The searching is over, Muffin. I already found LudiScum. That cat is out of the bag, the conversation is only relevant on whether LudiScum will be lynched now or later. Youre trying to bait me into declaring an entire scumteam again. Thats one of the reasons why I went after Palisades and hung him to his death.
But, essentially you and Ludi are proudly playing rabbits foot crystal ball mafia. Lets pick on IS, maybe he will crumble, maybe he will break, maybe we will get lucky. Wouldnt you love that feather in your cap for "taking me down"? Youre going for a rabid wolverine defense, just keep clawing and biting until one is left standing.
What I dont understand in all of this from Muffin is why he would attach himself to strongly to Ludi, especially on such speculative bullshit as in "I believe LudiScum when he merely pulling a name out of his ass" and "I like the way LudiScum feels". How do you prove anything against that? It will boil down to whoever can shout the loudest and the most often.
Great, wonderful. Now we get to play Scream at each other mafia.
Im using reasoning, logic and a steadfast method of catching scum. ie: WHAT I ALWAYS FUCKING DO.
LudiScum is guessing and Muffin is sheeping. Excellent work guys, really. Truly marvelous.
Lynching him is a town tell. Who thought he was town?
Anyone want to earn me a cookie by telling me who was defending him to the hilt?
It was MoS.
Also zmuffin I think.
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2011 11:06 am
by GreyICE
'kay, one or both of them are scum.
Isoing soonish
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2011 1:11 pm
by Magister Ludi
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2011 5:05 pm
by zMuffinMan
@IS,
1) I'm not asking you to tell me the entire scum team (although you're free to give up your teammates if you want). I'm asking you to analyse that Palisades wagon and tell me who's scum on it (apart from Ludi) and why. Since you claim you hunt scum by analysing wagons, surely this isn't too big an ask.
2) You use "logic" and "reasoning" and that same logic and reason indicated that mastin must be scum, right? And you're telling me your method of scum hunting is somehow superior or something? When Ludi flips scum will you be screaming, "nuh uh, I'm not scum, it must be muffin! Look at him, he doesn't rely completely on 'logic'!!!!"?
3) You're acting like I have some connection to Ludi other than his vote also being on you. I don't. He happens to think you're scum. I happen to think you're scum. I don't happen to think he's as likely to be scum as you are. It's as simple as that. You asked for an explanation for why I think this way, I told you, and now I'm strongly attaching myself to Ludi because I explained it. Riiiiiiiiiiiiight.
4) I'll play along with you for a minute. Hypothetically, suppose you were scum, would you play in a way that you perceive is pro-town? For example, would you use "logic" and "reasoning" to push cases for mislynches? If so, how would I, a mere pleb in comparison to the scum hunting king that you are, determine the difference between your play as scum and your play as town?
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2011 5:09 pm
by zMuffinMan
when ludi flips town*, even. I shouldn't post just after I wake up.
Let's lynch Ludi tomorrow anyway, cuz they're probably distancing.
oppertunistic vote + linning up lynches
Wait, you realize you just accused me of not voting a guy I said was scummy and then in the very next comment saying that my voting that very same guy was opportunistic? Surely a player of your
caliber
can see how that doesn't make
any
sense.
Looks to me like all you're trying to do is defend IS here.
Looks to me like all you're doing is squirming.
Try and follow me here.
You said I you thought IS was scum in your 1086. 16 post later you vote him. What this tells me is that your 1086 was a lie and that you did
NOT
have a scumread on IS.
↑Oversoul wrote:Nero, why are you suspicious of Darox, when you have literally never mentioned him other than calling out people for sheeping his vote?
Why don't you answer my questions and respond to my case on you like you said you would, then I'll answer yours.
You are such a poor excuse for a player, it's cute.
Are you the pot or the kettle?
Like I said CSL/Oversoul/MOS. We throw two of them in the pit and we can't miss.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 6:01 am
by The Fonz
↑Internet Stranger wrote:
Im using reasoning, logic and a steadfast method of catching scum. ie: WHAT I ALWAYS FUCKING DO.
LudiScum is guessing and Muffin is sheeping. Excellent work guys, really. Truly marvelous.
If he's scum, he's not guessing. Just saying.
Though this feels like the traditional crapwagon. Attack someone with bs (not seen any good defence of the notion that IS was 'coasting') then make out that his reaction to being attacked is scummy.
And seriously, did anyone SEE CSL's sheepy and sneaky hop onto the wagon? How are people missing how scummy she is?
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 6:41 am
by Internet Stranger
Because they see it as a novelty to drink my blood, Fonz. MoS is opportunistic, CSL is doing I don't know the fuck what, Ludi definitely started a crapwagon, especially with the "coasting" comment (good catch Fonz) and Muffin is just out for blood and using Ludiscum to do it. For the GLORRRY, right Muffin?
I still say LudiScum if your scum for starting a crapwagon on me and bad horribad posting during the Palisade wagon. Putting out one liners then claiming that you're awesome isn't going to fly Ludiscum. The only reason you get to sit back all smug is because you have a rabid MuffinDog doing all the aggro for you.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 7:04 am
by The Fonz
That said, zM has a point. It's VERY unlikely there were no scum on the Pali wagon, misrepresenting bastard though he was. No reason you can't look beyond those attacking you, even if you do think the push on you is scumdriven.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 7:53 am
by Internet Stranger
Im not switching my vote off LudiScum.
So is what youre asking me to do is to generate a list of suspects from the PaliWagon anyways, which is one of the reasons why I went after Pali int he first place? Just so... someone else has someone else to vote for instead of the LudiScum? LudiScum was on that wagon too you know. LudiScum is the SCUM on that wagon.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:07 am
by The Fonz
Well no, that's not why you suspected Palisade. I'm not asking for you to try to list 'all the scum.' I'm asking you to take off your tunnelvision goggles for a moment.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 9:42 am
by The Fonz
Or, to put it another way, it's a common feeling among town when you think you're being attacked based on crap that it's some grand scum conspiracy, all those who are most hardcore against you are scum, and stupid town are just following them, but actually, that almost never happens, since players who are really big threats to scum don't get wagoned, they get shot. So I'd say it's incredibly unlikely both zMuffin and Ludi are scum.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 10:51 am
by Internet Stranger
I never said that Muffin was scum. Muffins reads like an overzealous townie out to use my head on a spike a symbol of glorious victory. LudiScum is coasting along letting Muffin do his dirtywork for him.
Posted: Sat Sep 10, 2011 11:28 am
by Amrun
↑Nero Cain wrote:@Amrun why do you care if I suspect you? I DON'T want your lynch today.
I'm mod confirmed town, and you're not reading the game. At this stage, that's a scumtell.
Lynching him is a town tell. Who thought he was town?
Anyone want to earn me a cookie by telling me who was defending him to the hilt?
How does that even make sense? It doesn't matter who palisades was. A simple ISO of their posts revealed protown motivation. Unlike the rest of you, I do not have a history with mastin, and I could care less whether or not people hate him. It was NOT protown to lynch him, and the scum took advantage of the hate to rally careless/stupid townspeople to his lynch.