, Bert.

Why are you so confident about Paschendale lynch?

What bothers me about Pasch is the "THERE IS NO REASONING ABOUT THIS LYNCH, THIS IS ALL BS" thing. The victim card rings kinda scummy :/

-____-

I like the vote better than plum-vote, but I don't think that reasoning is correct.

It's a mixture of being confident in Plum town, Plum's case, and my gut. I feel good about this.

Did you really skim both their ISOs in three minutes?

Plum's playstyle is really old school. Smells like a mislynch.

Paschendale has tried really hard in this game, and it shows. It's a toss-up, but gut-wise I kept my vote on Pasch.

P-edit: Yes I did. I never really read, as you know.

Three minutes, though? To skim 101 posts between two players, read thoroughly enough to actually get information, process said information and make a conclusion worth voting upon? Come on, now.

For me, the reasoning largely stems from pasch's arguments against me, which are wildly overreaching and demonstrably false. I saw no evidence of similar behavior in his games either as town or scum; so one interpretation is that he's adopting a new strategy as scum (crazy town-tunnel, since for some reason the meta supports that).

He also evaded claiming and intentionally delayed posting while at L-1 with threat to hammer, until that threat went away (which makes me think there's a chance of daytalk).

Mastin's last few posts reek of positioning and non-falsifiable, easily-reversible argumentation, so I'd be even more comfortable with a mastin lynch, but we're getting a little close to the deadline for that. Given mastin's distaste for bussing, I'm willing to interpret his entry as a possible chainsaw riding on the suspicion of plum that he knew bro had.

In post 1113, Kazekirimaru wrote:Three minutes, though? To skim 101 posts between two players, read thoroughly enough to actually get information, process said information and make a conclusion worth voting upon? Come on, now.

I only get vibes! I never read games as you well know.

I already did go over the whole game before several times, just not enough to be able to talk about anything other than gut feelings.

EBWOP: Oh, and also Kaze, I think Brian Skies is scum for that statement I called him out on yesterday!

Him and Mastin on the other wagon = me staying away. Lol.

Both should claim.

Finally this site let's me phone post goddamn

How about we don't get more claims than necessary, yeah?

In post 1115, Bert wrote:

In post 1113, Kazekirimaru wrote:Three minutes, though? To skim 101 posts between two players, read thoroughly enough to actually get information, process said information and make a conclusion worth voting upon? Come on, now.

I only get vibes! I never read games as you well know.

I already did go over the whole game before several times, just not enough to be able to talk about anything other than gut feelings.

Yet you're still voting on gut feelings.

In post 1116, Bert wrote:EBWOP: Oh, and also Kaze, I think Brian Skies is scum for that statement I called him out on yesterday!

Him and Mastin on the other wagon = me staying away. Lol.

I can entertain this possibility, though.

AD has claimed dayvig

or pseudo-claimed it, at least

re:

In post 1119, Kazekirimaru wrote:How about we don't get more claims than necessary, yeah?

In post 1120, Kazekirimaru wrote:Yet you're still voting on gut feelings.

Yeah, that's how I operate.