Mafiascum.net

In post 11723, Klick wrote:@SoD I'm curious what you think.

Who, silly ol me? I'm content to let discussion flow without my input.

In post 11681, Nashville Dreams wrote:SoD Vanilla
Mastina not vanilla
Cassowary not vanilla
Keeper not vanilla
Bnuuy vanilla
Menalque vanilla
Freedom not vanilla

In post 11697, Nashville Dreams wrote:

In post 11688, Freedom wrote:But a genuine Vanilla Cop would've gotten me as Vanilla.
There's no way for them to have gotten me as not one.

must have been a mod fuck up then b/c its what we got.....

as for klick can we unvote because I really don't trust people not to randomly quickelim and lose the game....

This isn't a contradiction in our result. Mala's a bit in denial about you being scum, but she never denies our feedback. I thought about not even responding but letting your implied misrepresentation stand might have Klick think it was true or we had something to hide.

I see.
Thanks, Nashville for explaining.

In post 11637, Freedom wrote:

In post 11601, Menalque wrote: I won’t vote yet in case ducks/freedom wanna respond to that

I would prefer tictac being limmed before FL.

I think there's very little reason for this as a wolf when just going for a FL vote probably just wins Freedom the game.

In post 11728, Klick wrote:

In post 11637, Freedom wrote:

In post 11601, Menalque wrote: I won’t vote yet in case ducks/freedom wanna respond to that

I would prefer tictac being limmed before FL.

I think there's very little reason for this as a wolf when just going for a FL vote probably just wins Freedom the game.

He still has one miselimination to go either way, plus you were in control at the time unquestionably. It's very easy to distance there when it wouldn't even cost a miselimination.

Nashville, may I ask you something random?
Do you think that I'll pretend to be a VT as a Werewolf PR?
Wouldn't it be easier going along with your results?

Freedom, when you read through upon replace-in, how much did you read? And how much would you say you have read since then?

Frankly I think Freedom's play also makes little sense as wolf. His reads are all over the place early upon replace-in. He has tictac/bnuuy/Menalque as his initial PoE, then quickly switches Mena to leaning town without explanation. He then has tictac/bnuuy/SoD, but goes off the SoD scumread as well before deciding he is 'misreading' Nashville. His constants are scumreads on tictac and bnuuy. I feel this would be a very strange way to play it out as scum with the information we have, but I have no issues seeing it as a town thought process.

VOTE: Nashville Dreams

I have done proper consideration of the possibility of Freedom!scum, and I don't think that's a conclusion I'm going to come to today.

In post 11731, Klick wrote:Freedom, when you read through upon replace-in, how much did you read? And how much would you say you have read since then?

Not much before. I just did a few ISOs.
I've been reading every page since though.

(~_~ )

hello

SoD, what are your reads on Nashville and me?

In post 11738, Freedom wrote:SoD, what are your reads on Nashville and me?

I don't highly trust either of you.

I see.
Though, we could risk a no-lim today.
That results in tommorrow being a 2-1 ELO.
But then, you would need to decide tommorrow, if today ends in indecision.
But then, it's your choice so no pressure.

: |

The game isn't progressing.
Still interested if you're leaning any particular direction, SoD. The longer we wait the more I start to overthink things in a way that isn't really helpful for finding out which of them it actually is.

Basically, having someone else's perspective here would be the only thing left that could give me a new helpful view of things I think.

Freedom, can you talk to me about your read on SoD as you replaced in? What were your initial thoughts on him, and why/how did they change? I want a fairly clear picture of how you read the slot over time, and what things changed your read.

In post 11744, Klick wrote:Freedom, can you talk to me about your read on SoD as you replaced in? What were your initial thoughts on him, and why/how did they change? I want a fairly clear picture of how you read the slot over time, and what things changed your read.

As I said in 11269, I trusted SoD when I repped in. I forgot what made me think that TBH.
It was your 11402 that led to me dropping SoD to a Wolf read due to my distrust of dumbtells. Then, SoD posted 11434. Their explanation on their confusion made sense to me so I moved them to Null as I said in 11435. Then, Titus scumclaimed with her faked VC results in 11681. This makes me deduce that SoD is Town.

In post 11745, Freedom wrote:As I said in 11269, I trusted SoD when I repped in. I forgot what made me think that TBH.

But this is the bit I'm most interested in! You had them as one of your four trusted players, surely there's something you can remember from your catch-up?

In post 11746, Klick wrote:

In post 11745, Freedom wrote:As I said in 11269, I trusted SoD when I repped in. I forgot what made me think that TBH.

But this is the bit I'm most interested in! You had them as one of your four trusted players, surely there's something you can remember from your catch-up?

I would be lying if I said that I remember.

Fair enough, it happens haha.