Scummer of Love Invitational: Day 4 - The day the music died

[Singer is Nachomamma]

tl;dr: Axxle is not the play today.
CDB is the lynch, Axxle should kill Wyrd, and based on the mafia NK we'll decide whether to lynch Axxle tomorrow.




Axxle, if an SK, is clearly not BOTH investigation-immune AND bulletproof. So if chamber isn't lying then Axxle will be dead tonight anyway, especially if the scum think he's going to target them.

Reck what's your opinion on Wyrd and chamber?

no axxle should not kill wyrd

[Axxle]

I'm trying to figure out if CDB is scum or not. His joking manner seems like it's more of his scum meta, but he also seems to be more pushy as scum than he is here. I feel his interactions with panzer are null.

I'll just sheep singer if the two heads agree on the scum read.

[UberNinja]

tl;dr: Axxle is not the play today.
CDB is the lynch, Axxle should kill Wyrd, and based on the mafia NK we'll decide whether to lynch Axxle tomorrow.




Axxle, if an SK, is clearly not BOTH investigation-immune AND bulletproof. So if chamber isn't lying then Axxle will be dead tonight anyway, especially if the scum think he's going to target them.

Reck what's your opinion on Wyrd and chamber?

no axxle should not kill wyrd

YES HE SHOULD.

[Singer is Nachomamma]

NOPE

because before who the fuck cares if the SK is out there, he can keep offing people until I need to prove he's SK and get him gone (like when we get rid of more scum)

but now that I'm fucking dying just fucking deal with it

then your goals shouldn't have changed.
just because you're dying doesn't mean that it's suddenly more important that we kill the SK. instead, it just means that you will prove there's an SK when you do end up dying, which means that getting him lynched today shouldn't be that big of a deal.

HOW THE FUCK ELSE DO YOU USE THIS ROLE BECAUSE I'M PRETTY SURE STEP 1 *USE POWER* STEP 2 *CLAIM* ISN'T HOW TO DO IT

How the fuck else are you supposed to do it?
You already used your power, so there's no reason you need to live during the night. You certainly weren't playing before to draw a nightkill, so there's no worry of you preventing that from happening by claiming... and you have information that you can't act on alone. So all in all, yeah. Pretty cut and dry.

i mean MY GOD THERE WAS EVEN A 1-SHOT FBI AGENT IN THE SETUP

...that came up negative?

[Singer is Nachomamma]

I'm trying to figure out if CDB is scum or not. His joking manner seems like it's more of his scum meta, but he also seems to be more pushy as scum than he is here. I feel his interactions with panzer are null.

I'll just sheep singer if the two heads agree on the scum read.

still waiting for singersinger, so you might have to wait on the last part of that.

[Singer is Nachomamma]

tl;dr: Axxle is not the play today.
CDB is the lynch, Axxle should kill Wyrd, and based on the mafia NK we'll decide whether to lynch Axxle tomorrow.




Axxle, if an SK, is clearly not BOTH investigation-immune AND bulletproof. So if chamber isn't lying then Axxle will be dead tonight anyway, especially if the scum think he's going to target them.

Reck what's your opinion on Wyrd and chamber?

no axxle should not kill wyrd

YES HE SHOULD.

with reck as pretty much confirmed scum, wyrd is a bit likelier to be town.

[evilpacman18]

Wow you guys have been busy. Reeeeading.

[UberNinja]

tl;dr: Axxle is not the play today.
CDB is the lynch, Axxle should kill Wyrd, and based on the mafia NK we'll decide whether to lynch Axxle tomorrow.




Axxle, if an SK, is clearly not BOTH investigation-immune AND bulletproof. So if chamber isn't lying then Axxle will be dead tonight anyway, especially if the scum think he's going to target them.

Reck what's your opinion on Wyrd and chamber?

no axxle should not kill wyrd

YES HE SHOULD.

with reck as pretty much confirmed scum, wyrd is a bit likelier to be town.

Reck is not confirmed scum, he's confirmed marked-for-death.
And if Reck flips town, what does that do for your read on Wyrd?

And no matter what Reck flips, Wyrd is THE best target for tonight.
Whether town or SK, he's the best target for Axxle, hands down.

Don't screw this up, Axxle.

[UberNinja]

Somebody should compile a list of all actions and results that have been claimed so far.

[xRECKONERx]

yes guys I'm scum confscum so you should quicklynch and end the day so you can get your precious scumflip and I can move this out of my bookmarked topics

[UberNinja]

Who do you think we should quicklynch, besides Axxle?

[UberNinja]

Regarding CDB:

I'm not entirey used to CDB actually playing in mafia games since he usually lurks out in most of them. I will say his play this game seems drastically different from Great Idea Mafia, the open game that just ended where I was in endgame with CDB and DoubleJD. CDB was a lot more self-assured, confident, even cocky in that endgame (where he was scum). A lot of posts he makes also give me town vibes, like his whole don't be silly, I'm town vibe at the start of the game (I believe there was another one of those somewhere, too). The only thing that tinges my gut a bit to believe he may be scum are his fluff-posts that wind up being rather empty, vapid responses to things that don't matter, like #271, but I think I'm still leaning town on him at the end of the day.



Regarding Wyrd:

I'll admit I have a bias with Fate, but I tend to read him as town if he reads me as town. I can't think of a game I've played with Fate-scum off the top of my head, but I've played plenty with him as me-scum, him-town. I usually think he's being pretty genuine if he reads me as town based off of my early game play (or, in this game, early replacement play) because Fate really can read me well. In Always On Mafia, for example, Fate came out of the gate saying I was town, and that immediately gave me a good read on him because I think scum!Fate would much rather discredit me and try to get me lynched. This was also back in the day where I was actually good at mafia and could actually catch scum, so I may just be a waste of space, but I'm willing to go town on this for now. The "let me hand this off to Nuwen" shit is pretty hokey, but Wyrd's play here is very similar to Gay Mafia, where they were a shining beacon of townieness.



Regarding Katsuki:

"Katsuki is fun as shit to lynch" aside, he's scummy as ballsack here. Take a look where he takes the opportunity to jump on the UN lynch because "he makes the game unenjoyable". Whether UN is scum or town, it gives scum!Katsuki an easy to jump on the lynch without looking

terrible

. Also, a MattP vote hop without reason. The way Katsuki reacted to me voting him was also mildly panicky, something I'd expect from scum!Kats but not town!Kats. There were other things, too, like the D1 hammer on MoS outta nowhere, but seriously Katsuki looks scummy as fuck. I'd lynch him.


I don't actually know who the other scums are, because these are the only three people I've read in detail and I think 2/3 are town. But there it is.

This post will sure be interesting to reread after Reck flips

[chamber]

I really want to think axxle is an SK, but the way reck played this really makes me doubt his motives.

Glork immediately saying this makes me not town also bothers me, what motivation do I have for making that play as scum? Ways of interfering with investigations do exist. Seems super lazy for glork town.

Holy fuck uberninja nees to stop with the spam, I'd hammer here if he was still at l-1.

[UberNinja]

-yawn-

I don't like being irrational but I'm a human and am. Everytime you make an appeal to emotion like that you just inch me closer to hammering you.

If you're scum then it's obv you're just itching for a reason to hammer and you want me to give you that reason.

If you're town you're being more of a moron than I've ever seen. Hammer me so you can see how wrong you are.

@ chamber/CDB/anyone else: I'll take pointers on how to post post-game, thanks.

Hammer fucking Uberninja please.

My wagon is obviously not going through because the scum are probably all already on it.
Additionally Reck is now not voting me any longer so I'm not at L-1 anyway.

So that means, after chamber puts me at L-1 again like a good little scum player, gets yelled at by a townie who's not a moron, and backs off again like a good little scum player, that the ship which is my wagon has sailed on, and will not be happening.

MISLYNCH TAVERN IS CLOSED BITCH

[xRECKONERx]

I really want to think axxle is an SK, but the way reck played this really makes me doubt his motives.

Glork immediately saying this makes me not town also bothers me, what motivation do I have for making that play as scum? Ways of interfering with investigations do exist. Seems super lazy for glork town.

Holy fuck uberninja nees to stop with the spam, I'd hammer here if he was still at l-1.

here

vote UN

fuck if i care

[UberNinja]

Oh fuck no. FUCK no.

Welp, looks like chamber will get his chance after all.

Axxle, don't disappoint.
Wyrd, CDB, Katsuki, chamber. Dead in that order please.

[chamber]

Vote UberNinja

[ChannelDelibird]

Oh. Well. I was just about to come in and point out the obvious hypocrisy in UN having a go at people for posting "this is my last post, goodbye" type posts. But hooray!

Reck looks pretty obvscum too.

[Vu]

Day 3, Cheers to the Governor!

UberNinja (6): Katsuki, Wyrd, ChannelDelibird, BBmolla, xRECKONERx, chamber

ChannelDelibird (2): UberNinja, Singer is Nachomamma
Katsuki (1): Axxle

Not voting

(2): evilpacman18, Glork

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch and to no-lynch.

Deadline:

September 24th, 2012, at 12:36 PM EST

Countdown to Deadline:

(expired on 2012-09-24 12:36:00)

[Vu]

Day 3

"Guys, don't lynch me," pleaded UberNinja. "Or else, I'll...I'll...." He started to dance for them. It was mesmerising. It was

adorable

.

No one could move a muscle, they were in love. He was so adorable! Look at him dance, what a cute little bear. All he had to do was...keep dancing? Forever?

But, alas. UberNinja grew tired, and lazy. After all, he was a sloth bear! And when he stopped dancing they murdered him in a reasonably speedy manner. Excellent.

UberNinja (Dancing Sloth Bear from San Diego Zoo,

Mafiascum Aligned

Roleblocker) was lynched on Day 3.

I'M FUCKING SORE ALL OVER.

Despite facilitating the speedy killing of a Sloth Bear, Reck was in agony.

In fact so much agony he fell over and died.

xRECKONERx (You Whore,

Lucille Aligned

Goon) was burnt on Day 3.

Night begins. You have 48 hours for Night actions.

Countdown: (expired on 2012-09-14 09:11:11)

[Vu]

Night 3

"ROXANNE," sang Fate (at least, it was an approximation of singing, "YOU DON'T HAVE TO PUT ON THE RED LIGHT." He clutched Nuwen's hand. "THOSE DAYS ARE OVER. YOU DON'T HAVE TO

SELL YOUR BODY TO THE NIGHT

."

"Roxanne," sang Nuwen in return, "you don't have to wear that dress tonight...."

"That's it!" you shouted, from the next room. "If you don't shut up in ten seconds, I'm getting singer to kick you out of the house."

Wow,

you thought, as silence greeted you in return.

I can't believe that worked.

You felt very pleased with yourself until you walked into the kitchen to make yourself a drink, and saw Fate and Nuwen both lying face-down on the floor, within a few feet of each other. For a moment, you thought they'd passed out, until you leaned in and realized neither was breathing.

Wyrd (Impromptu Karaoke,

Mafiascum Aligned

Townie) died of a broken heart on Night 3.

[Vu]

Day 4, Votecount -1

Not voting

(8): Axxle, BBmolla, chamber, ChannelDelibird, evilpacman18, Glork, Katsuki, Singer is Nachomamma

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch and 4 to no-lynch.

Deadline:

September 28th, 2012, at 1:05 PM EST

Countdown to Deadline:

(expired on 2012-09-28 13:05:20)

[chamber]

Vote glork

[BBmolla]

Grillty?

[BBmolla]

VOTE: Glork