Mafiascum.net

In post 787, skitter30 wrote:Just to summarize where i'm at:

Town: uncrowned,
Town-ish: ss, peta, penguin, infinity
Idk: jv, pine, hoopla, dunn, tgp
Scum-ish: dgb, dave
Scum: lilith

Pretty similar to this but i'm gonna bump lilith up to the 'idk' tier
And maybe hoopla down to scum-ish

@mena

In post 1198, Uncrowned wrote:

In post 1115, Menalque wrote:it's mostly the incongruence of skitter defending a slot I think is VERY scummy whenever anyone has raised that when I would expect her to be calling the things out that I'm seeing and not defusing pressure there

Do you think this is just a feature of her playstyle or something she actively does as scum? This is the same kind of thing I brought up about her when JV was under suspicion.

Also hi!

Again this isnt a thing i actually do as scum outside of like newbie games

In post 1193, Menalque wrote:

In post 1190, petapan wrote:i dont know who i scumread

infinity

i'm not feeling it but might sheep anyway absent strong feelings

In post 1196, skitter30 wrote:I havent played with like half the pl and most of the older players dont know me

you have a slaxx quote in your sig so you can't be bad people

In post 1198, Uncrowned wrote:

In post 1115, Menalque wrote:it's mostly the incongruence of skitter defending a slot I think is VERY scummy whenever anyone has raised that when I would expect her to be calling the things out that I'm seeing and not defusing pressure there

Do you think this is just a feature of her playstyle or something she actively does as scum? This is the same kind of thing I brought up about her when JV was under suspicion.

Also hi!

Ehhhh I think if skitt!town which is how I’m playing it atm, she sometimes sees things in people that I don’t and gets to TRs where I can’t

Equally, I have sometimes trusted her a little bit too much > trusting my own reads, so I’m trying to find a balance

I’m not sure that she white knights VTs or defends buddies as a tule and think it’s very much situational. I think both scum and town skitt will defuse wagons on buddies or on townies depending on if she thinks it will benefit her in the long run, but I don’t have enough handle on the gamestate yet to say if I could see that happening here, and I also don’t really scumresd her

Hi back! It’s been a while! I think you’re very town, how do you feel about that?

He came back for a few months like a year ago
Cool dude, twas a fun game!

Mena do u actually townread me now or is it a day1 townread, out of curiosity

In post 1200, skitter30 wrote:

In post 787, skitter30 wrote:Just to summarize where i'm at:

Town: uncrowned,
Town-ish: ss, peta, penguin, infinity
Idk: jv, pine, hoopla, dunn, tgp
Scum-ish: dgb, dave
Scum: lilith

Pretty similar to this but i'm gonna bump lilith up to the 'idk' tier
And maybe hoopla down to scum-ish

@mena

Why down on hoopla? Hoopla seems to be getting like, a reasonable amount of pressure but I’m not seeing the scum there myself, I thought that tonally + effort they made was +town

Idk they feel a bit below null to me now

In post 1207, skitter30 wrote:Mena do u actually townread me now or is it a day1 townread, out of curiosity

Little of column A, little of column B?

As always I have no real interest in pushing you or guillotining you D1 and think it will be more productive to TR you.

I also broadly agree with you (if you check out my updated readslist it’s not a million miles from yours) but there are things giving me pause that I’m not sure I get, one being infinity’s placement in your reads

Why are dunn and Dave scum-ish?

Why isn’t S_S higher?

[tinfoilhat]Mena and skitter are scum together and we’re all going to die[/tinfoilhat]

Still hasn’t happened and I long for the day

Oh sorry ss should be higher too, he's townier now then he was then. Now quite as townie as uncrowned

Dave is making kinda oppurtunistic votes, and is kinda like watching this game from a sort of meta/birds-eye view perspective but isnt trying to actively solve himself really imo
Dunn's reasoning for pushing me was meh

Okay, it’s 2:35 and I have a full day of uh

Activities

Planned for tomorrow so I’m gonna try to sleep!

Catch you all soon

*not quite as townie as uncrowned

In post 1212, PenguinPower wrote:[tinfoilhat]Mena and skitter are scum together and we’re all going to die[/tinfoilhat]

One day!

Night mena!

Last thought is that Dave could be scum but I think I always scumresd him so I’m a little mistrustful of my judgement there

In post 1206, skitter30 wrote:He came back for a few months like a year ago
Cool dude, twas a fun game!

haven't talked with him forever but we were cool back in the day

Mena you are not going to ignore me after you made me start tryharding

In post 1205, Menalque wrote:

In post 1198, Uncrowned wrote:

In post 1115, Menalque wrote:it's mostly the incongruence of skitter defending a slot I think is VERY scummy whenever anyone has raised that when I would expect her to be calling the things out that I'm seeing and not defusing pressure there

Do you think this is just a feature of her playstyle or something she actively does as scum? This is the same kind of thing I brought up about her when JV was under suspicion.

Also hi!

Ehhhh I think if skitt!town which is how I’m playing it atm, she sometimes sees things in people that I don’t and gets to TRs where I can’t

Equally, I have sometimes trusted her a little bit too much > trusting my own reads, so I’m trying to find a balance

I’m not sure that she white knights VTs or defends buddies as a tule and think it’s very much situational. I think both scum and town skitt will defuse wagons on buddies or on townies depending on if she thinks it will benefit her in the long run, but I don’t have enough handle on the gamestate yet to say if I could see that happening here, and I also don’t really scumresd her

Hi back! It’s been a while! I think you’re very town, how do you feel about that?

That makes sense, I think I've said this but her and S_S *seem* to be playing from very reasonable perspectives that I think come from town more often than not. From my brief knowledge of Skit I doubt I'd be able to read her accurately anyway until more info had come out?

I've only skimmed your posting and want to give it a more thorough read when I'm done with this assignment lol

As for your read, I don't know. I feel like it's an easy read to make given the state of everyone's reads and the fact that I think for anyone who has brief game experience with me, they'll know I've pretty much townspewed this game lmao

Also ngl I feel like some of the stuff you've accused Infinity of could be said for me as well. I've asked a bunch of questions that sometimes don't seem like they're going anywhere, but like what Infinity said, it's how I also gather info and come to conclusions. I find it a bit interesting at least that you haven't called me out for the same thing, unless you think my play has just been that townie?

@Skit your read on Dave gives me a lot more confidence in my own of him since I've thought much of the same

plus maybe I'm a lil peeved at being called a non-logical LMAO

Skit where are you at on preferring a DGB vs. Lilith lynch atm?