Page 49 of 70
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 1:58 am
by Wake1
In post 1199, alimdia wrote:The only reason I thought wake is town was because he was the counter-wagon to Looker, but even Looker didn't want to vote Wake and looker instead tried to counterwagon on someone else.
Plus his JK claim. FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
You do realize I first voted for him and pushed his wagon.
Do you really think I would hardbus my partner if it were just two of us?
Tell me again how that's worth it.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 1:59 am
by alimdia
You may have voted looker first but you never helped me after that. I'm pretty sure I made the majority of the case and asked more people to hop on...
If you were looker's partner I wouldn't even call that a bus
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 2:15 am
by Wake1
In post 1201, alimdia wrote:You may have voted looker first but you never helped me after that. I'm pretty sure I made the majority of the case and asked more people to hop on...
If you were looker's partner I wouldn't even call that a bus
That's irrelevant.
If I were Scum do you honestly think I'd initiate the wagon on my partner and just let it happen? And as you know I HATE Day 1, which is exactly why I wasn't engaged with the game. THAT is my general meta.
Your argument may as well apply to you, and you being the partner getting rid of him, and your actions would be considered bussing.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:16 am
by profii
If you have an established meta that you can quote, that just makes it more probable that when you roll scum you would try to play consciously how you think town!wake plays - if anything that's a negative argument.
As for bussing, you voted for Elbirn today, who voted for looker on day 1 and managed to get off the wagon before it went through so it's fair to say someone you thought was scum#2 bussed scum#1 during day 1 but managed to get off the wagon so I dont think that argument holds any weight either.
i will be looking at Salad's posts though, that's an interesting point by Plank.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:26 am
by profii
In post 1190, alimdia wrote:I only claimed because I was a little dubious about Wake's claim. so I guess here is my full claim.
I am Town Night 3 doctor. To have a JK and a doctor on the same night? idk I was suspicious, so I pushed wake really hard about his claim.
I protected Elbirn last night. I am not notified if my ability failed or not (I asked the mod)
My breadcrumb on Day 2 when I saw that nobody died:
In post 805, alimdia wrote:Alright guys, I'm posting all my reads now, partly because if there isn't actually a
doctor
out there, I won't make it til Day orl
Night 3
. If there is, please protect me again.
I specifically said Night 3 when it should really be Day 3 in order to crumb. I said the no doctor part to crumb and WIFOM scum.
When I saw nobody died, my first assumption was that there was
Night 1 doctor, Night 2 doctor and Night 3 doctor. That was quickly proven wrong when Vorkuta flipped however.
If we think its possible to have a night 3 loyal JK and doctor, then I'll look at saladman as mentioned when I am free.
haha well this made things easy for me, I went looking for breadcrumbs in your ISO and somehow I missed this post.
I can actually feasibly see a town JK and a town doc (both n3) in a game to try and weaken their powers - e.g.
we got no kill last night - you said you protected Elbirn, so does that make Elbirn town? no - because we have a JK, who loyal/jailed me - so does that mean Elbirn tried to shoot me? Does that mean Scum tried to shoot elbirn or me?
We can't narrow it down so whilst we got the advantage of no NK, we dont clear anyone.
it actually adds up if you want my take on setup spec.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:44 am
by Wake1
I think the worst part about this game is that it makes you FEEL paranoid and see Scum in pretty much everyone. That's what I'm dealing with right now.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 6:52 am
by Elbirn
Theres no world in which theres a N3 Doctor and a N3 Jailkeeper
I also expect wake is the only person here who would no kill every night as scum
So I'm just gonna sit here
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 7:00 am
by Wake1
In post 1206, Elbirn wrote:Theres no world in which theres a N3 Doctor and a N3 Jailkeeper
I also expect wake is the only person here who would no kill every night as scum
So I'm just gonna sit here
You're gonna eat these words post-game, Elbirn.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 7:55 am
by profii
In post 1206, Elbirn wrote:Theres no world in which theres a N3 Doctor and a N3 Jailkeeper
I also expect wake is the only person here who would no kill every night as scum
So I'm just gonna sit here
This is where I get really confused because in my head it makes sense but... the amount of times I'm right on setup spec = approx 0
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 7:57 am
by Elements
In post 1193, alimdia wrote:That being said, do unvote Wake so theres no fast hammers and what not. And also so we can scrutinize more people
Why are you so placid towards the second N3 protective role?
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 8:22 am
by Eve
In post 1206, Elbirn wrote:Theres no world in which theres a N3 Doctor and a N3 Jailkeeper
I also expect wake is the only person here who would no kill every night as scum
So I'm just gonna sit here
How are you so sure of that? Suspicious suspicious very suspicious
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 8:24 am
by Eve
In post 1201, alimdia wrote:You may have voted looker first but you never helped me after that. I'm pretty sure I made the majority of the case and asked more people to hop on...
If you were looker's partner I wouldn't even call that a bus
How many games have you won in that town 100% win rate stat? Doesn't that mean you're a safe lynch since even if you flip town we'll probably still win? I see a strategy
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 8:26 am
by Eve
I think scum could be storing up kills and then release them all at once on a future night
There's a role for that but not sure if it's Normal
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 8:30 am
by Wake1
In post 1212, Eve wrote:I think scum could be storing up kills and then release them all at once on a future night
There's a role for that but not sure if it's Normal
It's not.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 9:53 am
by profii
I guess there is a way of looking at this as
Doctor = protective
Loyal JK = can only protect and potentially nerf another PR
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 11:53 am
by Elbirn
In post 1208, profii wrote: In post 1206, Elbirn wrote:Theres no world in which theres a N3 Doctor and a N3 Jailkeeper
I also expect wake is the only person here who would no kill every night as scum
So I'm just gonna sit here
This is where I get really confused because in my head it makes sense but... the amount of times I'm right on setup spec = approx 0
Well I look at it like this, both roles do essentially the same thing. A jailkeeper is just a doctor that also roleblocks. I'd be dubious if both of them were claimed in the same setup. I am especially dubious considering they both have a N3 modifier. And I think that if scum had a roleblocker, fake claiming jailkeeper makes sense.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 11:57 am
by Elbirn
Did mod announce if scum can multitask? That could explain all the no kills
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 12:51 pm
by profii
In post 1215, Elbirn wrote: In post 1208, profii wrote: In post 1206, Elbirn wrote:Theres no world in which theres a N3 Doctor and a N3 Jailkeeper
I also expect wake is the only person here who would no kill every night as scum
So I'm just gonna sit here
This is where I get really confused because in my head it makes sense but... the amount of times I'm right on setup spec = approx 0
Well I look at it like this, both roles do essentially the same thing. A jailkeeper is just a doctor that also roleblocks. I'd be dubious if both of them were claimed in the same setup. I am especially dubious considering they both have a N3 modifier. And I think that if scum had a roleblocker, fake claiming jailkeeper makes sense.
yeah I get it, I'd vote wake to clear it up to be honest
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 12:52 pm
by profii
In post 1216, Elbirn wrote:Did mod announce if scum can multitask? That could explain all the no kills
First flip was multitasking in the role
So maybe the 2nd isn't
Seems low power for a 2 man team
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 2:05 pm
by Elbirn
In post 1218, profii wrote: In post 1216, Elbirn wrote:Did mod announce if scum can multitask? That could explain all the no kills
First flip was multitasking in the role
So maybe the 2nd isn't
Seems low power for a 2 man team
That must be what I was thinking of, thank you. So...if the 2nd scum can multi-task it's because of their role, not explicitly as a part of the setup. Having two scum both of whom have a multi-task modifier would be pointless, you'd just make that part of the setup. So it seems reasonable to deduce that 2nd scum can't multitask. I'm sorry I said multitask so many times. Multitask.
Given that deduction and that there have been no kills, scum must have an action they consider more valuable than a killing power. Rolecop has already flipped. Roleblocker....could be it. Hm.
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 2:10 pm
by alimdia
In post 1209, Elements wrote: In post 1193, alimdia wrote:That being said, do unvote Wake so theres no fast hammers and what not. And also so we can scrutinize more people
Why are you so placid towards the second N3 protective role?
Because I don't want another quick-lynch, and the only reason I have for being suspicious of wake is because of his claim, and the way he forgot the loyal modifier in his initial claim.
In post 1211, Eve wrote: In post 1201, alimdia wrote:You may have voted looker first but you never helped me after that. I'm pretty sure I made the majority of the case and asked more people to hop on...
If you were looker's partner I wouldn't even call that a bus
How many games have you won in that town 100% win rate stat? Doesn't that mean you're a safe lynch since even if you flip town we'll probably still win? I see a strategy
I re-read this multiple times and have 0 idea what you're talking about. You're not that much better than Zote the unMighty
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 2:36 pm
by Elbirn
Are you people gonna make me case wake?
I was hoping it would be really obvious to you all and I wouldn't have to, writing lots of words is not my forte
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 2:39 pm
by alimdia
Case please
otherwise I'm prob doing eve or saladman
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 2:54 pm
by Elbirn
Okay I'll make you a deal
I'll do my best Elbirn-effort to summarize why its Wake if you can summarize why you suspect eve/salad. You may have already done so elsewhere but uhh I don't remember and I suck. Anyway if we do that we can compare notes and through the power of giving a damn we can actually solve the game instead of speed lynching people one two three break
Posted: Mon Dec 02, 2019 5:14 pm
by alimdia
Deal er...
You're not scum right?