BECAUSE transcend is either dumb town or just mafia
DixC is obvious scum though and you really need to look at his interactions with me from the time I replaced in to the end of the day (and with other people, read all that stuff with DixC in mind)
Here's Dunn calmly being hammered nearly 200 pages into a game.
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 12:57 pm
by Dunnstral
Yeah and you being wrong about my alignment and not listening to what I was saying, too
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 12:58 pm
by MURDERCAT
Maybe, I still carried the game and got you a win so
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 1:00 pm
by Dunnstral
So are you going to carry this game by going straight to DixC and Aneninen if I get lynched?
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 1:00 pm
by SirCakez
Switching a vote once isn't really throwing votes around
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 1:00 pm
by MURDERCAT
Anyway, Dix and Dunn are both scum I think. Notice how Dix is a strong town read until Dunn is afraid he is going to flip, then suddenly he's "obv" scum.
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 1:01 pm
by MURDERCAT
Cake come on, are you for real? 2 posts apart? You scum too? I need to go reread the last game...
I would lynch Dix today, but not with you leading it.
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 1:10 pm
by Dunnstral
Stop being picky and obtuse
Transcend is leading the vote on me, so you think he's town or what
Great, let's get DixC
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 2:55 pm
by SirCakez
In post 1159, MURDERCAT wrote:Cake come on, are you for real? 2 posts apart? You scum too? I need to go reread the last game...
it's like he's thrown six different votes....
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 4:15 pm
by MURDERCAT
Cake I want you to lay out exactly what about Dunn's posting today makes you think he is town.
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 4:28 pm
by SirCakez
It's not his posting today, it's his posting yesterday
Also he's the counterwagon to scumscend
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 4:30 pm
by MURDERCAT
You said his posting today was town desperation, I want you to explain what makes you think that please. Especially in light of the game I posted where he did not flail at all as town.
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 4:32 pm
by Dunnstral
I'm not voting Transcend. I want to get DixC (and willing to get anenenin too but just really want DixC)
Posted: Sat Jul 09, 2016 4:35 pm
by SirCakez
I think it's town desperation because I think he's town for other reasons, thus the desperation is probtown. It's not the desperation itself that looks town.
VOTE: Dunnstral
He is scum with Transcend
Thatpost
We know that if someone gets an early game run it's likely because scum are involved. Do not think me ignorant here, i know that there is a high likely hood that we have more village in our sites than mafia. I knew not to hammer Penguin because of this, I knew not to hammer smith because of this. I made some noise so I could get some votes moved around and sift through where players would go.
From this we have a good sense that ranger's list is reasonable:
In post 62, Smithereens wrote:Imo Maruchan did well to get this game rolling. You could at the very least be a tad grateful. I dislike Sircakez calling it a big ball of fluff when literally it's one of the only posts made thus far that has attempted to progress the game. Why is Maruchan a big ball of fluff but nobody else is?
UNVOTE: VOTE: SirCakez
It was fluffy because it was all a big fencesit. It didn't really progress the game at all and I'm not sure why you think it did.
DixC's vote on Shotty for the dog story was really terrible as well.
In post 86, SirCakez wrote:It was a terrible vote, i;e made no sense as reasoning for a vote. Jury's still out as to whether it was from scum or town.
Murdercat wrote:I implied it might be because Ranger can be lazy as scum (my experience with her suggests this is the case).
Lazy is literally my playstyle.
Where do you think I got into the habit of posting nothing but readslists in the first place?
SirCakez wrote:Why do I feel like you're barely doing anything here?
Because I'm barely doing anything here?
DixC wrote:Ranger, comparing post rates and updates I see a significant difference in this game: what are some queries that might help you out here?
Mostly, talking to others. I suppose talking to me is not without benefits, but I can't think of anything. Like I said, largely reactionary.
{karnos, Aneninen}
{SirCakez}
{Smithereens, shotty, Chip Butty, Murdercat}
{DixC}
{Maruchan, Transcend}
{podoboq, PenguinPower}
Scum read: too lazy to do work but so not-lazy that you'll work on telling people that you're lazy? Also preternatural lack of lazy basis for good outcomes... crazy, yes, lazy, no.
Town Read:Not concerned enough with my question to actually answer it. Has podoboq at bottom of the list.
In post 25, karnos wrote:On the one hand, this game is off to a very slow start.
On the other hand, I'm curious to see how ranger's read lists look with such a small sample of posts to read from.
Whut?
As the first post on Page2?
Maruchan's 27 is forced. Scummy.
Murdercat has noticed it in 28. Good. Townish.
Hate to be that guy, man, but that looks an awful lot like coaching.
No, I'm saying that he should have owned up to it. He didn't. He defended the inconsistency, and it's the fact that he didn't own up to it that's a problem.
WTF? I made the point about taking pressure of in #50. #51 was unrelated, from Karnos. And that quote I said could have been coaching was in #52. Shooty didn't reply at all to #50, but you say he defended the inconsistency??? That's BS, pure and simple.
Now you are definitely on my scumdar.
In post 66, Ranger wrote:{karnos}
{SirCakez}
{Aneninen, Murdercat, Smithereens}
{Chip Butty, shotty}
{Maruchan, DicX, PenguinPower, Transcend}
{podoboq}
Ranger's town again. Good to know.
scum read: is scum if maruchan and shorty are scum
town read: is not scum if Ranger is scum
In post 178, podoboq wrote:OK, so Maru is basically obv town to me. If you don't understand why, try treading what he posts. If it still doesn't make sense to you, slap yourself in the face three times, then ask me why, and I'll spell out for you how Maru is being the most supportive of pro-town play and showing the most opposition toward people who are showing anti-town play.
Murdercat wrote:What makes you dislike that post Ranger?
...Stuff.
I know that's a cop-out (no pun intended, given the setup) answer, but I'm actually not in the state of mind where I can answer. Just getting caught up in all of my games and going to sleep for tonight. (I'm planning on putting more attention into them over the weekend.)
SirCakez wrote:Pls do more then.
I'll do more when I feel like it. (And have energy for it, which I don't, but the feeling like it is just as important.) I currently do not.
In post 378, podoboq wrote:Karnos is pushing murdercat for looking like he's just trying to look busy.
I'm pushing murdercat for looking like he's just trying to look busy.
Murdercat says Karnos is probably town, but I'm coming up with BS reasons to push him, when Karnos and I have the same reason to push him.
There is an inconsistency there.
I don't think Murder is trying to look busy, he is getting wagoned after all...
My reads are mostly the same. Transcend has moved to my town pool for really obvtown posting over the last few pages. Maru and Podo have also moved into my townpool.
In post 793, SirCakez wrote:So Dix is Penguin and Smith's scum buddy looks like
In post 903, DixC wrote:No surprise Podo has me low, i've had him marked as scum forever.
Smith didn't go after Penguin, nor did anyone else that could have hammered Penguin.
The probability of there being two-three scum in this list is high:
podoboq,
MURDERCAT,
Transcend,
SirCakez,
Chip Butty,
Aneninen
The probability of there being one scum in this list is moderate:
PenguinPower,
Smithereens,
Ranger,
karnos,
drmyshottyizsik,
Dunnstral
In post 833, MURDERCAT wrote:That literally only makes sense if both Smith and Podo are scum and I'm willing to bet my life that at least 1 is town.
Now this is telling. Not that MurderCat is on the side of pod or smith, but that murdercat is trying to imply a discordance between he two so large that he is 100% certain.
The only way to be so certain is to 1) lie or 2) know because you are scum.
Based on what we know we should restrict our kill to someone on this list:
In post 931, SirCakez wrote:OMG
We can't hold a wagon together on anyone *facepalm*
Penguin's posting was terrible but the wagon in him dissolved for...no reason. That's a big scum tell.
Still stand by Penguin/Six/Smith scum team
I'm hammering Smith in the morning
