Nintendo Mafia (Game Over)

[The Master Hand]

I find it questionable that TMH both acknowledges my hinting and yet suggests that I'm tunneling. It's one or the other but he is still taking the opportunity to accuse me. Interesting.

Ghost, I would still

absolutely

right if he flipped townie. But there is no reason for him to have fakeclaimed cop as town. As scum he had to. And yeah I'm down.

Ythan...these are the following options for thil
1)He truly is a cop who found Espeonage scum. if this is the case then your tunnelling on him and a town flip makes

you

the lynch

2)He is scum who took out a buddy to save himself. If this is what you believed D3, and not that he was scum trying to get a mislynch, then you should have been voting Espeonage regardless. Why? because it suggests that you thought Espeonage was scum, who had a cop investigation (whether or not it was scum distancing or town-catching scum) backing up such a thought.

Did you think Espeonage was scum? Answer this in addition to my earlier question that was not given an answer: Who are his buddies? You don't know? Hypothesize harder.

3) He is a VT who miraculously picked scum and faked a cop investigation. Yeah, no.

Whatever the angle, you did not take the towniest approach and as such I have no reason to trust your hints. They certainly are there, but that does not mean I believe them. My post in no way suggests I'll be voting thil because you want people to

trust you

.

Trust me

, I'm not that easy to convince.

THIL, have you already given your investigation results for N1?

[GhostWriter]

3 should be revised to state that he's VT who called guilty on his counter-wagon and is now keeping up the charade to stay alive, whilst unknowingly drawing any scum RB.

[danakillsu]

So my side of my interaction with Espeo/Pine doesn't mean anything to anyone? I would think normally that big a bus would be impossible for scum to make.

@ lewarcher
Not going to reply to my actual words?

[mb53]

Prod dodge. Posting tomorrow.

[Ythan]

Both players were acting scummy. My suspicions on neither player was based on their interaction with the other. Either was a good lynch.

[jmj3000]

Placeholder for vote count before work

[lewarcher82]

@Dana: What information will it give us?

What information will what give us?

I

was talking about the wagon, not necessarily his lynch. I'm still not sure if I plan to lynch him.

Hmm. After reviewing the evidence, I tend to agree that thil's actions read more like inept scum than unfortunate town. I'll

vote: thil

and see what happens. The wagon should at least get us some information. So I guess we have a vig, a SK, and mafia shooting at the same time, then?

you know what would make you look a little less scummy? If you quit joining wagons without explaning why. What evidence did you review? If you had the time for reviewing evidence, how about making a post longer than 3 lines, once in a while?

So...you're trying to coach me? If you think I'm scum, why would you want to help me look less scummy? I reviewed the evidence that others were bringing to the forefront, and felt no need to reiterate it. What other wagons have I joined without explaining why? Also, please look at Ythan if you want to talk about short posts.

these very intense and meaningful words of yours, you mean? ok. I want you to quit saying that you have currently nothing to say and to explain your reads. After Lelouch died, your contribution to the game is almost null. I would like you to comment on the slots, and say clearly what you think of anyone. Who loons town to you, who looks scummy, and aboove all why.
I don't want to help you to look less scummy, I want to stop your fillerposting, and start doing something that will help us understand if you are really scum.

[thil13]

THEMASTERHAND: I did not have any results for N1, because I missed the deadline to send in my action. I got espeonage guilty N2, and I suspect I was roleblocked N3.

[lewarcher82]

THEMASTERHAND: I did not have any results for N1, because I missed the deadline to send in my action. I got espeonage guilty N2, and I suspect I was roleblocked N3.

you suspect it? how so? The first time you mentioned this you sounded far more certain about having been blocked...
since you already claimed, I don't see any reason why you shouldnt explain what happened in a more understandable way.

[thil13]

I was roleblocked. It's something that happens or not. I did my investigation, and I got no result

[Dekes]

Thil, who did you want to investigate last night?

Ythan, it may be better need to claim eventually to get the thil lynch through. It looks like there are three killing roles out there, so no protective role on the town side is nigh impossible. If what you say is juicy enough and thil flips scum, you're safe tonight.
I just don't want this to turn out into a possible scenario of thil flipping town and tomorrow you going like "Well, it was a gambit, I of course didn't KNOW he was scum, but I was super sure he'd flip scum. Sorry, town!" If it's not clear, I think you're town and I don't need a wasted lynch if you turn out to be wrong.

I hope to see content from mb in the future.

[crazypianist1116]

Thil's at L-2
Dana's at L-5
Ythan at L-6


Dana's vote hop here is uber suspicious.

Something rubbed me wrong about PaTB's thil vote. It seemed rather forced in response to a somewhat reasonable post.

I was originally going to say how Ythan was tunneling but then I went back and reread late day 3. Thil's voting patterns on day 3 just seem unreasonable for a cop who's caught scum. I'm not as suspicious of Dana after that reread as the post is consistent with everything, but that patb post still doesn't feel right.

You are just trying to rush a lynch.

There is a wagon on you and with good reason. To criticize nothing but the speed is very untownish behavior.

How is it "untownish"?

This I read as Thil accepting the fact that his own wagon was a good one, something that town doesn't do.

Rereading late d3 makes me not so suspicious of dana anymore, but I still don't like the patb vote.

TMH: How confident are you in Thil's claim?
Thil: Nameclaim?
Lew: Your dana vote is interesting as she's definitely not the only one with that content level. Do you find other similar players suspicious, or just specifically Dana?
Ythan: Your next suspect after Thil?

Also I would hate for this to be true:

I just don't want this to turn out into a possible scenario of thil flipping town and tomorrow you going like "Well, it was a gambit, I of course didn't KNOW he was scum, but I was super sure he'd flip scum. Sorry, town!" If it's not clear, I think you're town and I don't need a wasted lynch if you turn out to be wrong.

I'll vote after some answers. Leaning towards a thil vote. I'll also try and reread d2/d3 this weekend.

[danakillsu]

you know what would make you look a little less scummy? If you quit joining wagons without explaning why.

I don't want to help you to look less scummy

Yeah...

Well I'll tell you this much. You're not looking very town, Ythan's not looking very town, The Master Hand is looking pretty town, and thil's a complete wild card. So I'll

unvote vote: lewarcher

for self-contradiction.

[thil13]

I already name claimed pianist.

I don't think I'll disclose who I investigated last night at this time, at the time I had thought they were scum, but now I have a leaning town on them.

[lewarcher82]

dana, my first quote was a way to asking you for content. I thought it was pretty obvious.

I dunno if I am looking town or not, but I agree with your tmh read. There is something in his late posts that even looks like a surprising townslip to me.

@crazy: for my reads of dana up to the end of day 3, you just need to check my iso. As for your question: I find him scummy for a series of reasons that were pointed out during the game, starting from the beginning of day 2. Players with the same content level, for instance GW, are certainly not giving me super-town vibes, but at least they never stated - during a frantic game phase - that there was nothing worth commenting going on... so yeah, dana is not only scummy for other reasons, he is also posting one-liners in a way that smells like strategy.

PV-EDIT

but thil, it is irrelevant. If you were blocked, this is not related to the name of the player you were going to investigate. Dekes question is legitimate.

[GhostWriter]

<3 you too.

Ythan, it may be better need to claim eventually to get the thil lynch through. It looks like there are three killing roles out there, so no protective role on the town side is nigh impossible. If what you say is juicy enough and thil flips scum, you're safe tonight.
I just don't want this to turn out into a possible scenario of thil flipping town and tomorrow you going like "Well, it was a gambit, I of course didn't KNOW he was scum, but I was super sure he'd flip scum. Sorry, town!"

I concur wholehearted.

[Bunnylover]

I'm reading the thread, just haven't had the time to formulate anything x-x

[Ythan]

With chk and Pine both gone I do not currently have a clear frontrunner for number two.

[thil13]

If you really must know. I investigated TheMasterHand...

[Ythan]

Did thil never nameclaim?

[GhostWriter]

My character name is Merlon.

[Ythan]

Right.

[Ythan]

I'm going to relent for (just) the moment. If I determine that I should claim I will let us decide whether my information is as significant as I think.

[Kdub]

So my side of my interaction with Espeo/Pine doesn't mean anything to anyone? I would think normally that big a bus would be impossible for scum to make.

Wasn't that strong of a bus by any reasonable standard. Nice try hyping it up though.

Ythan, just to be clear, you are saying (without details for the moment) that you are certain that thil is lying about being a cop? Is your info strong enough that we should consider this to be a 1v1 situation like yesterday? Because if that is the case, then that is the only way I could see myself voting for thil today.

[Ythan]

...

Read the post immediately preceding the one you just made.