Page 46 of 53
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 6:07 am
by Malakittens
VT. I'm too lazy to log on my alt acc. Ill quote this when I do however.
Titus next.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 8:49 am
by Titus
VT. I absolutely disagree with Rebel's reads but Rebel will be dead soon enough if he's not lying. The end of that day made me think RT and SoS quickhammered their buddy. I cannot see why that doc heal would happen.
Notscience next.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 8:50 am
by Titus
Scratch that. AK was kitty. I like Kitty. I don't like NS, Rail or SoS.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 9:54 am
by GuyInFreezer
In post 1126, Titus wrote:VT. I absolutely disagree with Rebel's reads but Rebel will be dead soon enough if he's not lying. The end of that day made me think RT and SoS quickhammered their buddy. I cannot see why that doc heal would happen.
Notscience next.
In post 1127, Titus wrote:Scratch that. AK was kitty. I like Kitty. I don't like NS, Rail or SoS.
?
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 10:00 am
by beastcharizard
They are all believable. I was trying to figure out the logic of popcorning to kittens though. I just don't see the train of thought there. i popcorned because they were thought to be scum by someone like I am so I figured they sooner they claim the better since it will allow for more conversation on their claim.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 11:12 am
by ProHawk
Let me know when you get this sorted out.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 11:32 am
by ProHawk
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 11:57 am
by Rebel Without a Pulse
In post 1126, Titus wrote:VT. I absolutely disagree with Rebel's reads but Rebel will be dead soon enough if he's not lying. The end of that day made me think RT and SoS quickhammered their buddy. I cannot see why that doc heal would happen.
Wait what why?
In post 1129, beastcharizard wrote:They are all believable. I was trying to figure out the logic of popcorning to kittens though. I just don't see the train of thought there. i popcorned because they were thought to be scum by someone like I am so I figured they sooner they claim the better since it will allow for more conversation on their claim.
Who do you think ProHawk should have popcorned to?
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 12:14 pm
by Rail Tracer
titus wrote:The end of that day made me think RT and SoS quickhammered their buddy.
interesting. unless you think both of us are scum (making this game 9:4 lol), you must think at least one of us legitimately thought that any further discussion D3 was pointless.
titus wrote:I cannot see why that doc heal would happen.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile")
i have a couple theories about why i may have been targeted, outside of being super obvtown.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 12:25 pm
by beastcharizard
Titus is who I think they should have popcorned to based on what I perceive to be the scum reads from the town.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 12:35 pm
by Rebel Without a Pulse
In post 368, artemiskitty wrote:me too
i'm starting to read fast at this point, so i can be caught up and vote for him already
I liked this post quite a bit, actually. It felt pretty genuine to me.
In post 370, artemiskitty wrote:not terribly confident. but SOS was the first person to get my back up a little. she's good as scum.
i haven't been pushing because i've been slacking on actually reading the thread. which is what i'm doing now.
and i'm still not confident that they are TOWN. but also, not really thinking that our vote on them, today, is in the best place.
I thought the initial push on ffery was pretty town. A lot of players that come from offsite are more paranoid of ffery than they should be, and usually end up having immediate issues with her playstyle here because she's too hesitant/less aggressive in her pushes. It would also be pretty nicely faked paranoia if scum; ffery and I both deal with mollie's fake paranoia a lot, so we're pretty good at distinguishing the two with people we are familiar with.
In post 607, artemiskitty wrote:
sorry :/
just not that sure of Daniel Brown as being scum, despite nacho-hydra being certain.
i don't think Titus looks as bad as NS is making him out to be
The hydra had every reason to sheep me onto this mislynch at this point (occasionally follows me when I ask her to trust me on a read), but decides not to. Maybe it's a push for towncred as scum, but it makes a lot of sense from a Mantis-town perspective. It also means that she was willing to join both scumbuddies on the wagon for a while, which seems unlikely.
In post 677, artemiskitty wrote: In post 674, Natirasha wrote:
If there
must
be scum on the wagon, it's probably between Brian, Rail Tracer, and Titus. I am not happy with any of those choices, though, so I'm going to assume worst case scenario here.
titus is town, trust me!!
this is mantis
look at NS's ISO again
I like this post a lot.
In post 726, artemiskitty wrote:Only thing I could maybe be thinking is that there is no scum on the wagon (hard to agree with that when we maybe have 3 scum in the game) and that the kill HAD to be on the wagon because killing someone off the wagon would do harm in VCA along the way.
Hard to see someone coming up with a theory like this when they have two buddies on the wagon.
In post 1030, artemiskitty wrote:you are never *this* concerned whether your reads are screwy,as town... cause you are normally very confident.
this is why i don't trust you.
This is what I'm referring to re: ffery's two metas.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 12:35 pm
by Rebel Without a Pulse
In post 1134, beastcharizard wrote:Titus is who I think they should have popcorned to based on what I perceive to be the scum reads from the town.
doesn't seem that significant to me.
prohawk suspects ak more --> prohawk popcorns to ak.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 12:58 pm
by beastcharizard
I am just saying it is weird.
If I am not mistaken we can afford a mislynch today. I am ok with being lynched if it would help to better the towns chances of winning the game.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 1:02 pm
by Rail Tracer
i'm kind of interested in seeing what titus's logic for either sos or i being scum is, actually.
because if sos is scum and they didn't kill nacho (who left no obvious clues as far as i can tell that sos knew he was a doctor) then they're either playing some extremely gambity scum game or they're town. and unless you think i'm scum doing some sort of no kill gambit for whatever reason, it's extremely likely at this point that i'm not scum.
sad thing is i think cephy was right about titus being the one supplying AK with the town drugs.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 1:03 pm
by Rail Tracer
well, cephy thought it was more likely that titus is scum, i think he's the town drug supplier and AK is a junky.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 1:58 pm
by Rail Tracer
hm. maybe it's not town drugs. maybe cephy was right.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:25 pm
by notscience
VT.
I think I was the last one.
Nacho can you please explain about Titus from the past few days?
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:32 pm
by Rail Tracer
no, i've still yet to claim. i was hoping the remaining scum would be creative with their claim, but they're most likely hiding amongst the VT claims.
i was considering fake-claiming here, but seeing as i expect the next night kills to be nacho followed by me, i don't really see the point. also, if we cannot figure out the last scum without the help of PRs, then sadface.
i'm an odd-night cop, first night was natirasha, last night was beast (inno).
i'm unsure whether a godfather makes any sense here, but i'm thinking beast isn't the play today.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:38 pm
by GuyInFreezer
I reeeeeeeally think that this is 2 maf 1 SK setup.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:42 pm
by Rail Tracer
that would be rather odd. it would require one scum faction missing a kill N1, both scum factions missing their kill N2, and the SK missing his kill N3.
it's more likely we have 1 scum faction here.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:44 pm
by Rail Tracer
SK doesn't make a whole lot of sense either unless it's a bulletproof godfather SK. there are too many counters to it, otherwise (cop, hider, crosskills). also goon+1-shot strongman is underpowered vs town power + possible crosskills
at least i think. i'm not all that good with balance, though.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:47 pm
by GuyInFreezer
N1 kill was too weird to be scumkill imo.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:48 pm
by Rail Tracer
so i'm thinking it's:
miller doctor + ON-cop + EN-compulsive-hider + 1shot-compulsive-neighbouriser
vs
1-shot strongman + goon + ???
rolecop was a possibility i considered, which would make sense if they rolecopped me early on and tried to kill me N2/N3. or it's possible they figured me out because of how i was almost blatantly crumbing it multiple times over the last couple days.
roleblocker i'm thinking is unlikely unless the roleblocker is really, really bad.
encryptor is possible if there was a shred of truth to nati's final post. but i'm thinking that was mostly wifom, so i'm ignoring it for now.
and godfather is the obvious other possibility as a partial counter to the investigative power town has.
gif wrote:N1 kill was too weird to be scumkill imo.
i dunno. i think it was partially PR hunting and partially due to dessew's suspicions (maybe). remember at the start of D2 nati talking about how NKA suggested brian scum? lololol
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:50 pm
by Rail Tracer
In post 659, Natirasha wrote:Mario needs to post or replace out, really.
Dessew's main scumspect was Brian Skies. The nk fits in with my perception of Brian Skies, but as usual with NKA, >WIFOM. Move Skies down a tier in my reads for now.
Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:51 pm
by GuyInFreezer
UNVOTE: