In post 1093, Thestatusquo wrote:Reminder to myself and to anyone rereading the game in like 3 game days that chowchow and TIL are never red together.
We are not buddies with anyone and I strongly doubt chowchow is either. What I don’t understand is why you’re even making this post. I thought you had them as strong town?
~I
I frequently leave little notes for myself for when I reread the thread and if I end up doing so on d3 or 4 if either of you is flipped I want to look back on this. Did you know that not every time someone mentions your name needs to be responded to? You can just ignore things sometimes.
Thanks for the advice but I make my own decisions wrt to that.
In post 319, Wisdom wrote:I can vote Brain cell too
Thats who I wanted to vote but I thought mastina is in it for some reason and the claim changed my mind VOTE: brain cell
this was close to what I was thinking (still reserving judgment on it being TvT - I think that's the most likely scenario), but at this point I would be voting woolax for 304 as well.
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2021 6:29 am
by SleepyKrew
Instead of catching up I went to sleep early and woke up late oops. Will try to read when I get the chance today but Wednesday is by far my busiest day so
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2021 6:30 am
by Save The Dragons
not in order
Strong Town:
mastina
Truth Innuendo Lies (Nancy Drew + Marashu + Auro)
Thestatusquo
Kitty Trauma Team (kuribo + Malakittens)
Whemestar
Lean Town:
Dwlee99
T3
Ralts
Gypyx
SirCakez
Null:
The Goat
chowchow (Anonymous Hydra)
SleepyKrew
ssbm/Sharing the Brain Cell (esurio + Anonymous )
I am mareep. I pick a target to sheep and when I do I become a double voter when I am sheeping that person
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2021 6:37 am
by ssbm_Kyouko
Wheme sheeps mastina, mastina copies role and sheeps wheme, they both get double votes and confirm their roles, yes? Presuming Wheme can activate in the day and mastina is reflexive during the day as well
In post 1113, Wisdom wrote:Your good scum core is cakez crew and goat?
That's lackluster
That'd be lackluster if that was my scum core but thankfully it is not.
In post 758, mastina wrote:Milobird
Save the Dragons
Firebringer
Thestatusquo
Wisdom
Truth Innuendos Lies
Sharing the Brain Cell
WhemeStar
Kitty Trauma Team
Dwlee99
Ralts
Alexandrite
The Goat
Gypyx
chowchow
Woolax
SleepyKrew
imaginality
T3
SirCakez
Since then:
Kitty Trauma team has become more town.
Goat has become more scum;
Woolax is a little more scum;
SleepyKrew is more scum.
So my actual scum core is more like:
(locktown at least for D1)
Milobird
Save the Dragons
Firebringer
Thestatusquo
Wisdom
(almost locktown, is strongly town for D1)
Kitty Trauma Team
Sharing the Brain Cell
Truth Innuendos Lies
(various shades of ambivalence)
WhemeStar
Dwlee99
Ralts
(various shades of null)
Alexandrite
chowchow
Gypyx
(south of null by an undefined amount)
Woolax
imaginality
The Goat
(lean scum)
SleepyKrew
(lockscum)
T3
SirCakez
I realize that having only two lockscum isn't ideal and that my townreads aren't as sure as they should be, but I'm overall happy with having the scum
pool
be what it is;
{Woolax, imaginality, Goat, SleepyKrew, T3, SirCakez} is a group that I think should have at least 2 scum in it. Obviously, I'd hope for more, I'd think 2-4 in there total, but there should be a
minimum
of two scum in there.
I'm happy with a scum
pool
of six, with 2 of them being lockscum.
It's not where I'd
prefer
to be on D1, but I'm at least
content
with it.
Can you explain both your T3 and Imaginality reads? I think T3 seems really townie and how is Imaginality different here than in OMB? Wrt Cakez, he’s still totally up in the air for me.
In post 372, SleepyKrew wrote:if anyone else needs me to tell them how to live their life just ask
Me next thanks. Give me the exact answer in my head and win a prize
This is where I'm at, so far vibing with STD, SK, Wheme (read formed ore-claim). Bit of a mindmeld with Wisdom but I'll be reading more of him first. No large gutpings yet.
Bit of a scumlean on Gypyx and Woolox, though I've only seen Gypyx as a mod before, maybe his TED talk intro is normal for him. This does not imply I have meta on woolox, just didnt like that one post, think it was #304
On mobile, not double checking atm
Pedit: oh yeah, T3's nagging at me right now as well.
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2021 6:44 am
by ssbm_Kyouko
Haven't been taking notes so others just arent at the forefront of my mind atm
In post 391, Thestatusquo wrote:Didn't mastina do like exactly this in ydrssal and get mod killed
from my memory she didn't paraphrase and gave away things that made her claim look non-fakeable. Or w/e.
I think she is probably paraphrasing much more or altering claim enough to be half truths or w/e. I don't know why i am bothering commenting on it. I don't care what claim she goes with.
Maybe this is town
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2021 6:53 am
by Thestatusquo
So ok went back and looked and it seems like I haven't addressed them before directly. Here's a brief iso skim thought.
They were involved in discussion on mech spec as well as were one of the players complaining about thread length. Both things are very slightly more likely to come from scum than town. (like 52-48% or something like that)
In post 101, Sharing the Brain Cell wrote:I also thought scum was people. but then again I also got excited earlier because I thought our role confirmed no third party. and it does! but uhhhhh so does the ruleset whoops
my brain, like the moon, is made of swiss cheese.
shoulda been lunatone smh
In post 117, Sharing the Brain Cell wrote:so, calling it now, this is gonna be one of those games that I don't reread ever due to its pagecount.
-q (last post was also me, but also like... trust me it'll be obvious if it's not lol)
Firebringer wrote:Back in my day
Join Date: 2015
get off my lawn.
They seem to be really into my STD analysis without really explaining why. They vote STD and then later on move back to STD again without much explanation other than sheeping me. Could be pocketing me but I doubt it? More likely just looking for a place to park their vote which doesnt seem suspicious or genuinely believes in my attack on StD and wants to see where it goes. This is less likely I think because they don't really do any pushing on it. But ehhh it's hard to say this is better than rand in either direction.
In post 617, Sharing the Brain Cell wrote:okay one more thing actually: might reassess STD vote and talk with B about it when we're around later, see if B noticed anything I didn't, and go from there. thought process (because fuck your modern meta, I'm still gonna keep elaborating): I'm townreading people who are townreading STD and I feel like there's been a lot of slot interactions since then that are worth giving a closer look. I don't want scum-STD to slip away by posting less and slipping under the radar, but I also think there's probably something I've missed since our initial STD vote that is a more concrete reason to be voting someone, and I just kinda feel like my first big scumread of the first day is prooooooobably not correct because that would be too easy and I'm probably still better at correct townreads than correct scumreads. maybe that's me wifoming myself again tho. B is a more decisive person in general so maybe he'll be more useful lol.
-q
this is a pretty weird post. townreading people who are townreading StD, but who are those people? Waffles on the read a lot in a self conscious way, and also theres some dissonance here around how seriously they're taking the read with how they're talking about it vs how they're trying to project it "I don't want scum-STD to slip away by posting less and slipping under the radar" vs "I just kinda feel like my first big scumread of the first day is prooooooobably not correct because that would be too easy and I'm probably still better at correct townreads than correct scumreads. maybe that's me wifoming myself again tho" is a weird juxtaposition when talking about the same read.
replace out is probably pretty null.
I think I have them in the correct place as slightly scummy in that they haven't really done anything and the things they've done have been kind of weird but at the same time I don't think they were scummy enough that I feel the need to not wait for what the replacement has to offer with an open mind.
I want to pick at goat alexandrite imaginality wooper and wisdom reads a bit.
For goat I'd like your thoughts on their entrance and why it doesn't read scummier than null to you. For the scum reads just a sentence or two on why would be helpful.
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2021 6:58 am
by Milobird
I'm going to take this moment to call ssbm town as well.
