3d20 – The Great Board Game War [GAME OVER]

[Gamma Emerald]

okay

[Gamma Emerald]

way to go on the pagetop, me

[Dwlee99]

If cult doesn't exist gamma is just some other evil role.

[Marashu]

could we stop using the words "if cult doesn't exist"? Especially this close to deadline.

[Dragon of the West]

If there is a cult it isn't gamma

There is no if it was rolled.

what is this trying to say

Mega claimed their initial roll was a cult bus driver. That is why, in general, people think there's probably a cult in the game. The main scenario where there isn't a cult is if mega lied about their initial roll to lead us to hunting a cult that doesn't exist. No way mega outs the cult roll of they themselves are cult, so your slot isn't cult. With the assumptions that mega didn't lie and the cult portion of their roll wasn't fudged (which I don't think it would be given the setup specs), there's a cult

[Cook]

@mod

I didn't see it in the rules, if we hit deadline, is there no elimination, or does the person with the most votes get eliminated?

Resolves with no elimination.

[Marashu]

Thanks.

I'm willing to consolidate onto James or Cakez, since either is better than no elim. VOTE: SirCakez

[Marashu]

PS Kyouko please come back I want to hear from you before the day ends

[redtea]

I'm consolidating stuff rn, but I wanted to drop this real quick
VOTE: gamma
bc if we can't get cyrus on the chopping block, i can live with offing gamma

[Dwlee99]

Cakez can you claim

[T3]

VOTE: vegan cake

[Dragon of the West]

I don't really get the Cakez reads beyond the fact that they haven't been very engaged with the game

[redtea]

^same but i think you're saying this as scum

[redtea]

Spoiler: @Dragon

Dragon 1051
LOVE how you posted this without mentioning my response of "i'm not expanding on it lol that's too much work, i'm surprised i meta'd so much at all," where Iithen proceeded to talk a little bit about what i got out of it regardless. There may or may not have been (a) separate post(s) where I also went into what i got out of meta-ing cyrus.
BASICALLY, what I wanted was, if Dragon wanted to bother, he read the linked threads and see if we got the same "vibe". Because I am not erudite/experienced/focused enough person to explain what I was picking up on concisely, and- lemme tell you- I am

shite

at essays.

I'm assuming I'm off about the no lim thing but I'm interested to hear what people think about it.

"assuming I'm off," what do you mean here exactly?

Spoiler: @Gamma

What are the other examples of redtea meta reads this game? Based how you explained it it’s happened a few times up to now

partway through the game, because cyrus Became Relevant, there was the thought of "so... is he just like this or...?" And similar deal for James (who has since asked we don't use his meta against him). So I dug into it, and then ended up briefly reviewing pretty much everyone.

Besides, I have posted plenty besides that. And while most are questions, yes, it's not like there's nothing for him to go on/interact with in regards to me. So honestly, either he's being careless af, people like me weigh heavily scum for him, or... he's scum. And to be honest, I'd bet on the last, mostly based on his push on me. He's cherrypicking, regardless.

The first post in that spoiler is probably the biggest red flag by being vague conclusions with little backing evidence

if you give my meta a skim, you'll see I spoiler shit all the time to avoid clogging up threads- like linking posts.
I've been doing it since 2015. Letting Dragon do all this heavy-lifting for you is A Sign.

Okay nah I don’t think that’s entirely genuine from redtea
The Cyrus case feels a bit like trying to fit cyrus’ play into the mold redtea want it to fit in
VOTE: Redtea

...so you read those games did you?

Also want to note that Dragon's cyrus read, or lack thereof (iirc), is also based in meta. "He's too out there, there's no point trying to sort him." So my meta-ing was a direct challenge to that. And seeing how he's taken it.... I would not be the littlest bit surprised if they were partners. Not at all.
(update:It looks like it's not happening today at least, but I still want to include this comment: Seriously, if I get limmed, do

not

skim over Dragon. Gamma and Cyrus too.)

---

What's wrong with my Robert progression?

feels like your initial townfeels on him or whatever caused you to resist were just for show

didn't he only say he didn't think he was cult?
I mean I kind of feel similar about him instantly gunning for robert once kyouko explained her thinking to him. Isolated it's not AI, but against the backdrop of his overall play it's... weird.

[redtea]

Spoiler: @Robert M

redtea posts a lot of nonsense and asks questions without follow ups, especially recent posting but his earlier posting is solid and legit, he's probably pushed by scum. Thor is the worst and some of his posts have a cult feel. His role is interesting, he doesn't know how to use it, we probably should eliminate him today for that etc. The wording here "If you want to vote me out because you think scum will recruit me" really pings me because he says scum instead of cult. It's a sign of deception.

VOTE: Thor

i say the following whether town or scum: day 1 I don't have solid leads or conclusions. It's all soup in my head. I'm asking things to figure shit out later. A itty bitty tiny bit is starting to coalesce, but don't push me to share.
I also do follow up, and hound people when they don't answer me (if i remember i asked something lol).
Like I like the effort here, but.

"he's probably pushed by scum"
what does this mean though? I was pushed by scummates at the beginning?

Spoiler: @Nero Cain

what makes you think kyouko isn't deepwolfing as cult?

Didn't you think that SSBM was uber townie?

from possibly my first post about her, I've been thinking, she's either town or non-factional

tbh gamma always feels like scum. His play seems similarish enough to LN 235 that I'm not so gung ho about Gamma being scum this game.

I only kinda remember maybe playing a game with him before, but I didn't get that impression. And I usually remember those kinds of players.

#1105
fair
well i don't know if it's gonna help my case now, but my "wouldn't you like to know" post was mostly because I 1) was not going to vote you today, unless a wagon sprang up on you and there was a chance it could get hammered, and 2) I didn't feel like going back to check the context

[redtea]

Thor #1090
in response to 3, I believe the thought is, "he says scum instead of cult to try to exclude the word "cult" from people's minds, because he is, in fact, cult." The thing is is that, as your first point says, you've been talking a lot about it non-discretely, so it all completely cancels out.

#1091
This is probably true, but personally I can't use it to say it makes him scum, atp.

also, I gotta say I didn't see your claim coming.

[redtea]

Have you played with redtea before? This is the first time I've played with them so I'm afraid I'm reading into their play wrong

and to the left you can see scum covering his ass with the classic "maybe im wrong tho :/"
(update: this was the point in my catching-up I thought scum might be successful in pushing my elim. I believe that is what Dragon was planning for here with this post)

[redtea]

If there is a cult it isn't gamma

true facts

[redtea]

*disappears back into the aether*

[Dragon of the West]

@redtea - I literally just went through your ISO and quoted the first handful of meta related quotes I found to give examples. And tbh I didn't like that it swayed gamma so easily.
Also, I told you I wasn't going to metadive. Me asking you what AI stuff you got from your meta reads was about me getting a better read on you and the legitimacy of your reads/metadives.
The "assuming I'm off" was me saying that I'm guessing I'm wrong that a no lim could be a good play for D1. I think that might of been an extension of a thought from my post before that one

[T3]

Cakez is just being scummy tbh

[cyrus62]

Win lose or draw I want cooks to do this setup again but next time every keeps what they roll lol.

[Dragon of the West]

Have you played with redtea before? This is the first time I've played with them so I'm afraid I'm reading into their play wrong

and to the left you can see scum covering his ass with the classic "maybe im wrong tho :/"
(update: this was the point in my catching-up I thought scum might be successful in pushing my elim. I believe that is what Dragon was planning for here with this post)

Nah, I'm just not sure of people's alignments before they flip because I'm town. And this being our first game together means I have no basis for how you tend to play so reading you D1 is that much harder. I'm trash at D1 reads in general and I don't understand how people tend to be so overly confident of reads this early in a game

[T3]

Really demotivated

[cyrus62]

Have you played with redtea before? This is the first time I've played with them so I'm afraid I'm reading into their play wrong

and to the left you can see scum covering his ass with the classic "maybe im wrong tho :/"
(update: this was the point in my catching-up I thought scum might be successful in pushing my elim. I believe that is what Dragon was planning for here with this post)

Nah, I'm just not sure of people's alignments before they flip because I'm town. And this being our first game together means I have no basis for how you tend to play so reading you D1 is that much harder. I'm trash at D1 reads in general and I don't understand how people tend to be so overly confident of reads this early in a game

Most is it is fake I think. Like I said my is only hunches not reads.