Open 742: C9++ (Game Over)

[Clemency]

thats unfortunate because i have today booked

Alright. I can probably lynch Clemency for this. He's been avoiding the game today, ans so has 0verki11. If I'm going to lose to scum I'd rather lose to someone who actually tries.

i'm not avoiding the game i'd just rather not be on my phone when i'm dm'ing a game of d&d for my friends

[TTTT]

@pengy- do you really think scum!TTTT buses Egix like this?
go read my scum PTs

Without even reading anything, I would like to remind you there is a SERIAL KILLER in play, and YOU had suggested it's best we leave them alone and try to lynch MAFIA today, which was what triggered me on you in the first place.

dude I'm talking to pengy here
do you mind?

[TTTT]

thats unfortunate because i have today booked

Alright. I can probably lynch Clemency for this. He's been avoiding the game today, ans so has 0verki11. If I'm going to lose to scum I'd rather lose to someone who actually tries.

i'm not avoiding the game i'd just rather not be on my phone when i'm dm'ing a game of d&d for my friends

MS > DD
ditch those nerds

[Gamma Emerald]

I'll admit I don't know why this...
4-2-1 >> Lynch Mafia >> 4-1-1 >> 2 NKs >> 2-1-1/3-0-1/3-1-0/4-0-0 (very swingy) 3 chances out of 4

is strictly worse than this...
4-2-1 >> Lynch SK >> 4-2 >> 1 NK >> 3-2-0 LyLo (solid. No ifs)

if we put expected values on each of these:
2-1-1 = 0 wins
3-0-1 = .5 wins
3-1-0 = .5 wins
4-0-0 = 1.0 wins
average = .5 wins

3-2-0 = .5 wins

I mean we could argue the expected values...
but at this point I'm out of my element

I feel like if the numbers are run objectively the odds are better if we lynch mafia, but lynching mafia creates a lot of possible outcomes while lynching SK gives us 50/50 5p LyLo into clearless 3p LyLo.

[TTTT]

bottom line we lynch the scummiest player in the game
that pengy and gnelf agree upon

[davesaz]

Votecount 3.4

Gamma Emerald(1)

~ Almost50(24)

Almost50(1)

~ TTTT(53)


Not Voting (5): Gamma Emerald(20), Gnelf(20), Clemency(11), 0verki11(1), PenguinPower(32)

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Day 3 deadline is in (expired on 2018-12-29 14:11:18)

[TTTT]

UNVOTE:

[0verki11]

Sorry, was asleep A50 is almost always scum here however due to the lack of defenders could be sk.
Assuming they flip SK that leaves TTTT, Gamma and Clem in the PoE pool, I think Clem is more likely to flip scum out of the 3 leaving TTT and Gamma for last scum, and gut tells me Gamma will flip scum over TTT

[0verki11]

if A50 flips mafia I would choose Clem as a buddy and Gamma as sk if we have one.

[TTTT]

Why is Gamma more likely scum than me from your POV?

[0verki11]

You just seem more townie than them

[PenguinPower]

What is it that makes TTTT seem more townie?

[Gnelf]

i should've faked a guilty

[Gnelf]

pp lets lynch a50

[PenguinPower]

We have time.

I'm not opposed to that (obviously given my statements in this game), but we have time. I want more from Clem and 0ver.

[Gnelf]

alternatively

if clemency is town here we lost anyways so we can lynch him too

[PenguinPower]

I kinda feel that way about either of them right now, which is why I want more.

[Gnelf]

@everyone

you have 5 sticks. Put one next to the person you think is most deserving of the stick (1 stick = more scummy)
i put one stick next to a50

Gamma Emerald - 0
Gnelf - 0
Clemency - 0
0verki11 - 0
Almost50 - 1
PenguinPower - 0
TTTT - 0

[Gnelf]

Rules for stick placement:
1) You can only put one stick at a time
2) You cannot take back a stick
3) You must wait until at least 5 other people have placed a stick before you can again
4) We will policy lynch anyone who doesn't play the stick game in a timely fashion (unless pp doesn't want to play)

[Almost50]

I could tell you where to put your stick, but I'm a shy guy.

[TTTT]

"sticks"?
so much opportunity for shitposting
but I'll play along...

HURT: Clem

[Gamma Emerald]

I guess I’ll try this, kinda cool idea but I wanna hear why this specifically when we’re done. I wanna know if this is usable in the future.

Gamma Emerald - 0
Gnelf - 0
Clemency - 1
0verki11 - 0
Almost50 - 1
TTTT - 1

Let’s just remove PP from that kthxbye

[Gnelf]

if clemency is town here we dont win

lets lynch clemency

[TTTT]

if clemency is town here we dont win

why?

[0verki11]

I feel that TTTTs more agressive enterence was towny due to that fact there wasnt really a reason for it, it seemed town motavated.