I'm still trying to figure out what makes ED a better lynch than the other lurkers
Continued absence of a read of his own
There's enough content and scum reads on active players that it doesn't make sense to be wagoning a lurker, and I'm not going to fake a read on a slot with such little content like the rest of the town seems to take solace in.
I've asked multiple people multiple times to talk to me about why ED is scum because I'm not going to be able to start brute force looking through the thread for them and have been ignored.
What is your read on ED?
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:46 am
by Flubbernugget
Also yikes isn't a foundation to lynch me on so try again
In post 735, EvilDeanius wrote:There's not alot there that I particularly dislike but there was a point where people seemed to start talking about him for lack of proper content, at which point he then switched to pushing on others who also hadn't done anything/alot. The timing just seems like a deflection to me, it seems off.
This is a good observation insofar as people pushing me for content when I don't really feel like doing things on day 1 tends to work, but I don't think it's a great reason to "gut" scumread me
Can you expand on your Vork townread (given you list him as TvT with nomnom)? That's been the basis for a good part of Dunn's iso so it would help me if you could comment on whether you see Dunn's push as townie if Vork town is one of your stronger/only reads.
Vork seems town because I feel like they would be more cautious about their pushes as scum. I don't think scum immediately attacks a miller claim in the way that they did, they just sort of let it sit for a while. They've also been very self assured of their pushes, and I think that comes with someone who cares more about lynching scum than just appearing townie.
In post 841, EvilDeanius wrote:Vork seems town because I feel like they would be more cautious about their pushes as scum. I don't think scum immediately attacks a miller claim in the way that they did, they just sort of let it sit for a while. They've also been very self assured of their pushes, and I think that comes with someone who cares more about lynching scum than just appearing townie.
Cool.
Do you have a read of Dunn?
736 asked two questions, and he chose to only answer one in 841
I asked a follow up half an hour later on Thursday and he never replied.
And the rest of his iso is a) active lurking or b) sheeping largely consensus reads
In fairness I think this was the last time he logged on to the site and
he's probably going to get replaced
(@mod?)
If people want to wait for a replacement, sure. But we have 4 days and the Replacement Queue just got nuked from [someone getting banned] so I wouldn't be holding my breath that we're going to get a replacement anytime soon.
Flubber do you want to sell us on Buj scum or something or what?
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:52 am
by Flubbernugget
Dunno. Why should Buj interest me?
Is vork being wagoned for being scummy or annoying.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:53 am
by Flubbernugget
Let me look more closely at what urap has been saying about buj
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:54 am
by ofrhz
looking for a replacement for EvilDeanius, who hasn’t picked up his prod
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:55 am
by nomnomnom
welp
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:55 am
by ofrhz
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:55 am
by Nero Cain
I could be wrong about evil D but lurker lynching isn't the worst thing in the world.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:56 am
by Flubbernugget
Got any reasons in your iso for scum reading ed, nero?
In post 1108, NerfedBuJ wrote:As for the rti thing that's just some weird shade. It's like you can't just accept I townread you you have to do something sneaky.
She plays at different times than I do and she was vla a lot this game. Also I don't force conversations. I don't have a way to really explain why you're town to me. I've slso not given this game that much attention. My motivation fluctuates. Especislly when I don't feel my reads changing at all despite other people not agreeing. Like we're definitely at an impasse as town and so the importance of lynching right day 1 becomes significantly less. We just need info at this point to change it up a little have people say new things.
Like, this is a scum motivation masked by makeup and cheap perfumes
This seems too easy which normally wouldn't make me skeptical, but buj is always scummy iirc
I had a lot of issues being sble to actually focus on what was actually being said in the thread when I caught up due to a bunch of IRL stress. I'm missing obvious things but trying to read it all again isn't fixing that
This wasn't a challenge. It was a "say yes and Ill make the time to look through your ISO"
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 11:04 am
by Nero Cain
I was calling ED town. I'm just tired of s1 and lynching a lurker s1 isn't the worlds worst thing.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 11:05 am
by Nero Cain
kinda funny 2 me that this is who I've been calling scum and they are all pushing the same wagon.
In post 1100, ofrhz wrote:EvilDeanius (3): Detective Pikachu, u r a person 2, teacher
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 11:14 am
by Flubbernugget
@urap
I don't see anything wrong with buj's reads list, he looks like he's trying to solve the game, and I've been calling out the fact that this game is apathy lynching several times and yet it's only concerning when buj does the same thing but with more words?
This selective scum read thing this town likes to do needs to stop.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 11:15 am
by Flubbernugget
Actually, you're cherry picking posts to scum read me too
oh wow, this really does seem to be a thing; i'd forgotten, sorry
ok
couple of follow-up questions:
a) i noticed that urap was in a bunch of games with you - what's his read accuracy on you like?
b) this might be a weird question - why do u think u died so often fairly early on in newbie games?
This isnt a reaction that comes from scum i think?
Skitter, do you have much experience with flubber? I've interacted with him more outside of mafia games than in. I don't even know if we've played together before, but this fits with my personality read on him. I think he can make this post as either alignment
and he kind of has to after that post I yikes'd lol
a bit, not that much.
he's kinda lynch-bait-y sometimes imo
but like idk if he's scum i'm not sure what he's doing here really
also i don't feel like scum!him asks to be wagoned
