curiouskarmadog wrote:Xyl, also, (speaking of rhetorical)...anyone who has played this game more than 2-3 times has been mislynched...what a useless question used to distract...what was the point of that question and how does it have anything to do with my attack on you? Again, you misrepresent what I said. I didnt just come out and say " i am not scummy"...you asked me...
curiouskarmadog wrote:I havent analyzed my own play in this game...what is the point? i dont feel that my play has been scummy, because I am town. Everything I do is to try to catch scum....What is the point of this line of questioning?
This started with your saying "The entire damn game you constantly try to paint my play as scummy even though it is not." This is the classic OMGUS attack: "my play isn't scummy, you should know it isn't scummy, so the fact that you're attacking me for it proves you're scum". Which usually turns out to be wrong, but anyways. I was trying to figure out why you said you're not scummy; I
do
see you as scummy, as do other people. And yes, I thought your answer might help reveal your alignment.
(Just as a curiosity, I've never been mislynched in a forum game. Scum keep trying though. I'm expecting the record to fall any game now. It almost fell in Lynch All Lurkers when elvis_knits noticed I had been on every single townie bandwagon.)
curiouskarmadog wrote:but this brings up an interesting point.....all you really have said this game is ..CKD is obviously scum or some variant (speaking of assertions, hypocrite)...but you have not put forward a clear case what so ever....I request you do so...I also request for you to explain if you think I am scum, why you havent done so thus far...if you feel you have..post number please....
Hmm... you're right, I haven't made the case clearly because it's not based on things you've done so much as it's based on things you
haven't
done. Best I've said it is in
this post, where I said "CKD's behavior this game has definitely been geared towards generating suspicion and pushing lynches. Nothing he's done so far gives me a feeling he's town."
Specifically, I expect actual townies to jump out at some point in the game and say "No, I don't think X is scum, we shouldn't lynch them". Scum do too, but less, and X is often a scumbuddy. In my read I don't recall you doing that anywhere; would you like to point out some places where you did?
You were also happy to answer the "who is scummy" question but didn't answer the "whose flip surprised you" question. In fact, when I gave you a second chance you answered "nothing surprises me". It's not conclusive, but that is scummy.
In general I don't see anything that makes me think you are town, rather than scum eager to push lynches and not particularly caring on who. Everyone else in the game looks townier than you do. So you're my #1 suspect.