How do you expect to find the culprit when you're all worried about each other's feelings? If you're planning to expose a liar, then you have to corner them psychologically.
Well I'd rather have confirmed scum in 2 people than mislynching JK
How do you expect to find the culprit when you're all worried about each other's feelings? If you're planning to expose a liar, then you have to corner them psychologically.
I dont see the issue of waiting for a claim. Not like its 3 hrs left
How do you expect to find the culprit when you're all worried about each other's feelings? If you're planning to expose a liar, then you have to corner them psychologically.
Una made some weird posts for Una to be fair but I don’t like SIV either
102 posts in, already 3 town stances.
In post 133, profii wrote:Usually I can town hunt pretty easily but there is a lack of players towning it up in this game
he claims to be able to usually townhunt pretty easily, and has already taken 3 stances in that game, and yet claims “there is a lack of players towning it up”. why does it seem to me that he is not taking a similar stance in our game?
In post 142, profii wrote:I’m pretty sure I’ve been criticised in my earliest games for being seen to town hunt more than scum hunt so I find it weird that someone would expect to find a history of me doing it - I kinda assumed site meta is scum hunt or die
Anyway. TW - our only other game I think was the mafia month game where I was scum. Why do you think this is my scum game again? I think this is your paranoia game because town lost that game I mentioned
claims he is a townhunter more than a scumhunter as town
In post 151, profii wrote:Well I think Mr Otter can be town, that’s good
so I feel like maybe i was in tchills lynch pool the whole time,
koki is probably town
and tchil is adding fuel to any passing wagons to see if they go through (i.e. mafia win-con remove any town)
In post 530, profii wrote:I know that me being really weak but now the wagon has momentum let me see.
Dunn:
ruby / worst / tchil / koki / azurit / Lucky Otter.
now let's just look at some of the prev. wagons at their peaks
profii (5):
Kokichi Oma, the worst, UnaBombaH, Tchill13, SIV36
koki:
maria / profii / performer / SIV / TChill
the dunn wagon is
mostly
TRs, id say luckyotter is one of my stronger town reads maybe
My gut instinct is I don't TR Tchill and he appears on all the wagons, this is making me think 'any lynch will do for scum' sort of vibes. But again, it's quite simple, scum don't give themselves away like that.
sorting wagons and explaining why he cannot quite townread tchill.
LuckyOtter is like my biggest town read and tchill is my biggest scum read.
someone else can do it
not messing around before night phase where he is killed n1. he is messing around here however
”
my instinct is telling me profii is flipping scum here. thus, i heavily favor lynching him. little-to-no townhunting in this game = high chance of him flipping scum. need to investigate his scumgames really quickly, but i am pretty damn sure i want this lynch right now. ARONIS HOWEVER HAS BEEN TOWNHUNTING TO AN EXTENT off memory. VOTE: Profii
In post 307, GirlInFreezer wrote:What they're saying is that if you were scum there's a lot easier ways to push you and you wouldn't bother going for supplementary details which may end up not being in favor of the narrative you're pushing
But as town you would do the meta analysis
It's not the most rigorous of thinking but it makes sense
i see this now. but this argument definitely isn’t cogent enough to adapt my early stance on him. all of this is attributable to profii-scum too. i’m not thinking he’s someone we should townread right now though, and i tend to be right when i call townreads into question as town, as they typically are scum. so if i’m not following a townread someone puts out, and i call it into question as town, and they can’t back it up with a statement that changes my mind, that players has had a tendency of flipping scum.
suffice it to say, i don’t call that many townreads into serious question.
this is additional reason why we lynch him. my gut instincts here have been extremely accurate of late. i cannot fully townread profii, and have called tr’s of him into question. this has proven remarkably accurate for finding scumplayers in my recent games, even extending to a multiball scum game where i questioned a townread on creature and he was scum. in american presidents mafia, the only townread i questioned was on momrangal. she flipped scum. and this was on d1 before i replaced out of that game. this has been absurdly accurate overall of recent, and i encourage everyone to trust my gut here.
Spoiler: serious lack of town stances by profii in this game where he has taken a lot of scum stances if you look at his iso
In post 279, profii wrote:I actually like that page topping post from
Shoshin
there - It’s easy for scum to just throw out whatever narrative they want to try and get people to believe but you’ve gone meta diving to go and find the “right” narrative irrespective of what you find
In post 248, profii wrote:Stungun seems to be struggling to scum hunt but trying in their own unconventional way
Aronis declaring themselves not scum hunting is a big alarm bell
My gut feeling is Shoshin is politically moving the vote around for buddying to try and split the pack as it were
GIF seems ok but I can’t read RC well so I’m not the authority on that
Whilst inactivity is annoying - if it is scum, I guess it indicates we are not putting scum under pressure thus, but I’ll hear NSG out
I also have Kokis PM explaination in my mind that he got the reject PM which could be a scum sign
So basically everyone could be scum and you don't have any thoughts about who it is?
Well the point of that post was
stun - prob not scum
Aronis - scum read
Shoshin - scum lean (though i later retract that)
Gif - no idea right now but if you held a gun to my head I’ll go town
NSG - whilst lurking is bad, I’ll aboid reading a slot on 2 posts
Koki - scum lean
So 8 players excluding myself, I’ve offered 3 potential scum slots
I’m leaning most strongly towards Aronis
So basically everyone actually is less than half
There are other times where I would call this shade and say you are scummy for it but your meta diving is swaying me towards saying you are someone who has confidence in their convictions and when you believe in something you will lead your wagon rather than sheep someone else’s
If some other players come in with “yes this fits your meta” uncontested I’ll basically lock town you tbh despite me thinking there are flaws in your case - the intentions seem pure
In post 954, profii wrote:Like given the wagon I kinda wanna lynch Stun if it was me.
He seems to be getting some firm town reads but I’d question that - as time goes on it seems to be a more and more concerning slot
notice his focus is on discrediting my townreads, although he does not specify which of my townreads he is calling into question. nsg is in his townread pile—my heaviest townread. and shoshin is my others, so exactly what is he discrediting or calling into question here?
In post 972, profii wrote:GIF feels like someone who is trying to push me because he thinks I’m scum
Stun feels like he is trying to push me because he can get the lynch though at this point
My town flip will hopefully lead you to Stun fairly quickly but idk where 2nd scum is
Whilst Aronis seems scummy, the lynch kinda stalled whereas there seems to be momentum on me and to a degree GIF - could easily be there
I’d expect Koki and NSG to be town
Not sure in creature and Nico
I sort of think it’s best to flip me just so scum don’t know not to kill me tonight as I’m not JK.
so, in 1000 pages, there has been a definite shortage of townreads so far by profii compared to his other towngame.
