pieguyn wrote:also my logic isn't that just being a Psychic makes you conftown; it's that there wouldn't be more than 1 Psychic on the scum team, since NM didn't understand how the role worked, and thus that any remaining Psychic would be conftown.
That makes sense, I didn't think of that. I was wondering why formerfish thought I was lying because I didn't see a clear benefit from trying to claim that. But also, it's not like my psychic is the exact same as nm's flipped psychic move. So maybe there are different types of psychic which makes it viable to have more than 1 on the scum team? Does that make sense?
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 2:36 pm
by Seohyun
whoops pagetop
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 2:41 pm
by Formerfish
↑pieguyn wrote:I didn't use Psychic last night. that might be why Seo's action didn't do anything.
also my logic isn't that just being a Psychic makes you conftown; it's that there wouldn't be more than 1 Psychic on the scum team, since NM didn't understand how the role worked, and thus that any remaining Psychic would be conftown.
↑Seohyun wrote:Yep I did, no response at first. Then with the whole missing night actions thing earlier I asked if they got mine and they said yeah.
↑Flames682 wrote:MS I'm gonna ask you one more time why is Tier scum? Explain it so I can actually understand it this time not some bs that I can't read.
Also I will reread ISOs later.
MS is dead. Was that supposed to be an attempted "townslip".
No because scum didn't kill MS so it wasn't a townslip in any way
↑pieguyn wrote:I didn't use Psychic last night. that might be why Seo's action didn't do anything.
also my logic isn't that just being a Psychic makes you conftown; it's that there wouldn't be more than 1 Psychic on the scum team, since NM didn't understand how the role worked, and thus that any remaining Psychic would be conftown.
pieguyn wrote:also my logic isn't that just being a Psychic makes you conftown; it's that there wouldn't be more than 1 Psychic on the scum team, since NM didn't understand how the role worked, and thus that any remaining Psychic would be conftown.
That makes sense, I didn't think of that. I was wondering why formerfish thought I was lying because I didn't see a clear benefit from trying to claim that. But also, it's not like my psychic is the exact same as nm's flipped psychic move. So maybe there are different types of psychic which makes it viable to have more than 1 on the scum team? Does that make sense?
You used your psychic ability on the first night? Why weren't you in the neighborhood then?
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 6:35 pm
by Flames682
Who did you target Seo?
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:02 pm
by Seohyun
↑Formerfish wrote:You used your psychic ability on the first night? Why weren't you in the neighborhood then?
I don't know, that's why I was wondering if I was blocked or something
↑pieguyn wrote:also my logic isn't that just being a Psychic makes you conftown; it's that there wouldn't be more than 1 Psychic on the scum team, since NM didn't understand how the role worked, and thus that any remaining Psychic would be conftown.
How do you know there isn't more than 1 Physic on the scum team? NM had 3 abilities, so it is very likely that all scum have Psychic along with other abilities.
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:11 pm
by Flames682
And along with FF I think Seo is lying. Or is saying the truth except he didn't really target BBT
↑Flames682 wrote:And along with FF I think Seo is lying. Or is saying the truth except he didn't really target BBT
VOTE: Seo
Too bad, I did. Tho I guess you won't know for a while.
@formerfish
1. I told you, I sent in my action and got nothing back, I assumed it was fine because in other games I've played I got nothing back as well. Then when the mod said to send in missing actions I sent a PM to double check and they said they had received it.
2. "Please explain this question and asnwer." - I don't understand this, you don't understand my reply?
3. incredulous, tho I guess I shouldn't be considering it's a upick
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:36 pm
by Formerfish
1. So you were not told that a connection could not be made? You think that someone out there is blocking you?
2. Pretty self explanatory I thought. What does Flames mean by who you targeted, and what do you mean by you targeted BBT?
3. We already had one role that mentioned a loss of vote (granted the player would effectively be treestumped, but still) so is it really that out of the question that there would be another role like that?
I guess you guys have to figure out if you think that this was a town action pushed on me because they would think I was scum, or if this is a scum actions pushed on me because I was right on and they figured that it would be harder for me to push a lynch if I wasn't able to vote.
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:48 pm
by Seohyun
1. Nope, was told nothing. Unless it's something like "people with psychic can't target each other", I don't know what else it would be.
2. I targeted BBT with my psychic ability and I assume that's what Flames wanted to know. Or are you asking what my ability actually does?
3. Not really out of the question, just was surprised considering MS's is more of a handicapper, whereas this ability just seems to be removing other people's votes. Unless they were also handicapped in some way, which might be a possibility considering it seems like it wasn't used night 1 (Like can only use it twice or something).
re: town action or scum action
Not sure right now
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:53 pm
by Formerfish
This is why I don't think you have the ability. That isn't how it works. And with someone who already flipped with the ability I am amazed that you still don't get it.
Here is how Psychic actually works. Anyone who has it can opt to activate it. Once activated anyone who had the ability that used it will be placed in a neighborhood. Once the neighborhood is open it must be used constantly (probably told what that means exactly in the neighborhood thread) to stay open.
I don't think you have the ability because the way you were not told about not making a connection doesn't match mine at all, and even if you were blocked I would still expect the message from the mod to be about the same.
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:58 pm
by Seohyun
But that's not what MY ability says in the description, like I said before. MY ability description has a target.
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 7:59 pm
by Formerfish
Then you don't have Psychic. My description matches NM's, you can't have the same move with a different description.
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 8:01 pm
by Seohyun
lol, then I guess it's a different psychic.
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 8:02 pm
by Formerfish
And again, I feel like the mod would have sent a similar message to you as was sent to me in the event that a connection could not be made. That didn't happen.
pedit- So you are trying to tell me that you have a move called psychic and it does not match the move description in NM's role pm?
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2015 8:03 pm
by Seohyun
I have no idea why we even spent this long on this. Let's talk about something else. Like, who do you think was the one that took away your vote?