Guns & Roses III [Game over]

[Something_Smart]

I'm down.

VOTE: Aaron

[DrDolittle]

I think there should have two scum in here:

Datisi, Amrun, DrDolittle, AaronFrost

is this just from the last 4 people that voted you or does this have any addl substance behind it

[GuiltyLion]

The tell is pretty obvious:

If it's a player I can immediately tell it's town and I can't tell it's town this game in any way, it means it's just scum

can you link me to the games where you could immediately tell AF was town?

[GuiltyLion]

or just name them if you don't wanna grab links

[Salamence20]

Idk how I feel

[Salamence20]

I dont like the fact there wasnt a claim.

I dont like the fact we are going after aaron with less than 24 hours.

I dont like how SS just bought it.

I dont like creature going “hahaha I was here all along”

I dont like any of this

[Salamence20]

I mean it matches what Ive come to expect of creature BUT WE DONT HAVE TIME FOR GAMES.

He should have been here earlier

[Something_Smart]

He should have been here earlier

Yeah.

But who do you think was most harmed by him not showing up earlier?

[Salamence20]

Town if he is town.

If hes scum, his scumbuddies who didnt bus

Remember prior to me voting creature you werent willing to do either wagon at the time and it looked like we were going nowhere.

[Salamence20]

Youre going to have to explain this to me like im 5 to make me believe im not voting scum right now

[Something_Smart]

Town if he is town.

If hes scum, his scumbuddies who didnt bus

In particular, himself, regardless of his alignment.

If he's town, he thought he could make up for it by getting reads based on how people treated his wagon.

If he's scum, he thought... (Fill in the blanks. Why did he continue to lurk after being wagoned for lurking?)

[Creature]

I won't ever claim

[Something_Smart]

I don't think it's impossible for him to be scum but you should certainly not be that confident.

[GuiltyLion]

If he's scum, he thought... (Fill in the blanks. Why did he continue to lurk after being wagoned for lurking?)

maybe he thought he could gamble on Menalque effectively driving the DDL counterwagon to save his skin

not saying that's like the

most

likely explanation, but it's not unreasonable that scum him would continue to lurk

[Creature]

I am leaving some reads if I am mislynched and your second chance is to follow them

If you don't, I take zero part of this loss, you're the one who harmed yourself

[Something_Smart]

I won't ever claim

Um

That's a bad policy.

[Creature]

not saying that's like the most likely explanation, but it's not unreasonable that scum him would continue to lurk

Not D1

I can lose the gas any other day but D1

I won't ever allow myself to get lynched as scum D1

[Creature]

I won't ever claim

Um

That's a bad policy.

That's like what I do every game

[GuiltyLion]

The tell is pretty obvious:

If it's a player I can immediately tell it's town and I can't tell it's town this game in any way, it means it's just scum

can you link me to the games where you could immediately tell AF was town?

Creature you should answer this because it will give your read on AF a lot more validity if we can see that there are immediately noticeable differences in AF's play

[Salamence20]

Town if he is town.

If hes scum, his scumbuddies who didnt bus

In particular, himself, regardless of his alignment.

If he's town, he thought he could make up for it by getting reads based on how people treated his wagon.

If he's scum, he thought... (Fill in the blanks. Why did he continue to lurk after being wagoned for lurking?)

Because he wasnt worried about being lynched meaning that theres a good chance those who voted him were town.

...why arent we lynching this guy? Hes the best source of information at this point?

Why are you on Aaron now when you had plenty of chances earlier? What is it about creature that made you think AF is scum?

[Something_Smart]

But you'll allow yourself to get lynched as town D1?

[Creature]

unless it's MU

MU necessitates massclaiming D1 because town sucks at not lynching important town roles when they're claimed 2 days later

[Creature]

The tell is pretty obvious:

If it's a player I can immediately tell it's town and I can't tell it's town this game in any way, it means it's just scum

can you link me to the games where you could immediately tell AF was town?

Creature you should answer this because it will give your read on AF a lot more validity if we can see that there are immediately noticeable differences in AF's play

I have this:
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=80540

I had one other game in mind but can't link it rn

[Creature]

...why arent we lynching this guy? Hes the best source of information at this point?

Typical say before an obvious mislynch on a target that gives no actual info because everyone was like "oh his lynch gives info"

[Creature]

But you'll allow yourself to get lynched as town D1?

I will care less because I like to insult town for being stupid af (more of masochism)

Still, I am somewhat trying rn