Mafiascum.net

In post 1194, Io wrote:Vedrith probably isn't scum though.

Why?

In post 1200, Skelda wrote:

In post 1194, Io wrote:Vedrith probably isn't scum though.

Why?

You know I make longer posts less often so I don't have to repeat myself.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p8301283

I also think V's town. I think Skelda is one scum now, I don't know who the other could be.

Guess it's time for...
BS'd reads list #4(?)

{BlackStar}
{Naomi-Tan}
{Creature, Io}
{V}
{Seraphim, KTS, Blitz}
gap
{Skelda}

Gun to head I'm gonna say Blitz since the only reason my initial suspicions on them have been voided out are due to her being a complete and utter dunce.

I just thought about it

KTS-Skelda doesn't make sense due to interactions that I don't think wre forced.

Seraphim started out towny, extremely towny but might be skating on towncred.

Would bet a sum of money that it's Blitz-Skelda though.

And yes I am treating BlackStar as confirmed town hence why he's in the top tier by himself.

In post 1155, Killthestory wrote:hey creature what happened to me being scum?

Did your team tell you to push someone else?

In post 1169, Killthestory wrote:

In post 1168, Creature wrote:I want to flip Vedith, he'll give us a bunch of info even if he flips town.

okay

VOTE: Vedith

Just came across this string of posts.

This is a contradiction i.e. him fosing Creature then voting with Creature.

But since he's KTS and has an overall "IDGAF" play, I'm gonna have to just put that on watch for now. Any other person and I'd probably be tunneling them into next Thursday.

I don't know who to trust anymore. I keep getting this feeling that someone I townread is probably Mafia and I'm not sure who it is. I hate when you have those games where someone was Mafia and you never suspected them.

I hate when I get the scumteam PoE'd but someone's like "Nah, X is pretty much town"

I'm almost certain about the people in the first two tiers and I'm gonna say 90% certain about the third tier people being town.

There should probably be a moderate sized gap in between tier 3 and tier 4 btw.

At least at these I agree.

PoE:
Vedith
Seraphim
Killthestory
Blitzkrieg
Skelda

That's a very safe pool of 5 imo.

I'd start PoEing with Skelda.

Sure, if we have BlackStar to shoot Skelda, we'll be:
5 townblock vs 4 non-townblock

That's kinda where I'm at right now

Skelda + Vedith is possible but he's my best non bloc TR.

Skelda + KTS seems least likely based on interactions.

Skelda + Sera is possible as said before but Sera had a very towny beginning

Skelda + Blitz is very plausible to me

In all honesty though I'm super down with having a bloc of 4 people who post one liners and 1 person who writes novels in every post lol.

In post 1213, Creature wrote:I'd start PoEing with Skelda.

I think one of Vedith, sera or blitz is more likely to be scum

Is there a town-aligned roleblocker?

In post 1218, Creature wrote:Is there a town-aligned roleblocker?

Why would we know this?

Honestly I would put Verdith at the very absolute bottom. He is so unlikely to be scum it's not worth putting him at the highest scum tier. Plus you're scum reading him for the same reason people are town reading you so like it's just a double standard at that point.
I could do a Skelda or Kill today. Kill is just off this game which is why I am voting him.

Io do you think Skelda and KTS can be a possible scum team?

how am I off this game lol?

also transcend pressure is a thing lol

In post 1220, Transcend wrote:Io do you think Skelda and KTS can be a possible scum team?

Probably not. I think one is scum, more leaning to Kill being the scum though.
If Skelda is scum Kill and Blitz wouldn't be on the scum team just because of Skelda's early tunnel on them.

But KTC was also at the top of Light's town reads. Kill hadn't really done anything at that point so it's free town read for no real reason.
Blitz was also a decent scum read by Light aw well, so that's why I don't see Blitz as the most likely scum.

Really if Skelda is scum I would guess you or Naomi would be scum with them. Probably Naomi.

Just paranoid that Naomi didn't write romances on Mini 1820.