I needed to take a step back and look over the game again and make sure I wasn't letting anyone slip through the cracks. Here's what I came back with:
1.
CSL
- CSL is coasting, a quick ISO of him revealed that he was all over the Palisade wagon without posting any reasoning, and then he flipflopped between who to save once he was in the ring with Oversoul, and then AFTER he was dead, CSL claimed that "I never felt that Palisade was town until he started posting walls," in spite of the fact that it was his own switching of votes that saved Oversoul at the last second when he was one vote away from being killed, prompting CooLDoG to hammer.
4.
zMuffinMan
- muffin and I have had a lot of the same trains of thought so far this game, so I have a hard time seeing him as scum. He's been one of the few voices of reason in this game. I'm still keeping an eye on him, though.
8.
Nachomamma8
- His first post after replacing actually contained a really good point: "IS is not IS, which is sad, but means we'll probably get more done. We gotta wait until I build up some towncred first though because he'll just beat whoever he's up against into a bloody pulp regardless of alignment." This occurred before the IS suspicion, and I think it's a really decent point that IS hasn't felt like himself so far this game. He hasn't been acting like town-IS at all. Getting back to Nacho, though, his ISO shows a lot of insightful posts, to the extent that I wouldn't expect from scum. He feels very genuine, and I'm inclined to place him in the town category. However, I'm still not entirely sure why he's voting for me, as he hasn't expressed any suspicions for me so far.
9.
Darox
- I'm having a hard time naming one protown thing that Darox has done this game. On the other hand, other than being completely retarded about Palisade, he hasn't done much in the way of anti-town shit either. His suspect list today is meh, and most of his ISO is meh. So that's my conclusion: meh. He needs to make a great effort and stop being an idiot if he's going to fall into the town category.
10.
GreyICE
- I think springlullaby was probably telling the truth, so I'm willing to let GreyICE skate for now. He needs to give us some real content, though.
13.
The Fonz
- The first thing I notice in The Fonz's ISO is that he was majorly pushing to out BL's full role when she claimed miller. He not only picked up on the fact that she was a power role, but he used that to try and get her to claim unnecessarily. It makes me think she was a scumkill. Additionally, he was all over the Palisade wagon, which is a second strike. Third strike will put him at the top of my scumlist.
15.
kiwieagle
- kiwieagle has just been pretty much retarded all game. He's like Darox-light, cuz he doesn't even pretend to give us content either. Useless != Scum, though.
16.
Internet Stranger
- I've said all I can say on IS at this point. He's scummy as fuck and hasn't been himself.
17.
Bogre
- Was with me on the Palisade read, but hasn't really done much else other than go after Oversoul and kiwieagle. If we do have a white knight out here, it's probably Bogre. Not enough evidence to do anything about it yet, though.
18.
Toogeloo
- I don't really know what to think of Toogeloo. He doesn't seem to understand why Palisade was town, but at the same time, a lot of his early posts felt genuine and looked like he put a lot of effort into them. I'm going to go out on a limb and say he's town.
19.
Amrun
- Half-confirmed town, scummy as fuck. We'll come back to her when we know more about the setup.
20.
Magister Ludi
- Didn't do anything of substance other than tunnel on Palisade all game. Unfortunately, my gut now tells me that he was one of the few who actually let their bloodlust for mastin get away from them and didn't pay attention to anything Palisade was actually saying. If Ludi is really town, he needs to give us some better content. The call on IS is good, but I want some more in-depth looks at the other players from Ludi.
24.
Nero Cain
- Skated by until today on next to no content, was one of the people who said we should throw Palisade in the ring because it doesn't matter who goes up against Oversoul since he's going to die anyway (which backfired and was what we were trying to warn you guys about). Now today all of a sudden he turns on the afterburners and starts attacking people. Not seeing anything good from this player slot.
25.
Oversoul
- The gambit seemed real, I'm willing to let this alone for now. I don't really know why he was in the ring to begin with, but I just don't have a read on him.
tl;dr -
Scumny:
CSL
The Fonz
IS
Nero Cain
Undecided:
Darox
kiwieagle
Bogre
Amrun
Magister Ludi
Oversoul
Town:
zMuffinMan
Nachomamma8
GreyICE
Toogeloo
Man, I really hate the people I have to be town with this game.
such a drag.
