Perfectionist Mafia - Resultas

[EtherealCookie]

Yeah, I don't really understand the bandwagon, just for ignoring a question? Sometimes I do too, and get to it later.
:O

[Sanjay]

I don't understand the bandwagon either.

Here are my reason for voting manho:

1. I wanted him to post.
2. I thought his voting analysis based vote was suspicious if he had a neutral read on FL and a scum read on dramonic. Here's why:

cop-SW was roleblocked and vig-mufasa was redirected, so our last 2 scums are roleblocker and redirector, right?

let's analyse the vote count: (i'll assume for all mislynch there exist a scum in the wagon)

D1: although BC was the lynch, SW was nearly lynched:

Vote Count - 11!

9 Votes:

Snow White

(

My Milked Eek, saberwolf, AlmightyBob

, Deuxieme Octopus,

Mufasa

,

Starbuck

, Faerie Lord,

Wickedestjr

, dramonic)

scums are in {manho (replaced DO), FL, dramonic}

End Of Day Has Been Reached

10 Votes

BloodCovenent

- 10 (EtherealCookie,

xRECKONERx

,

Sposh, saberwolf, starbuck, wickedestjr

, DeuxiemeOctopus, Santos,

almightybob

, FaerieLord)

this is not a mislynch but i can see scum jump into it late when the lynch is inevitable. also, i don't believe scum-cookie will stay on the godfather wagon for the whole day 1.
scums are in {manho (replaced DO), Santos, FL}

8 Votes:

Sposh

(EtherealCookie,

saberwolf

,

xRECKONERx

, Sanjay,

AlmightyBob

,

mufasa

,

elvis_knits

, FaerieLord)

scums are in {cookie, sanjay, FL}

Vote Count:

Snow White

: (

Snow White

, Sanjay, MrSuave,

Mufasa

,

xRECKONERx

, Santos) + After hammer (dramonic)

scums are in {Sanjay, MrSuave, Santos, dramonic}

as i know i'm not the scum, FL is the scum or (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay) are all scum).

vote: FL

note that the conclusion is true if my assumation is true.

other analysis coming when i have time.

If you look at the conclusion he reaches, that it's either FL or the set (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay)), then voting FL is

somewhat

reasonable. But the path to that conclusion is kind of screwy, using the BC wagon as an effective mislynch wagon. Besides, there are a lot of scum in town right now, and I don't understand rejecting the (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay)) hypothesis so easily.

I can see this if he had a scum read on FL previously, but I don't see why he is passing up his dramonic scum read.

As for what everyone else is doing on the wagon I'm not sure.

Santos?

[manho]

actually, i found FL being pro-town recently. my reason for voting him is not really about his scumminess, but his vote.

so,

unvote, vote:dramonic

. he is really scummy.

[Sanjay]

actually, i found FL being pro-town recently. my reason for voting him is not really about his scumminess, but his vote.

so,

unvote, vote:dramonic

. he is really scummy.

Yeah, that's kind of why I'm voting for you, manho.

Why not vote dramonic before?

[dramonic]

Oh noes, I'm really scummy!

...why?

[manho]

actually, i found FL being pro-town recently. my reason for voting him is not really about his scumminess, but his vote.

so,

unvote, vote:dramonic

. he is really scummy.

Yeah, that's kind of why I'm voting for you, manho.

Why not vote dramonic before?

as i found FL scummier before, but dramonic scummier now.

[EtherealCookie]

What makes you find people scummy?
I don't get it, telling me someone is scummy without any reasoning doesn't sway me to your side at all. And if you're town, then you should have a case on someone, because you're supposed to be scum hunting, not randomly calling out people as scummy, which is something I'd expect scum to do.

[MrSuave]

well, it's not that I was being non commital. I was just asking why this BW was even happening. sure if someone were to give me a good enough reason, other than "he's scum" then I would gladly support it. at that point I had no real reason for or against it.

that being said, his latest posts are full of pointing fingers with no reasoning, and phail logics. (more so the pointing of the fingers =D) before I decide to vote, what is he at right now? L-2 or L-1? I don't want to accidentally hammer him

[Santos]

Unvote

I was voting to incite moar posts from manho. Does that answer your assumed question of why I voted manho, Sanjay?

I'm agreeing with the how suspicious dramonic is playing, but his play in Out in the Wilde has me a little skeptical of dramonic-scum.

No matter, I have another target:

Vote: EtherealCookie

Gut.

[Sanjay]

FL, did you miss my question about why you decided to use Santos as a placeholder vote?

[EtherealCookie]

Unvote

I was voting to incite moar posts from manho. Does that answer your assumed question of why I voted manho, Sanjay?

I'm agreeing with the how suspicious dramonic is playing, but his play in Out in the Wilde has me a little skeptical of dramonic-scum.

No matter, I have another target:

Vote: EtherealCookie

Gut.

And once again, terrible reasoning. "Gut." Yes, gut instincts are so reliable. Let me know when someone actually has a reason to vote for someone, that goes further than "scum."

[zwetschenwasser]

Hmm... I seem to have been wrong. Manho isn't freaking out, so I renounce my suspicious and

Remind people that I'm on V/LA. Unvote

[Sanjay]

You aren't allowed to unvote in this game, zwet.

[Santos]

FL, did you miss my question about why you decided to use Santos as a placeholder vote?

...he gave a reason why he changed his vote to me. But if you're looking for something else...

And once again, terrible reasoning. "Gut." Yes, gut instincts are so reliable. Let me know when someone actually has a reason to vote for someone, that goes further than "scum."

Well,

Unvote

because I have a better reason than a gut feeling:

Vote: zwet

because I've never seen him relinquish a vote like that before. Its erratic play on his part and is entirely a plausible reason to vote for him.

[Sanjay]

What.

[Sanjay]

Voting for obv. town for reasons isn't better than voting for possible scum on gut, Santos.

[Max]

7 days to deadline and VOTECOUNT:

manho (3): Santos, zwetschenwasser, Sanjay,
zwetschenwasser (2) Ethereal Cookie, Santos
dramonic (2): dramonic, manho
Santos (1) FaerieLord,
MrSuave (1): Mr Suave
FaerieLord (0):
Ethereal Cookie (0):
Sanjay (0):

5 To Lynch (self votes discounted if it's lylo)

[zwetschenwasser]

Sorry I didn't know you couldn't unvote... sheesh

[manho]

dramonic is probably active lurking. his iso is full of one-liner. and he is not on the BC-wagon...

[dramonic]

I'm the one active lurking yet you still manage to miss my explanation for not being on that wagon 3 times???

[zwetschenwasser]

dramonic is probably active lurking. his iso is full of one-liner. and he is not on the BC-wagon...

Do you have a conclusion?

[dramonic]

his conclusion probably has something to do with his vote...

[MrSuave]

I'm the one active lurking yet you still manage to miss my explanation for not being on that wagon 3 times???

did you just admit to active-lurking? =O as town, don't you usually play more forward and out spoken? =O

[dramonic]

no, I'm replying to his accusation. I don't consider to be active lurking, since I dont think my content is fluffy goodness.

[Sanjay]

Mr. Suave, you still undecided about manho?