Oh well, can dead share their thoughts too?
Very good play for Phoenix, respect to you, mighty scum!
I am not surprised Datisi picked Norway. Norway looked way scummier through whole game.
Thank you for such wonderful game.
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:22 am
by Menalque
Very well played, phoenix
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:23 am
by Menalque
I think D3 was probably what ultimately lost this for town
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:23 am
by Menalque
P.s. shout out to kanna for her excellent lylo reads
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:23 am
by NorwegianboyEE
Razor is scum MVP
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:24 am
by Naerys
In post 1127, Menalque wrote:I think D3 was probably what ultimately lost this for town
I should have tried harder to persuade
But i doubt it would work.
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:25 am
by Menalque
No, again, this was much more on town for defaulting you into the likely scum partner when you were fairly clearly town — but more than that, it was doing that openly in a way that allowed scum!phoenix to hammer you without having to do anything to get that extra mislynch, therefore essentially losing town a day phase worth of content that may have been critical to figuring things out in lylo
In post 1127, Menalque wrote:I think D3 was probably what ultimately lost this for town
I should have tried harder to persuade
But i doubt it would work.
I mean, worst case scenario - you still get lynched. Otherwise, you succeed in convincing someone you're Town, so I don't know why you gave up so easily.
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:26 am
by Menalque
@dats, well played and bad luck in lylo
Fwiw you’ll see in dead thread that I was totally sold on scum!norway and was yelling at you to hammer him from day start
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:27 am
by NorwegianboyEE
You scumreading me when i'm town is nothing new for me.
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:27 am
by Datisi
The way your reads were switching from TRing Naerys at the time it didn't make sense to pushing her out of the blue shortly after you voted Map. You also looked at 1973 Day 1 and said his play seemed similar only to today say it didn't. Also I'll c/p the reaction bullshit
Spoiler:
Okay, I reread the Day 1, I think I'll take a break to type up what the "reaction test" was for posterity's sake.
So, after Map got lynched, I went through their play and found that they were voting Naerys for a good part of Day 1. Nothing wrong with some distancing. But I thought that if that distancing was planned, that Naerys would bring it up during the next day as part of her defense, i.e. "Map was voting me here, so we're not partners!".
When she
didn't
bring that up, I started worrying, but since nobody else made sense to me (believed in the Salad TR, and didn't think Map got bussed), I decided to ignore the test altogether. Then Naerys flipped Green.
Map wolf voted both Norway and Jackson during Day 1. So I figured let's try again. I asked them both "short reason why I should vote the other person." Because since both partners were bussers, you'd think scum would try to use that to their advantage?
In post 960, Ph0enix wrote:I very much don't like his constant vote switching (especially referring to D2).
He accuses me of voting Map Wolf late even though he himself wasn't sure about Map for the most of D2 as he was busy suspecting you, Salad and also Naerys. How he suddenly stopped pushing you and started trying elsewhere I still don't get, either.
The 180 flip on Naerys makes no sense whatsoever. Either his accusation doesn't make sense, or his townread in the first place.
Phoenix's reply tries to tell me why Norway's behaviour is off.
In post 90, Map Wolf wrote:VOTE: Norwegian
Don't really like 67 and 75. I don't see how GBJ finding you suspicious makes him scum.
Sure he unvoted immediately, but that's definitely not something a scum partner would do.
Literally the first thing Norway mentiones is "Map voted me ergo we're not partners".
pedit: oh hey Mena is here what a surprise
yeah Day 3 was very fucking dumb of me, as described up here
not like my method ended up helping me but fuck that's what happens when datisi is conftown in lylo
ppedit: okay cool at least i wasn't alone :')
Posted: Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:27 am
by Naerys
from their point of view i could have been newb!scum that got nervous from losing partner i guess
In post 1127, Menalque wrote:I think D3 was probably what ultimately lost this for town
I should have tried harder to persuade
But i doubt it would work.
Maybe it would've
I was very dumb for trying to rush that lynch but I was genuinely second guessing myself
it's just that nobody else made sense as the partner
