Mafiascum.net

that's a good point about skitter; her good reads as scum are usually gamestate analytically nuanced more so than like intense gamesolvey town critical so to speak

I'd need to reread this

In post 234, The Dark Wanderer wrote: i am surprised that of all the people in this game i am the one being floated as a deep wolf.

No, honestly you shouldn't be that surprised in my opinion...
Although you feel kinda towny, to me it sounds like you're playing kind of by-the-book and being very easy on your town reads, kinda like DVa.
We keep wondering if it's genuine or not I guess.

In post 267, probs a robot wrote: I correctly townread Musicjax and thought his alignment was very obvious.

obvious is a pretty strong word... (later I read his own town case and took this with less salt)

DVa sounds sketchy but I dunno if that's really scum, it's even more straightfoward than Tesxx since I would you can argue that Tesxx was more of a ruthless type

Ray sounds kinda superficial

Robot still a hard read

middle of page 13, time for a coffee

In post 1153, Nibbui wrote:Woah, Tesxx and DRW are so scummy at least until

page 4

that it's scary

More so Tesxx, he is like, coming too strong. DRW kinda seems like scum a bit inexperienced (my opinion )

Gamma being mildly scummy

In post 1173, Nibbui wrote:I would post my impressions of other players posts but that would take too long and I don't think it is that helpful.

Have ended

page 8

and I'm this is the most important news:

I feel that DVa is trying to put her own coalition foward but without really reconsidering the people on it. It doesn't sound much like someone that is worried about the coalition failing, but more like someone that want to get create a consensus of town reading the people she indicated. I mean, part of this is every town objective but the way she goes at it seems kinda rash and unnatural. I dunno if it's because of her personality or because of her aligment though. What you yourself say about that DVa?

probs robot feels town superficially but mmmh, I think a experienced scum player can fake that with a bit of effort, yes.

Skitter is being reasonable.

Hmm these highlighted things look kinda off. They’re the same points I used for my retread do it seems imitative.

do you think scum!Nibbui is imitating your catchup?

In post 1178, the worst wrote:do you think scum!Nibbui is imitating your catchup?

Yeah

can you show me where and talk me through why?

In post 1177, Gamma Emerald wrote: Hmm these highlighted things look kinda off. They’re the same points I used for my retread do it seems imitative.

wot

Sorry Gamma I don't ever remember you doing that since I've not seen you play that much, actually, I kinda copied it from NSG some time ago when I read her games. It makes easier for you guys to follow of what I'm talking about in my posts.

Need to ask though, what would be "off" if I actually was coping you?
It's just a way to optimize catching up?

In post 1180, the worst wrote:can you show me where and talk me through why?

You saw my fucking retread, why are you playing dumb?
And it could be a way to optimize catching up, but my optimization was formed to my method of sorting posts, which was well-served by cutting the thread into 100 post chucks. I doubt you did the same method.

In post 1182, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1180, the worst wrote:can you show me where and talk me through why?

You saw my fucking retread, why are you playing dumb?
And it could be a way to optimize catching up, but my optimization was formed to my method of sorting posts, which was well-served by cutting the thread into 100 post chucks. I doubt you did the same method.

I'm saying the odds that he decided to parrot your re-read is incredibly unlikely. I was hoping you'd step back and talk me through it slowly or realise that it was exceptionally unlikely.

I know he’s not parroting my method exactly, that’d be cosmic coincidence levels of crazy
But it looks similar to the point I felt it needed discussion

here is deadline -> (expired on 2018-12-06 19:15:00)

HURT: Nibbui btw

In post 1182, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1180, the worst wrote:can you show me where and talk me through why?

You saw my fucking retread, why are you playing dumb?

???
I'm not playing dumb at all. I really have no idea what you're talking about, and there's no reason for me to lie about that as either aligment. I probably don't remember it at all.

and like, you still didn't answer me what would be "off" if I was actually using a similar method to yours ? (that you can check and see that it's more similar to NSG's)

I'm kinda...wtf...

In post 1185, schadd_ wrote:here is deadline -> (expired on 2018-12-06 19:15:00)

That's a good deadline

In post 1184, Gamma Emerald wrote:I know he’s not parroting my method exactly, that’d be cosmic coincidence levels of crazy
But it looks similar to the point I felt it needed discussion

In post 1186, Gamma Emerald wrote:HURT: Nibbui btw

This is like the kind of read I have as town when I'm severely overgamed but I'm not sure that's like.... a thing he's doing before he's reading the game organically is all... it's kinda hard to tell whether this is discrediting or really legit and left of centre

In post 1187, Nibbui wrote:

In post 1182, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1180, the worst wrote:can you show me where and talk me through why?

You saw my fucking retread, why are you playing dumb?

???
I'm not playing dumb at all. I really have no idea what you're talking about, and there's no reason for me to lie about that as either aligment. I probably don't remember it at all.

and like, you still didn't answer me what would be "off" if I was actually using a similar method to yours

to organize my catchup

? (that you can check and see that it's more similar to NSG's)

I'm kinda...wtf...

TW was playing dumb. I was trying to respond to two people at once.
And I don’t recall NSG using those numbers. It’s the numbers that struck me as odd.

I was objectively playing dumb ye but I was doing that in the hopes you'd explain yourself in more detail

In post 1190, Gamma Emerald wrote: TW was playing dumb. I was trying to respond to two people at once.
And I don’t recall NSG using those numbers. It’s the numbers that struck me as odd.

She used to use at least when catching up a lot after replacing. I can stop reading the game to go search for it but...really Gamma?

Also, you still didn't answer me what is remotely suspicious if I was to use a similar method to make my catchup more understandable?

sorry that i keep talking about not the actual game but you have no idea how much it flatters me to see someone who read my past games and took inspiration from them

In post 1192, Nibbui wrote:

In post 1190, Gamma Emerald wrote: TW was playing dumb. I was trying to respond to two people at once.
And I don’t recall NSG using those numbers. It’s the numbers that struck me as odd.

She used to use at least when catching up a lot after replacing. I can stop reading the game to go search for it but...really Gamma?

Also, you still didn't answer me what is remotely suspicious if I was to use a similar method to make my catchup more understandable?

My issue is it resembles how I was reading things in this game. Past games are irrelevant.

the replacement makes me a lot more confident that yurikojasmine was in fact scum.

i'll do another dive for associatives there i guess.

TDW insisting that people should town read remember me of myself

It's a bit town indicative to me, but maybe he is just trying to take over the some pseudo-leader position to decide who goes to the coalition and who gets lynched afterwards because I don't feel great insight or genuiness in his reads. Even his tunneling about robot doesn't seem genuine imo.

I'm probably scum reading Raya, yeah, she circles around too much for me.

It's not because Gamma critiqued me just now but I don't see him in a good light. I waited a bit to see if he engaged in the game however it's page 15 and there's very little Gamma, although DVa doesn't doubt for even one moment her read on him.

Interesting enough his outburst seems more town than scum for , I mean, is Gamma erractic enough to shade me for that as scum?

Although I need to say it's not organical.

HURT: everyone

HEAL: Northsidegal
HEAL: Nibbui

I'm wondering if I should add Skitter or Tesxx but I've become less enthusiastic about it.

TDW is kinda forming a exclusive-entry fanclub right there where you need to townread him to get in...

I feel good about NSG, not as town as I wanted her to be, but townier than the rest of the playerlist.

page 18

Anyway:
What are your reads rn Nibbui? Any posts you find important?

In post 1193, northsidegal wrote:sorry that i keep talking about not the actual game but you have no idea how much it flatters me to see someone who read my past games and took inspiration from them

not pocketing you but I like your town game

FYI I also felt like I wasn’t in the game as much as I should be around then
It’s why I decided to go back and reread