Mafiascum.net

In post 628, SirCakez wrote:

In post 626, RadiantCowbells wrote:I'm fine with everyone starting the game by townreading active people but I'm not convinced jormun lie Amrun Elmo is 4 scum right now

I'm also having this concern.
It's never as easy as 4 scummy low-content players.

In post 653, SirCakez wrote:is Shuichi actually Ceph?

In post 673, Shuichi Saihara wrote:

In post 670, SirCakez wrote:what is the cohesion tell?

In short, the idea that townies care about the reads of other players, and will shift their reads to align more with players they're townreading and less with players they're scumreading. It's something I'm not sure I agree that people actually do -- I know that I usually don't and I think at least some players are like me in this -- but hitogoroshi and I have had a number of fun arguments about it (and I actually mean fun, that isn't sarcasm and he's a treasure.)

In post 675, Shuichi Saihara wrote:I like your definition too, it might be better.

hito is a better town player than me, so I'm starting to think I should at least give that idea the time of day.

In post 1054, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 254, Jormengand wrote:

In post 253, Trojan Horses wrote:I'm curious about Jormengand's profile picture. Is it a specific reference to something, or something guessable?

It's not a reference. It is guessable what it

is

but it's not a

reference

to anything specific. Apart from a fun fact about me, I guess.

[line][/line]

Anyway, back on the game: I have no ideas, other than "I have no idea where anyone's getting their reads from so that's weird, huh."

In post 609, Jormengand wrote:Oh yeah, wagon me while I'm asleep, that's great. Don't worry, I'm used to dying early on both sides so I guess I'll just readslist and hope that I make sense. These aren't in any particular order 'cause I just grabbed them up at random:

SirCakez - I can understand the poke vote on me from town PoV, so that's fair. I don't... get the read on Elmo? So I'm kinda wondering on Cakez's reasoning there but honestly overall seems NAI.
Trojan - seems to be actually trying to to gamesolve so Imma say probably town, especially with the amount of detail they're going into.
We Are Not Helping - is not helping. A large amount of their ISO is just memeing, and while Trojan was also memeing a little and going on about my avatar, Trojan was also actually doing work. Over a hundred posts in, WANH has posted meaningful content in a tiny minority of them, which to me comes off as slightly scummy.
Baezu - I don't like the thing of posting reads without actually explaining those reads. While I don't want to OMGUS, especially not on a read, sheeping someone who said that it was suspicious to know that something was "Random nonsense" between reading it and properly analyzing it (???) seems like a bit of a weak sheep, and the rest of the reads aren't explained at all.
Bernadetta - Doesn't seem to be... actually doing much? Literally just meming around instead of playing, which isn't very towny from my experience.
FireMaPoka - does this player even have any posts? I don't think so, or at least I can't find them (PEDIT: Hey, I found out how to do ISOs without having to find an actual post by the player. Yeah, user has no posts.)
Lie Ren - As above, so below.
Shuichi - Not much to tell from the first three posts. I know as well as everyone that not reading anyone until you've had some time to think and sleep isn't a scumtell.

So on this side of the game, I'd like to see more analysis from most of the players,

especially

the ones who are scumreading players for no reason other than not having posted analysis yet (give us a chance, some of us are ill and/or multitasking. Also I prefer to wait until I have more to work with) - if you

have

got a scumread on someone, then you should have at least some reasoning to explain; if you

have

got the energy for a hundred and one posts, then post something useful. If someone doesn't have reads, I think they should get a chance to make some. I can tell you now that scumreading people just because they were slightly late to the party isn't helpful.

(Also, I don't always have the energy to do things, and seeing how much energy I put in earlygame be brought up as a tell is really disheartening. It's a longform game, I'll get around to my reads eventually.)

The gap from here to here really feels like

Scum told him he needs to give reads so he gave reads

In post 1100, Lie Ren wrote:

In post 628, SirCakez wrote:

In post 626, RadiantCowbells wrote:I'm fine with everyone starting the game by townreading active people but I'm not convinced jormun lie Amrun Elmo is 4 scum right now

I'm also having this concern.
It's never as easy as 4 scummy low-content players.

Except wasn't it that easy in Civilization Mafia, minus the low content players actually being scummy?

In post 1057, Trojan Horses wrote:

In post 1050, gobbledygook wrote:1. Why me?
2. Datisi is in this hydra?
3. Wants to sheep me?

1. Obv townread
2. Who is Datisi
3. Who is Datisi

In post 1060, RadiantCowbells wrote:ILL DO YOU ONE BETTER WHY IS DATISI

In post 1061, gobbledygook wrote:When is Datisi

In post 1102, Lie Ren wrote:

In post 673, Shuichi Saihara wrote:

In post 670, SirCakez wrote:what is the cohesion tell?

In short, the idea that townies care about the reads of other players, and will shift their reads to align more with players they're townreading and less with players they're scumreading. It's something I'm not sure I agree that people actually do -- I know that I usually don't and I think at least some players are like me in this -- but hitogoroshi and I have had a number of fun arguments about it (and I actually mean fun, that isn't sarcasm and he's a treasure.)

Sure, possibly.

Do you not think scum would do an alternate approach, aligning with those whose reads match their ends? Am I missing it being intrinsically linked to your main hteory?

In post 1103, Lie Ren wrote:

In post 675, Shuichi Saihara wrote:I like your definition too, it might be better.

hito is a better town player than me, so I'm starting to think I should at least give that idea the time of day.

Who is hito? I know the name but don't know of anyone here who would be him. Is it on of the Trojan Horse heads?

In post 1104, Shuichi Saihara wrote:

In post 1054, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 254, Jormengand wrote:

In post 253, Trojan Horses wrote:I'm curious about Jormengand's profile picture. Is it a specific reference to something, or something guessable?

It's not a reference. It is guessable what it

is

but it's not a

reference

to anything specific. Apart from a fun fact about me, I guess.

[line][/line]

Anyway, back on the game: I have no ideas, other than "I have no idea where anyone's getting their reads from so that's weird, huh."

In post 609, Jormengand wrote:Oh yeah, wagon me while I'm asleep, that's great. Don't worry, I'm used to dying early on both sides so I guess I'll just readslist and hope that I make sense. These aren't in any particular order 'cause I just grabbed them up at random:

SirCakez - I can understand the poke vote on me from town PoV, so that's fair. I don't... get the read on Elmo? So I'm kinda wondering on Cakez's reasoning there but honestly overall seems NAI.
Trojan - seems to be actually trying to to gamesolve so Imma say probably town, especially with the amount of detail they're going into.
We Are Not Helping - is not helping. A large amount of their ISO is just memeing, and while Trojan was also memeing a little and going on about my avatar, Trojan was also actually doing work. Over a hundred posts in, WANH has posted meaningful content in a tiny minority of them, which to me comes off as slightly scummy.
Baezu - I don't like the thing of posting reads without actually explaining those reads. While I don't want to OMGUS, especially not on a read, sheeping someone who said that it was suspicious to know that something was "Random nonsense" between reading it and properly analyzing it (???) seems like a bit of a weak sheep, and the rest of the reads aren't explained at all.
Bernadetta - Doesn't seem to be... actually doing much? Literally just meming around instead of playing, which isn't very towny from my experience.
FireMaPoka - does this player even have any posts? I don't think so, or at least I can't find them (PEDIT: Hey, I found out how to do ISOs without having to find an actual post by the player. Yeah, user has no posts.)
Lie Ren - As above, so below.
Shuichi - Not much to tell from the first three posts. I know as well as everyone that not reading anyone until you've had some time to think and sleep isn't a scumtell.

So on this side of the game, I'd like to see more analysis from most of the players,

especially

the ones who are scumreading players for no reason other than not having posted analysis yet (give us a chance, some of us are ill and/or multitasking. Also I prefer to wait until I have more to work with) - if you

have

got a scumread on someone, then you should have at least some reasoning to explain; if you

have

got the energy for a hundred and one posts, then post something useful. If someone doesn't have reads, I think they should get a chance to make some. I can tell you now that scumreading people just because they were slightly late to the party isn't helpful.

(Also, I don't always have the energy to do things, and seeing how much energy I put in earlygame be brought up as a tell is really disheartening. It's a longform game, I'll get around to my reads eventually.)

The gap from here to here really feels like

Scum told him he needs to give reads so he gave reads

I'm not usually up for this kind of bigbrain predict-exactly-what-the-scum-are-doing thing, but actually I like this one.

In post 747, Baezu wrote:Honestly, I think I'll be able to figure out the Baker later...

But for the love of God, people, this is town RC

In post 758, Lie Ren wrote:Nearly forgot about this game. My bad.

I wish this would have two unique threads. I’m not exactly a fan of sifting through games I don’t have to, so having to play around the players I likely won’t be trying to sort is going to be obnoxious.

In post 1111, Lie Ren wrote:

In post 747, Baezu wrote:Honestly, I think I'll be able to figure out the Baker later...

But for the love of God, people, this is town RC

Which person is the Baker here?

Also, I have been trying to avoid completely needless fluff, but I don't really feel the need to compress posts down, and part of me feels like doing that in Perfect Masquerade hurt my ability to stay on top of the game.

Also you didn't tell me who hito might be in this game, unless he's not and I misread?

In post 1116, RadiantCowbells wrote:Lie could be nontown

In post 1116, RadiantCowbells wrote:Lie could be nontown

In post 1115, BBmolla wrote:Gobbs why you on the JJ wagon brotha

In post 1121, gobbledygook wrote:I vibe with the Lie Ren scumreads. I am curious why he revealed his main after NSG subtly outted him.
I also feel like NSG knows everything.