Mafiascum.net

Like I can understand if this is too nuanced for day 1 in a super large and I can see where you're coming from, but I feel like you're saying "this is diff than his scum game" but my bigger concern is that this is really different from his towngame. Scum that recently lost a scum game can adjust their play; town tends to be a little more consistent in how they approach games

Going to sleep.
So is it just Drixx you want me to look into? @Kirari

What? I'd like reads on Drixx/Elsa/Aaron/Fonz

In post 1124, TrueSoulEnergy wrote:Because I don’t necessarily disagree with the Elsa push.
They were on my starting wagon after all.

Why do you scumread Elsa though? Aside from him being on your wagon

In post 1120, Kirari Momobami wrote:The first four votes were all naked which suggests it was just a random wagon for the most part? Given the biggest threat to a 50 player day one is inertia, I'm not sure why you'd be primarily concerned with five votes being too many or a "policy lynch" getting another 20. Town does have to start somewhere after all

On a reread maybe I was a bit too sensitive... but I'm sure you can understand why I thought that wagon was not exactly random?

In post 1122, Kirari Momobami wrote:Like I think town is more likely to join in on a bandwagon to get the game rolling and meanwhile you're:
1) claiming SK
2) congratulating people on their scumday
and
3) complaining that an RVS wagon is a policy lynch when only one person had said as much

Wait who is your main? Have you not played with me before?

Kirari, I don't think Drixx's overall post count is ever high as either alignment, but he comes into the thread and comments on things currently happening in the thread as opposed to long catchup posts. I generally think this is towny, especially if someone doesn't really do this as scum.

yeah granted I haven't liked his tone either. I don't actually dislike this push; I'm just a little surprised the TSE wagon seems to be falling apart and we're all going off in our own directions.

In post 1125, Kirari Momobami wrote:I feel like you're saying "this is diff than his scum game" but my bigger concern is that this is really different from his towngame.

yeah this is pretty much what's happening I think

In post 1129, Something_Smart wrote:On a reread maybe I was a bit too sensitive... but I'm sure you can understand why I thought that wagon was not exactly random?

Sure but that TSE has a negative reputation is more an indication that he's a fine RVS wagon, so since the point is to get him to give some sort of reaction and get the game going, shading the wagon before he reacts seems kinda anti-town. Like the whole point of RVS is to get reactions, and saying "no don't randomly wagon someone!" in a 50 player game RVS is like ???

I never said not to random wagon him? I said not to policy lynch him (and it wasn't complaining, either)...

In post 1132, Cat Scratch Fever wrote: I'm just a little surprised the TSE wagon seems to be falling apart and we're all going off in our own directions.

What did you think of the self-vote?

In post 1135, Something_Smart wrote:I never said not to random wagon him? I said not to policy lynch him (and it wasn't complaining, either)...

I guess; it read as complaining to me but maybe it wasn't meant that way. I didn't get this impression from your posts

Where are you on Fonz/Elsa/Aaron?

In post 1136, Kirari Momobami wrote:

In post 1132, Cat Scratch Fever wrote: I'm just a little surprised the TSE wagon seems to be falling apart and we're all going off in our own directions.

What did you think of the self-vote?

Not out of his scumrange imo

I feel like TSE is very LAMIST-y as scum when he gets run up

In post 1130, DrDolittle wrote:VOTE: something_smart

Why do this?

In post 1137, Kirari Momobami wrote:

In post 1135, Something_Smart wrote:I never said not to random wagon him? I said not to policy lynch him (and it wasn't complaining, either)...

I guess; it read as complaining to me but maybe it wasn't meant that way. I didn't get this impression from your posts

Where are you on Fonz/Elsa/Aaron?

Why are you continuously bringing up my name for a scum list? Very rude.

In post 953, davesaz wrote:That feels like town A50. Obviously preliminary.

I'll take your word for it.

In post 1003, Amrun wrote:It’s probably as good a flip as any but my spidery senses don’t give me good vibes.

Nero’s description sounded like “why TSE deserves to be voted” vs “why TSE is scum.”

If TSE is town, I’m turning sights on Nero.

Hottest take thus far

Amrun’s right but she’s also scum

In post 1086, Kirari Momobami wrote:Conversely, why are my reads on page 12-13 not going to be "because I read their posts"?

I certainly would expect it to have something to do with their posts.
What you seem to not be doing is saying why the posts give you that read.
The why is what matters. It's almost the only thing that matters.

Cool hit us with a reads lists and explanations dave

I'm not the one claiming to have a high number of reads. And you don't get to reverse the question like that.
It's midnight:30 for me and past time to sleep. Maybe tomorrow.

In post 1137, Kirari Momobami wrote:Where are you on Fonz/Elsa/Aaron?

No impression on any of them at the moment and I'm about to go to sleep.

If you want me to look into any of them, I can do that tomorrow.

In post 1147, davesaz wrote:I'm not the one claiming to have a high number of reads. And you don't get to reverse the question like that.
It's midnight:30 for me and past time to sleep. Maybe tomorrow.

Yes I do

You're making a bad faith argument and discouraging people from giving reads

I have given explanations for every read asked of me in good faith

So now I want your reads with explanations since you decided to take a lazy pot shot at me

VOTE: dave

pop ins to complain about impressions and reads = you can get voted