Mafiascum.net

In post 1098, Rick Dalton wrote:Yeah, this is a mislynch.

In post 1120, Rick Dalton wrote:so I sheeped to see what would happen

In post 1122, Rick Dalton wrote:I think it’s quite fair for me to not like that. We may be character alts, but I don’t believe I ever sheeped Cliff and acknowledged that I thought that read was 100% correct. It’s Day 1.

I think it’s incredibly fair for me to not like the wagon on Cliff, who has now become a town read based on the wagon on him, not him himself.

Sharon Tate is also part of the gang, and was someone I put in the proclaimed town block.

I did this on a recent Rick Dalton game as well. With Sakura Hana and Formerfish.

Guess what happened there? That ended up being the 3p lylo, and was a big 1v1 between FF and I, but in the end we caught ScumFF.

In post 1106, Tchill13 wrote:This game is amazing fr. Ppl can disappear and the active ones are punished for playing the game over and over again. It's hysterical.

In post 1107, Tchill13 wrote:I just remember being fos'd and figured I'd be run up. Doesn't seem like there's a ton of pressure on me atm.

In post 1113, profii wrote:Something fishy going on between rick / cliff

In post 1125, Elements wrote:

In post 1098, Rick Dalton wrote:Yeah, this is a mislynch.

L-7 halfway through the day IS NOT A MISLYNCH

In post 1130, Carcalilly wrote:

In post 1113, profii wrote:Something fishy going on between rick / cliff

I'm pretty sure this is just some cute gimmick of theirs.

In post 992, Elements wrote:Hectic, join us
VOTE: roster

In post 993, profii wrote:Continuation from last night

JJD - shouldn't be today's lynch imo

Hectic - I get a vibe from his iso that he is being active for actives sake. I'd say he perhaps lacked direction until this little roster wagon popped up so that's something to consider

Fish monger - thered be a tumble weed gif here if I was clever

Hopkirk is a little bit similar to hectic in his jovial entrance to the game but I get more of a sense that he is trying to convey opinions as the game progressed so I'm ok with that

Roster - come talk to me or the votes stays, y'arr!

Carcalilly - inquisitive enough to be town

Finish this tomorrow I think

I feel like some of this is a bit out of context as sometimes you only see 1 side of a conversation but whatever I'll reassess once I've done them all - not sure if I'm going to come out with a realistic number of slots of concern so we shall se

In post 997, Carcalilly wrote:

In post 977, Hectic wrote:Woah, what's going on here?

According to my memory of the wiki, wagons on people who probably aren't even reading the thread right now are utterly useless. Move your votes from roster to anyone else, people.
Either roster will get replaced or will make a return and we can judge/lynch him then if he continues to actively lurk.

the savior has returned to offer his wisdom!!

In post 1000, Garmr wrote:I am 1000

In post 1007, Garmr wrote:Even through I haven't be vocal in my interactions.


1.I have a town read on judge dread His answer to my query made me feel warm about him. Plus I don't think scum would react the way

2.Laid out a test for gamma i'll find out if his town or scum and I don't need to use any powers to do all it requires is a bit of faith in him it should become obvious latter on. I guess this can apply to Bob in some extent as well. But I forgot he was in the game tilll recently. Through last game and this game bob feels different his more how to do I put it aggressive which makes me feel like his town.

3.I found Hopkirks vote pretty scummy on me I was going to shift over but I thought I would feel them out more. I feel like a town hopkirk wouldn't of disengaged like he did when it wasn't working out so well. But it honestly surprised me he would jump off me. It feels like he was dipping his toys in the water to see if he could get a wagon off instead of actually hunting.

4.I town read Elements now I don't want to go into it because it involves set up speculation.

5. I'm not feeling the "You are great vote" anymore.


Interactionless read.

Well I like caralilly for town but I don't have interactions with them. I hope to change this maybe like day 2 I'm not really in a rush through since I town read them. She pushes the game so I think she vital to the game at the moment as well.

In post 1135, Hectic wrote:Why'd you feel the need to Express a read on Fish Monger on particular? There are other relatively inactive players this game. What makes him different?

In post 1140, Elements wrote:Hectic, we're trying to move onto a Cliff wagon given so many people don't want to vote roster

In post 1141, profii wrote:

In post 1135, Hectic wrote:Why'd you feel the need to Express a read on Fish Monger on particular? There are other relatively inactive players this game. What makes him different?

I am working my way through ISOs literally in playerlist order from post 1.

I wouldn't call what I put there 'a read' - I just wanted to make a joke about a player still have 0 posts at time of writing given we were about 30 odd pages in

In post 1138, Hectic wrote:

In post 1007, Garmr wrote:Even through I haven't be vocal in my interactions.


1.I have a town read on judge dread His answer to my query made me feel warm about him. Plus I don't think scum would react the way

2.Laid out a test for gamma i'll find out if his town or scum and I don't need to use any powers to do all it requires is a bit of faith in him it should become obvious latter on. I guess this can apply to Bob in some extent as well. But I forgot he was in the game tilll recently. Through last game and this game bob feels different his more how to do I put it aggressive which makes me feel like his town.

3.I found Hopkirks vote pretty scummy on me I was going to shift over but I thought I would feel them out more. I feel like a town hopkirk wouldn't of disengaged like he did when it wasn't working out so well. But it honestly surprised me he would jump off me. It feels like he was dipping his toys in the water to see if he could get a wagon off instead of actually hunting.

4.I town read Elements now I don't want to go into it because it involves set up speculation.

5. I'm not feeling the "You are great vote" anymore.


Interactionless read.

Well I like caralilly for town but I don't have interactions with them. I hope to change this maybe like day 2 I'm not really in a rush through since I town read them. She pushes the game so I think she vital to the game at the moment as well.

The Elements read is interesting here.
Has Elements talked about his role at all this game?

The read on Hopkirk is a wiki-approved play.

In post 1143, Hectic wrote:

In post 1141, profii wrote:

In post 1135, Hectic wrote:Why'd you feel the need to Express a read on Fish Monger on particular? There are other relatively inactive players this game. What makes him different?

I am working my way through ISOs literally in playerlist order from post 1.

I wouldn't call what I put there 'a read' - I just wanted to make a joke about a player still have 0 posts at time of writing given we were about 30 odd pages in

Ah, I didn't realise they literally hadn't posted yet.

If you can understand why I said it why did you portray it as scummy earlier?

The reason I'm very aggressive with my response/vote is because your post/vote on me are scummy.

In post 1091, Garmr wrote:

In post 1039, Hopkirk wrote:

In post 1007, Garmr wrote:Even through I haven't be vocal in my interactions.


1.I have a town read on judge dread His answer to my query made me feel warm about him. Plus I don't think scum would react the way

2.Laid out a test for gamma i'll find out if his town or scum and I don't need to use any powers to do all it requires is a bit of faith in him it should become obvious latter on. I guess this can apply to Bob in some extent as well. But I forgot he was in the game tilll recently. Through last game and this game bob feels different his more how to do I put it aggressive which makes me feel like his town.

3.I found Hopkirks vote pretty scummy on me I was going to shift over but I thought I would feel them out more. I feel like a town hopkirk wouldn't of disengaged like he did when it wasn't working out so well. But it honestly surprised me he would jump off me. It feels like he was dipping his toys in the water to see if he could get a wagon off instead of actually hunting.

4.I town read Elements now I don't want to go into it because it involves set up speculation.

5. I'm not feeling the "You are great vote" anymore.


Interactionless read.

Well I like caralilly for town but I don't have interactions with them. I hope to change this maybe like day 2 I'm not really in a rush through since I town read them. She pushes the game so I think she vital to the game at the moment as well.

ew
So what makes you think Town-Hopkirk would have stuck on you there? Would scum Hopkirk reasonably expect a wagon after one question and mostly naked vote?

The direct implication of ' see if he could get a wagon off instead of actually hunting.' is why I said ew. Implying I'm not hunting when I've explicitly made clear who I townread and people I'm disliking/looking at is clearly disingenuous.

For you to have missed my scumreads/townreads existing then you must either
A.) have a problem with my other posts
B.) only care about my vote on you and ignore my other posts
C.) not have read my other posts- which I'm infering from some stuff you've said isn't the case.

Eagerly awaiting your reply at the first available opportunity.
Kind regards,
Hopkirk

-Hop

What did you get out of your vote on me then? You just painted something as scummy then left. It was like you were testing waters. If you were town I felt you would of pushed a bit harder to get something concrete as up to that point you gained no new information or anything to change or confirm your read on me; This shows you weren't looking to sort my slot but to push a case.

Also it's B because my point doesn't revolve around other peoples posts and your comments on them. It's focused on that instance. Trying to spread out and say look at what I did with other people doesn't excuse your actions dealing with me.

see if he could get a wagon off instead of actually hunting [/quote as a fairly central point.

Are you saying you don't see a conflict between that, and you revealing that you don't care if I was town/scum hunting elsewhere?

You're arguing at the same time with the conflicting premises:
-I did something INSTEAD of hunting which is what makes it scummy.
-That it's irrelevant whether I was hunting at the time.

In post 1096, Rick Dalton wrote:Plus, i don’t buy that he’s actually scum. I haven’t been reading too closely, but i feel like he’s getting pushed as scum for NAI reasons.

In post 1099, Garmr wrote:I think my case on hopkirk is better than the cliff wagon.

In post 1102, Rick Dalton wrote:

In post 1099, Garmr wrote:I think my case on hopkirk is better than the cliff wagon.

Honestly, the cliff wagon probably happened because he pushed Hopkirk.

He got chainsawed somewhere, I imagine.

In post 1106, Tchill13 wrote:This game is amazing fr. Ppl can disappear and the active ones are punished for playing the game over and over again. It's hysterical.

In post 1113, profii wrote:Something fishy going on between rick / cliff