In post 897, morph the cat wrote:
We initially called it "obvious as fuck" and I think pie is using the term ironically (i.e., he disagrees that it was obvious as fuck).
Mac, to me, it's more about the reaction than whether the test had a perfectly sound basis. And the reaction itself has me a little conflicted. Cabd has more of a town sense because of pie's softclaim.
aah gotcha. on both points. pretty moot now since he's practically conftown.
wayne wrote:Help me understand. It's day one where we have no information. You see where I'm coming from and say I'm 90% right. And you want me to drop it in favor of the 10% where I'm wrong. How does that make sense?
I don't say you're 90% right, i said there's a 90% chance it's a liar tell but still 10% chance he's just using it as habit. 90% is probably too high, maybe 75% is more appropriate.
regardless, we're not lynching based entirely off of tells.
maaan, SSK was useless. sorry, but defending yourself from your own lynch whilst on raising fingers at others is really poor fucking play.
mastin2 wrote:For the record--I want an SSK claim, but not a lynch. (At least, not yet.) While I think he's scum, he's far from certainly-scum, and I want us to all have time to analyze his wagon from both perspectives. If he's scum, who his scumbuddies are (such as if they're bussing, and if so, who), if he's town, who the scumteam is (and how many if any are on the wagon).
have you done this yet? I'm assuming you have since you are mastin after all.
pieguy wrote:I think she's town but omfg paranoia. liking her questions and analysis of players. re: "scumslip", see above. I missed that it was a reaction test until she outright told me it was.
as did I; but why are you still paranoid when it was a reaction test?
is it just me who thought of crocodile dundee through ffery's
928? NOPE, RESPECT TO WAYNE
In post 939, pieguyn wrote:you know what
shoot: MafiaSSK
I'm a 1-shot vigilante and I have to use my shot on D1 or else I lose it. this seems like the best option
now
that's
a reaction test pulled off well.
In post 946, morph the cat wrote:Also there's a 1 in 11 chance we're going to die too from that shot, so don't mind us, we're gonna post some reads and stuff in a hurry.
what? why?
morph reads wrote:Town
pieguyn - lol dayvig. Way he went about it is legit town thought process. No way there's a scumdayvig in a mini, anyways.
Mac - Ffery's read
do you disagree, cabd?
]quote="mastin"]Though that said, morph's probably town. (The real concern is on Psychlone and GP.)[/quote]
this is true. i'm worried by the lack of presence from both in the thread.
morph wrote:Wait, but we'll use it with enough time to finish out the day. Something about the setup just clicked to me, actually. Nacho should know what I mean when I say that borkie is using the same trick andy did in red wedding regarding odds and evens.
can you expand? im trying to think but it's not coming too me about RW.
thezmon's reaction was weird. pie is claiming compulsive d1 dayvig and he's still trying to throw dirt on it. meeeh
User avatar
Joined : July 15, 2013
Post Post #1029 (ISO) ยป Fri Nov 08, 2013 11:22 pm
Mastin, cabd here.
Tell me why you can't talk to me. You had zero issue talking with me in xenogears when I was pushing your wagon. What about it being morph makes me unapproachable?
this is a very good question. echoed my thoughts a little
...and the answer wasn't really an answer.
wayne wrote:Stupid is easy to fake. Which is probably why so many people play VI...
this much is absolutely true for what it's worth. it's easy to abuse a newbcard (i did it myself in my first scum game pretty much) which is why i tend not to give them out unless im absolutely certain.
In post 1069, Mac wrote:v/la the weekend
possibly back tonight, who even knows?
lots of laughing at me thinking i'd be back on a saturday night. hooray for alcohol!
In post 1084, Varsoon wrote:Although, it was obvious from SSK's response to the fake shot that he was town.
You guys are meanies.
^scum^
VOTE: Varsoon
In post 1096, thenewearth wrote:Then why not vote me?
You think I'm scum?
You think mastin is my buddy now huh?
Here
Lemme help you in lynching me
VOTE: TNE
this is also terrible posting.
i think I could get on a GP vote. gut says there's one scum in {GP/Psy}.
i'm getting a townread off bro. seems a bit controversial, and i dunno if i could explain it or not if anyone asked.
Speaking of which, not being lazy, I looked at Mac. Who had Mac as a weak scumread, but reversed it in a sense, later defending attacks against him. It's something to look into. (Also, Mac's iso is much shorter than I remember it being, which is another concern; he's been posting much less than I thought he was, and it has me worried.)
I'm not sure who you are saying was defending me. most of my posts have been catchups, i've explained this in the thread a few times. you guys become active when i sleep
mastin's reaction to being voted was awful. then again i'm not over the moon about psychlone either. varsoon's answer to pieguy wasn't great either < thus i'm now reasonably confident of a scumflip.
does anyone remember xenogears when after the hammered had been dropped twice on scum and FTL came in and voted like they thought they were hammering? i scumread them for it in gears and i'd compare varsoon's reaction to SSK similar to FTL fakevoting in gears.
