Mini 2186: Pokemon Battles [GAME OVER]

[Infinity Zero]

why raya, and why not titus?

i had titus as town because the way she handled her claim felt pro-town, plus her push on perfume felt internally consistent

i also liked her vote on vax

Tbf I had Titus in my lower TR tier
But I felt like townbinning her was too much atp
Meanwhile Raya’s Vax vote was one Infinity quickly pegged as town and I felt good about her contributions from what I read. So if you liked Titus’ vote you should have liked Raya’s too. Nancy was calling out Titus for playing in a way that suggested she needed to push specific miselims but I think your PoE was too wide and that suggests you’re trying to leave more miselim options open.
-Protocol

[Infinity Zero]

also i want the record to show that i'm currently fourth in postcount

so anyone saying i'm lurking is just wrong

Never said that.
-Protocol

[Mistyx]

why raya, and why not titus?

i had titus as town because the way she handled her claim felt pro-town, plus her push on perfume felt internally consistent

i also liked her vote on vax

Tbf I had Titus in my lower TR tier
But I felt like townbinning her was too much atp
Meanwhile Raya’s Vax vote was one Infinity quickly pegged as town and I felt good about her contributions from what I read. So if you liked Titus’ vote you should have liked Raya’s too. Nancy was calling out Titus for playing in a way that suggested she needed to push specific miselims but I think your PoE was too wide and that suggests you’re trying to leave more miselim options open.
-Protocol

i've been burned by players by raya a lot before so i don't think the level of contribution is something clearing

so who are the mislims i'm trying to keep available then

[Mistyx]

also titus was literally in my lower TRs as well

1118

[wellermanbob]

Tbh i think the reason today was wild is it's TvT and scum are salivating in thread about chained executions

So I would prefer if Red used actual words to claim his information so at the very least I can accuse him of gamethrowing later

[Mistyx]

Tbh i think the reason today was wild is it's TvT and scum are salivating in thread about chained executions

So I would prefer if Red used actual words to claim his information so at the very least I can accuse him of gamethrowing later

this is the spice i needed

i had the same thought but i didn't want to say it for fear of sounding like an idiot

[wellermanbob]

I dont sell spice just sugar tea and rum

[Mistyx]

if red/chara t/t i dislike everyone who immediately voted chara after they claimed

which is inf/raya/s+m

i think inf looks bad for their reaction to the claim if red is town at all actually

i want to talk about 1147/1148 a bit - raya, s+m, can you explain why that logic doesn't apply to scum!chara as well? and wouldn't it be more likely that town!chara told the truth about their claim if they knew the red check wasn't real?

[wellermanbob]

if red/chara t/t i dislike everyone who immediately voted chara after they claimed

Ya but we shouldn't have to execute them both to find out we are in that world lol thats just bad manners.

Red doesn't have a posting restriction right its just a gimmick
??

[Mistyx]

if red/chara t/t i dislike everyone who immediately voted chara after they claimed

Ya but we shouldn't have to execute them both to find out we are in that world lol thats just bad manners.

Red doesn't have a posting restriction right its just a gimmick
??

well how else do you propose we solve that

also i believe so yes

[Smoke and Mirrors]

*shrug*

Same thing just happened in Open 802. Caught scum, people said I was wrong. Said scum won.

It's probably just jjh and the twins.

After I flip town, jjh will go after gamma.
The twins will lurk.

I think I may have possibly voted Titus because she really hurt my feelings and I try not to let that influence my vote.

IZ is super obvious town btw. So, this makes me question my Titus scumread.

Infinity thinks Mistyx is more likely scum than Titus and apparently Chara was guiltied so Titus might be town, but I feel like she handled you very differently to how I did.
-Protocol

Hence the initial scumread and yes, completely agree with this.

[Mistyx]

this is nancy right

why do you think infinity is obvtown? i have more experience with gamma than i do infinity and don't think gamma's outside of his scumrange

[wellermanbob]

I mean we implore them to not be a dillweed and refuse to play with them again if they don't use their words

[Smoke and Mirrors]

okay treating that as a direct cc

catboi/titus/jjh/twins town - feel more confident on the latter two
{red/chara} has one
last is in {infinity/s&m/raya/bob}

cool

This PoE is why I 100% agree with IZ.

[Mistyx]

okay well

we still do have a mafia game to play

if chara/red are t/t, who do you think is scum?

[Mistyx]

okay treating that as a direct cc

catboi/titus/jjh/twins town - feel more confident on the latter two
{red/chara} has one
last is in {infinity/s&m/raya/bob}

cool

This PoE is why I 100% agree with IZ.

so which of my townreads do you disagree with

[Smoke and Mirrors]

Btw can I just state I love how the creepypasta gimmick makes the guilty look? Like DAMN, Red NAILED his aesthetic.

clearly, gamma is scum trying to pocket red

Spoiler:

agreed tbh

No.

[Mistyx]

Btw can I just state I love how the creepypasta gimmick makes the guilty look? Like DAMN, Red NAILED his aesthetic.

clearly, gamma is scum trying to pocket red

Spoiler:

agreed tbh

No.

nice

[Raya36]

if red/chara t/t i dislike everyone who immediately voted chara after they claimed

which is inf/raya/s+m

i think inf looks bad for their reaction to the claim if red is town at all actually

i want to talk about 1147/1148 a bit - raya, s+m, can you explain why that logic doesn't apply to scum!chara as well? and wouldn't it be more likely that town!chara told the truth about their claim if they knew the red check wasn't real?

1147 was referring to scum!Chara. I feel like town!Chara would have more to say than just a claim if they were wrongly guiltied. It feels like scum!Chara claimed and left it at just that to avoid giving more info or further incriminating themselves.

[Mistyx]

if red/chara t/t i dislike everyone who immediately voted chara after they claimed

which is inf/raya/s+m

i think inf looks bad for their reaction to the claim if red is town at all actually

i want to talk about 1147/1148 a bit - raya, s+m, can you explain why that logic doesn't apply to scum!chara as well? and wouldn't it be more likely that town!chara told the truth about their claim if they knew the red check wasn't real?

1147 was referring to scum!Chara. I feel like town!Chara would have more to say than just a claim if they were wrongly guiltied. It feels like scum!Chara claimed and left it at just that to avoid giving more info or further incriminating themselves.

so if you think scum!chara would react differently to being guiltied...

why are you voting them?

[Mistyx]

they said they didn't have time to play tonight and i'm inclined to take that at face value

[Mistyx]

to clarify i'm not against killing chara but i don't understand your logic on this push

[Smoke and Mirrors]

why raya, and why not titus?

i had titus as town because the way she handled her claim felt pro-town, plus her push on perfume felt internally consistent

i also liked her vote on vax

Tbf I had Titus in my lower TR tier
But I felt like townbinning her was too much atp
Meanwhile Raya’s Vax vote was one Infinity quickly pegged as town and I felt good about her contributions from what I read. So if you liked Titus’ vote you should have liked Raya’s too. Nancy was calling out Titus for playing in a way that suggested she needed to push specific miselims but I think your PoE was too wide and that suggests you’re trying to leave more miselim options open.
-Protocol

i've been burned by players by raya a lot before so i don't think the level of contribution is something clearing

so who are the mislims i'm trying to keep available then

You are seriously arguing that scum!Raya NKs the player who has her as his strongest tr?

[Raya36]

if red/chara t/t i dislike everyone who immediately voted chara after they claimed

which is inf/raya/s+m

i think inf looks bad for their reaction to the claim if red is town at all actually

i want to talk about 1147/1148 a bit - raya, s+m, can you explain why that logic doesn't apply to scum!chara as well? and wouldn't it be more likely that town!chara told the truth about their claim if they knew the red check wasn't real?

1147 was referring to scum!Chara. I feel like town!Chara would have more to say than just a claim if they were wrongly guiltied. It feels like scum!Chara claimed and left it at just that to avoid giving more info or further incriminating themselves.

so if you think scum!chara would react differently to being guiltied...

why are you voting them?

I said I think scum!Chara would claim the opposite of what Red claimed them to be. And that's exactly what Chara did

[Mistyx]

why raya, and why not titus?

i had titus as town because the way she handled her claim felt pro-town, plus her push on perfume felt internally consistent

i also liked her vote on vax

Tbf I had Titus in my lower TR tier
But I felt like townbinning her was too much atp
Meanwhile Raya’s Vax vote was one Infinity quickly pegged as town and I felt good about her contributions from what I read. So if you liked Titus’ vote you should have liked Raya’s too. Nancy was calling out Titus for playing in a way that suggested she needed to push specific miselims but I think your PoE was too wide and that suggests you’re trying to leave more miselim options open.
-Protocol

i've been burned by players by raya a lot before so i don't think the level of contribution is something clearing

so who are the mislims i'm trying to keep available then

You are seriously arguing that scum!Raya NKs the player who has her as his strongest tr?

i think that argument applies more strongly to scum who might be substantially pushed the next day

raya wasn't in a bad enough thread position to need unwnd defending her