Mafiascum.net

Our PT is still slightly empty because arthiur is asleep or something

In post 1097, Nahdia wrote:i want every1's reads on Parame and HS.

Town for Para - Maybe town, maybe butter me up for HS, not decided.

Wait, I thought that was a joke earlier.
How could I be buttering you up when you're a scumlean?

I asked a daring question and I used suggestive phrasing in attempt to extract an honest reaction out of Jester, and I didn't like his response. But I'm not going to say he's scum based just on a hunch. If I'm going to be totally honest, I like playing with him regardless of whether he's scum or not and I'd feel pretty horrible if I were the reason he got voted off as town. I wish he'd just shut up about my read on him.

He didn't lie to you, I just said that to shut him up. :/

In post 1096, Vedith wrote:

In post 1095, The_Jester wrote:Dunno she apparently doesn't wanna see me die. Or maybe us.
As I said, I'll need some time cause it's hard to differentiate between buddying cause we like each other and buddying to pocket.

I mean, I'm not sure how to even think of that.
If there's scum in you 2, I'm 100% certain it's not you though.

Tell me, why is Maria town lean for you?

Oh I saw like one post that I liked but it's prone to change. I'll tell you what I think when I finish catching up.

In post 1102, Human Sequencer wrote:Wait, I thought that was a joke earlier.
How could I be buttering you up when you're a scumlean?

Oh? I'm a scumlean?
That changes a lot then. I thought you had me as scum then didn't because I thought Dunn was scum.

No, but having Dunn as scum did help you a whole bunch, same with a bunch of your townreads.
You went from 'this is obviously scummy, lynch this' to 'oh, that makes a little more sense, but this slot is still a little suss'

In post 1106, Human Sequencer wrote:No, but having Dunn as scum did help you a whole bunch, same with a bunch of your townreads.
You went from 'this is obviously scummy, lynch this' to 'oh, that makes a little more sense, but this slot is still a little suss'

Well, alrighty then!

In post 1098, inspectorscout wrote:Nahdia, can you give your thoughts on MDS?

I'm primarily a tonal reader so heavy elaboration isn't something you'll get from me.

Townlean, ever so slight.

@HS maybe it's me but it looks like you can't decide on your judgement criteria

In post 1020, Human Sequencer wrote: Vedith's entire play is him -acting- like his abrasiveness while he's town, but he's not town so it's muted, blunted and not as powerful.

In post 1106, Human Sequencer wrote: You went from 'this is obviously scummy, lynch this' to 'oh, that makes a little more sense, but this slot is still a little suss'

First you scumlean on him for not being as decisive and aggressive as town!Vedith is - and rightfully so- but then you townlean on him for not being so blunt and seeing him coast, leaving his options open.
Which is it?

I'm not townleaning vedith.
Please read the thread.

That post literally does not even make sense. That's an empty jab at a stone wall.

I will happily answer any questions you have but I must ask you to word them a little more legibly.

I would like the people who scumread Vedith explain why scum!Vedith would call his-- gentleman scum, especially with how many votes Gamma has right now? Like even if it's a gambit for towncredit, towncredit is literally useless for Vedith if Gamma ends up being booted from the dance floor.

If there's scum in that pair, I don't think it's Vedith.

In post 1111, MiniDeathStar wrote:I would like the people who scumread Vedith explain why scum!Vedith would call his--

her?

gentleman scum, especially with how many votes Gamma has right now? Like even if it's a gambit for towncredit, towncredit is literally useless for Vedith if Gamma ends up being booted from the dance floor.

I mean, I'm not really pushing Gamma, at least where the rest of you can see, it could be seen as a creditable cause while I hope that Maria and Shadow is lynched - That's if I'm scum, of course, which I'm not.

You raise a good point, but no way am I just handing Vedith a townread with that logic alone, that's akin to handing him the game if he's scum.
Saying 'anybody who scumreads their partner isn't scum!' is ludicrous.
It's also wifomy as fuck.

@Gamma, could I please have your recollection of your PT so far?

I think I'm getting the hang of games with more than 9 people. This is really fun and interesting.
Again, fucking incredible setup, mod.

Oh I know. I'm just saying it's a good thing to consider, even if it's a WIFOM.

In post 1109, The_Jester wrote:@HS maybe it's me but it looks like you can't decide on your judgement criteria

In post 1020, Human Sequencer wrote: Vedith's entire play is him -acting- like his abrasiveness while he's town, but he's not town so it's muted, blunted and not as powerful.

In post 1106, Human Sequencer wrote: You went from 'this is obviously scummy, lynch this' to 'oh, that makes a little more sense, but this slot is still a little suss'

First you scumlean on him for not being as decisive and aggressive as town!Vedith is - and rightfully so- but then you townlean on him for not being so blunt and seeing him coast, leaving his options open.
Which is it?

Am I getting clarification?
It really just seems like you're scared of talking to me because you're scared of slipping up even more.

In post 1097, Nahdia wrote:i want every1's reads on Parame and HS.

HS solid town, comparing to last time her play doesn't feel like an imitation
Parama close to solid town unless Shadow flips town

In post 1115, Human Sequencer wrote:@Gamma, could I please have your recollection of your PT so far?

One second

Post 1: I ask about Vedith's desire to pair with Shadow
Post 2: Vedith says Parama might be right (which I assume means he changed his mind about wanting to pair with Shadow), then points out Maria's inconsistency
Post 3: Vedith complaining that Maria is going to avoid the lynch because she just does
Post 4: Vedith tells me to participate in the partner PT more and asks for reads on MDS, pie, and scout
Post 5 and 6: me responding to Post 4
Post 7: Vedith talks about MDS, Pie, and scout some more
Post 8: Vedith mentions HS is buttering him up, comments on the chances town has
Post 9: Vedith says Jester is town

Vedith, would you say this is accurate and fair?

You made two posts out of 9? Hm.

Vedith, you implied that you were pushing Gamma in your PT after we were discussing how you had him at #3 scumread.
I don't see much 'pushing' in that recollection.