Mafiascum.net

Yay for jumping on wagons because you can't figure what the fuck is going on!

VOTE: DrippingGoofball

Amzela, how good do you think you'd be at discerning Cerb as town or scum in forum based Mafia? Hopefully you don't talk about the game outside of the game, but do you get a sense that you can read him without actually seeing him? Is your only experience with Cerb in live versions of the game?

Also... you need an avatar.

I'm caught up in the sense of having passed my eyes along all of the pages.
I have not processed all of that stuff. Certainly not in depth.

@wisdom -- because she doesn't seem to be doing anything to solve. That is a mismatch from what I remember, though the memory is quite old. Failure to solve is a good reason on d1 in any case.

I agree with the creature scumread, though with the caveat that a holiday week is not a good week to judge activity on.

Varsoon fake dayvig feels right from a playstyle point of view, probably more town than not but that's weak.
Profii is probably walking dead after the cop soft / not soft / crumb / not crumb / no that wasn't really a hardclaim thing. I still have a weak scumread there.
Alonzo is treading on too derp to be scum so maybe it is.
I really have to go now. Was supposed to stop this more than half an hour ago.

@Davesaz: Profii's a dead man after the claim and the walkback of the claim (when they realized this) solidified them as town for me.

In post 1075, Varsoon wrote:

In post 1070, Alonzo wrote:

VOTE:VARSOON

For faking day actions

Did you get any worthwhile reads out of the interactions that happened due to it?
Do you agree that me faking the vig helped us move away from the RR v DrewVa stuff which was weighing the game down?

I'v not played with either Hydra involved so It was an interesting insight into the logic of both. I got good stuff.

I found your action attention seeking, and then pointless.

In post 1151, Toogeloo wrote:Amzela, how good do you think you'd be at discerning Cerb as town or scum in forum based Mafia? Hopefully you don't talk about the game outside of the game, but do you get a sense that you can read him without actually seeing him? Is your only experience with Cerb in live versions of the game?

Also... you need an avatar.

pfft. Avatars are overrated!

Someone asked me what my read on amzela is, to which I say: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

^^ Honestly, I don't think she's faking being lost or the cute little newb that she is...and she hasn't done any of the obvious things that newbscum do, so maybe slightly more inclined to think she's town than scum, but there's very little behind that position.

-Cerb

In post 1153, Varsoon wrote:@Davesaz: Profii's a dead man after the claim and the walkback of the claim (when they realized this) solidified them as town for me.

Daves gottttttta be scum

If I was a cop...

In post 1155, Reasonably Rational wrote:

In post 1151, Toogeloo wrote:Amzela, how good do you think you'd be at discerning Cerb as town or scum in forum based Mafia? Hopefully you don't talk about the game outside of the game, but do you get a sense that you can read him without actually seeing him? Is your only experience with Cerb in live versions of the game?

Also... you need an avatar.

pfft. Avatars are overrated!

Someone asked me what my read on amzela is, to which I say: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

^^ Honestly, I don't think she's faking being lost or the cute little newb that she is...and she hasn't done any of the obvious things that newbscum do, so maybe slightly more inclined to think she's town than scum, but there's very little behind that position.

-Cerb

ive seen multiple games not lynch multiple cute little noobs just because they cute little noobs so we I’ll take anything I can get to sort her

Anyway Varsoon, now the dust has settled what did that day vig reaction test achieve for you and how/why

In post 1127, ruru wrote:

votecount

With 26 alive it takes 14 to lynch.

DrippingGoofball (6):	davesaz (56),	CheekyTeeky (992),	BrightEyedFish (1089),	RCEnigma (1098),	pinturicchio (1099),	DrewVa (1121),
RCEnigma (3):	Thor665 (61),	BuJaber (262),	Tails (477),
BuJaber (3):	DrippingGoofball (609),	Varsoon (614),	Majiffy (631),
Majiffy (3):	Malakitty (42),	Wisdom (1078),	hebichan (1083),
BrightEyedFish (1):	Alchemist21 (386),
CheekyTeeky (1):	Alonzo (440),
Chickadee (1):	Fortian (830),
Reasonably Rational (1):	profii (885),
profii (1):	Reasonably Rational (893),
Alonzo (1):	Gamma Emerald (897),
Thor665 (1):	Amzela (1044),
Creature (1):	Chickadee (1090),
Not voting (3):	Creature,	Toogeloo,	Flavor Leaf (416),

(expired on 2018-12-04 02:30:00) remain.

I'm wondering about the timing of the tailend of DGB's wagon. Possible counter to Majiffy's wagon picking up momentum. Hmm.

My thoughts when I voted. Did not stop me from voting.

I was just trolled

I could swear this was the day

In post 1158, profii wrote:Anyway Varsoon, now the dust has settled what did that day vig reaction test achieve for you and how/why

You're town and we got to move away from the lame RR v DrewVa stuff that was bogging the game down.
Other stuff too but that'll be evident D2.

In post 1084, Fortian wrote:Regfan and I think profii is probably town.

In post 947, CheekyTeeky wrote:Ok prepare to be amazed:

{Farside/Alonzo, Fortain, Profii}
{Fish, Chick, Gamma, Hebichan, Pint, RCE, Tails, Varsoon, Wisdom, RR}
{Creature, Davesaz, Malakitty}
{BuJaber, Flavorleaf, Alchemist, Majiffy, Thor}
{Amzela, DrippingGoofball, DrewVa}

Also, why are we in the top tier? I feel like our posting so far makes us a slot that's easy to "townread" when constructing a reads list, but my expectation is that town would be more likely to be a bit more skeptical. Especially given that both Regfan and I have been on the site for a long time and I don't feel we've exactly amazed here.

I skimmed a few and felt you were one of the most obvious townies in intent. I don't base my reads on level of amazement lol. I tend to make lists D1, sometimes flipping my whole list upside down so your wtf reaction helps to solidify my read there. I'll probably update it later today.

In post 1146, Wisdom wrote:how is dgb obvscum
isnt she always like thisqq

How familiar are you with DGB?

In post 1162, Creature wrote:I could swear this was the day

What day

In post 1166, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1162, Creature wrote:I could swear this was the day

What day

Going to catch up on Monday.

This is a prod dodge.

In post 1151, Toogeloo wrote:Amzela, how good do you think you'd be at discerning Cerb as town or scum in forum based Mafia? Hopefully you don't talk about the game outside of the game, but do you get a sense that you can read him without actually seeing him? Is your only experience with Cerb in live versions of the game?

Also... you need an avatar.

My experience with Mafia and Cerb is him fanboying over A50 and Varsoon's games. It's the whole reason why I decided to try things out in the first place.

With regards to how they play, however, I don't know. I feel that the Drixx v Nancy thing was very genuine, so I don't think they're on the same side. This makes me more inclined to say RR is town just because I think they'd be more focused if they were scum. I need to ISO Nancy and make my conspiracy board for who's associating with who. I need to make my case.

If they’re both town they would be on the same side and not know. Agree it’s probably not theater in the same faction.

In post 1118, DrewVa wrote:Also wouldn’t be shocked if Goofball/Majiffy/Wisdom are a team.

LOL I've made like 3 pointless posts, wanna show your calculations to the class?

In post 1142, profii wrote:VOTE: Bujaber
im gonna sheep this because it will probably help me sort BuJ and I can't put my thoughts on Wisdom into coherent sentences yet

Excellent vote.

In post 1155, Reasonably Rational wrote:pfft. Avatars are overrated!

Hey now, even you had an avi for a while!



Creature, what are your reads? I don't need a big reads list or anything, but any thoughts you have.

Ok so after digging through a few DGB games...

Town:

Mini 2020 Starts off similar to here but gets invested in sorting a few scum reads also. Intent becomes clearer as the game progresses.

Transformers Mafia Similar to here but we're again missing a "scum detected" post. Looks like DGB lurked themselves dead.

Mini 619 - House Mafia Constantly softs that they are a PR. Much more active and engaged, was the lylo mislynch.

Scum:

Steven Universe 2 Much more question orientated vs stating opinions. Phrases Town reads differently. Looks nothing like the other town games.

I think it's likely this game is more in line with DGB's town meta. I see they are often mislynched/left until lylo as town. Though we're missing the certain aggressive tunnels I saw in a couple of town games, I think the attitude of nonchalance is stil strongly town/3p indicative here.

VOTE: Thor