I think it's fairly safe to assume right now that the 3 scum are within GM, KJ and Caled.
We lynch GM as she is obv scum and then tailor our dreams to investigate the other two and protect as many of the 3 of us as possible and possibly block their dreams. Its a 3 person job to get those done imo and it'll narrow things down
If needed we can no lynch tomorrow to pinpoint scum even more.
I cannot comment on the issue due to the influence it may have on the game, but a mod error did not occur.
Vote: Haschel
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:17 am
by Guyett
why?
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:20 am
by goodmorning
Guy: I am not interested in losing this game before I've even gotten a chance to play it. I strongly dislike the way you're attempting to put yourself in a leadership position. I strongly dislike the way in which you discount Haschel as Scum (with fwitch, likely).
Speaking of things, the one caled sent to "rescue" us? That was Haschel.
Also, why dream a dream like that one unless you are deliberately trying to clear yourself as not a killer?
And why do caled's and Haschel's dreams confirm one another so completely?
If that doesn't look a bit odd to you I don't know what does.
@caled: Could you please post the entire text of said dream?
P-Edit:
Why vote Haschel? Because of the above, along with the fact that his dream and mine are somewhat contradictory.
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:21 am
by Natirasha
answer me this then, gm.
Why did caled not hammer last night?
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:22 am
by goodmorning
What do you mean last night?
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:29 am
by Natirasha
I put the L-1 vote at 1:48 pm.
caled posted thrice starting at 6:12 pm. Her third post indicates beyond a shadow of a doubt he was reading the thread and didn't miss any votes. If you are town and caled is scum, she had ample opportunity to hammer. She didn't.
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:36 am
by Guyett
GM who is town and who is scum?
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:38 am
by goodmorning
If you're asking why she didn't hammer yesterday, it's because she was already on the wagon.
If you're asking why she didn't hammer me today, either she wasn't paying attention/didn't realize the significance (which she's done before in this game), felt like trolling for some reason, or (as is most likely) she isn't Scum with Haschel and it's you or Guy instead.
PEDIT:
Haschel is Scum, not only for his dream but also for his content. I have to go ISO you and Nat to figure out who the other is. Anything either of you would like me to know before I start?
In post 1145, killerjester wrote:See it's pretty suspicious that you'd assume Mod error over Haschel-scum. Especially when caled thinks she isn't seriously maimed, which could lend support to your claim that it doesn't count as a visit. The fact that you didn't immediately doubt Haschel's claim might be allusive to scum who knows Haschel isn't lying.
Just noticed this.
In a game with complex mechanics like this one, even with an organized mod like Zai, I would expect mod error to happen.
I would hope that lies wouldn't. I can't think of many reasons Town OR Scum would have to lie anyway.
@Guy: Nat is discounting caled as a partner of anyone but me due to her not hammering me.
I'll leave this game here as a slight rebuttal to that but am inclined to agree.
Posted: Tue Oct 15, 2013 5:43 am
by Guyett
Nat can only be scum if I am scum due to my dream last night
any combinations of {cedric guyett nat} and {Killer Caled} as killer or Caled would have hammered town GM
Killer and Caled cannot both be scum as either could have hammered for a scum win