Page 50 of 323
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 7:35 am
by Ankamius
VOTE: JohnnyEnglish
this is always a good vote tbh
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 7:39 am
by themilkcartonkid
In post 1201, Taly wrote:I wanted to bait more people to discuss
overki11
and actually have them try to interact with me more directly, but I think I've caught on.
In post 1117, themilkcartonkid wrote:It's probably going to be a while before I can put together a real case. Nancefloir shouldn't be the lynch because I'm not 100% about it not being playstyle. The sea come from their almost exclusively AtE reasoning, a couple of weird almost slippy posts that I think I've shared a few of and the fact that all their srs are omgus. Bef sounds so increadibly stilted and unnatural. Mbaki... I had a reason but I'll have to remember what tired me was looking at. I think some obvious towns are taly, chenn, and oka. And again, I dont know who shadow less cloud is
You have one post to tell me why my scumread on
Nancefloor
was OMGUS.
406 768 821 955 (Better yet, point out what reads are OMGUS.)
And another to sell me on why
kittybells/mbaki/time devil
are all white noise here.
You have until after I leave the house, finish my test, go get immunizations, and then return. I'm leaving now.
The wine signifies the sand of an hourglass.
This has nothing to do with the quoted post? I dont think your vote is omgus, I think the opposite. I also havent read rc or timedevil so ? Mbaki I for some reason sred last night but I dont have a huge reason to today beyond an icky feeling
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 7:48 am
by themilkcartonkid
Two things I would like to discuss for fun, 1 why did you originally start mafia and 2 what power are you most looking forward to. I started mafia because I enjoy the roles, but I continue because I think it helps me read people irl. I am excited about using the all town group thing
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 7:48 am
by themilkcartonkid
And yes, this will actually help me sort
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 7:51 am
by Clemency
In post 1217, Ankamius wrote:also I think that's like the 12th way my name has been misspelled on this site
sure thing, ankle
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 7:52 am
by Clemency
In post 1227, themilkcartonkid wrote:Two things I would like to discuss for fun, 1 why did you originally start mafia and 2 what power are you most looking forward to. I started mafia because I enjoy the roles, but I continue because I think it helps me read people irl. I am excited about using the all town group thing
1. i needed a new group of people to annoy
2. hit me up with that dance
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 8:13 am
by NanceFloor
In post 1214, Time Devil wrote:TemporalLich's Lead Rist
[Town]
Taly
(you are good at questioning and your posts are getting more towny.
1201 is a decent push as well.)
chennisden
(Good scumhunter,
551 and
590 are examples.
1010 is a good question.)
Fuscosco
(The catch-up starting with
847 shows town promise, though agreeing with mbaki's lynch list isn't towny (unless of course it's being used against mbaki).)
RadiantCowbells
(Usually votes for good reasons, though the PL push is strongly NAI. Townlean regardless. Would like explanation on the hasty TMCK vote in
960.)
Ankanimus
(I feel you're towny with
395 and
753 I guess.)
Creature
(what is with the don't lynch list on
1135? I think that list is good as a TR list though.)
themilkcartonkid
(I don't get why you're strongly scumread, your BEF push seems genuine and
1168 gained info.)
JohnnyEnglish
(I've got nothing to go off of. Default neutral. Confbias was very scummy though.)
Clemency
(You've got charisma, but your ISO doesn't have much info.
244 is my main impetus for not scumreading you harder.)
OkaPoka
(
429 is a good post and
652 is also towny, but you're mostly a fluffposter. Scumlean.)
0verki11
(
719 is a good post but that's about it. Scumlean.)
Chemist1422
(Low activity, though
912 is good. Still seems weird though.)
mbaki
(the lynch list in
403 is a blatant attempt to control votes, which benefits scum more than town.)
BrightEyedFish
(little info and activity...
231 isn't a good post as it says the chen vote is a defensive maneuver.
1170's reads feel forced.
Shadowlesscloud
(Your very low activity is very unsettling, and your ISO is dry of info.)
NanceFloor
(This isn't Dann's towngame,
411 and
417 make NanceFloor caught scum,
420,
424,
471,
833,
835,
917, and
1077 are wolfy reactions, and the readlist on
846 is forced. The heads still disagree with each other as evident in
1210. Scumlock.)
[Scum]
VOTE: NanceFloor
-TL
*not winning a paragon for this game*
~ND
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 8:17 am
by NanceFloor
+1
*possible paragon winner*
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 8:18 am
by NanceFloor
In post 1218, Ankamius wrote: In post 1211, NanceFloor wrote: In post 1207, Ankamius wrote:why does that necessarily mean SvS
Scum have to have survivability more than to lynch the 8ball
Sure but you don’t think they’d ideally like to hit that if they could?
~ND
if I was scum I'd rather not hit the 8ball at all
Why not?
~ND
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 8:23 am
by Ankamius
because that's information that otherwise you would not get at all
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 8:51 am
by Taly
In post 1226, themilkcartonkid wrote: In post 1201, Taly wrote:I wanted to bait more people to discuss
overki11
and actually have them try to interact with me more directly, but I think I've caught on.
In post 1117, themilkcartonkid wrote:It's probably going to be a while before I can put together a real case. Nancefloir shouldn't be the lynch because I'm not 100% about it not being playstyle. The sea come from their almost exclusively AtE reasoning, a couple of weird almost slippy posts that I think I've shared a few of and the fact that all their srs are omgus. Bef sounds so increadibly stilted and unnatural. Mbaki... I had a reason but I'll have to remember what tired me was looking at. I think some obvious towns are taly, chenn, and oka. And again, I dont know who shadow less cloud is
You have one post to tell me why my scumread on
Nancefloor
was OMGUS.
406 768 821 955 (Better yet, point out what reads are OMGUS.)
And another to sell me on why
kittybells/mbaki/time devil
are all white noise here.
You have until after I leave the house, finish my test, go get immunizations, and then return. I'm leaving now.
The wine signifies the sand of an hourglass.
This has nothing to do with the quoted post? I dont think your vote is omgus, I think the opposite. I also havent read rc or timedevil so ? Mbaki I for some reason sred last night but I dont have a huge reason to today beyond an icky feeling
Wait, you were meaning
Nancy's
scumreads were OMGUS? Well, this is embarassing.
....oh yeah.
1210 was right.
Still, you haven't even glanced at the votes placed onto you. You entered the thread by making the ewww statement of
kittybells
being
8ball
, but also haven't recognized the push made toward you.
969
I feel like it's an easy angle to simply state that
BEF
is
"obvscum"
here
992, but I don't understand why you state he's obvscum and then also continue to put up scumreads that are neither well-reasoned or have much thought placed behind it.
1074 1117
You've listed posts with vague commentary and so far the majority of your thoughts don't have much grounding that suggest they are genuine.
979 1176
If
mbaki
feels
"icky"
but not necessarily a scumread, why not work to resolve that?
In post 1227, themilkcartonkid wrote:Two things I would like to discuss for fun, 1 why did you originally start mafia and 2 what power are you most looking forward to. I started mafia because I enjoy the roles, but I continue because I think it helps me read people irl. I am excited about using the all town group thing
1)
Something to pass the time. I like to think critically and this is also a social-ish game. Lowkey wish I got noticed more for my insights or what I bring to the table in problem-solving. Every mafia game is different so it's not boring or too repetitive.
2)
No specific power, tbh. I like to evaluate the powers collectively and evaluate what's the best course of action for town to solve with the least amount of issues as possible. IE, PoE-based powers are not for early-game, and it seems very possible to avoid NKs while also generating both conftown players and limiting who are likely scum. Some powers are just fun fuckery that help reads.
What was the point of this post? And what were you expecting from
BEF
upon him answering you?
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 9:47 am
by mbaki
Yea, I might just site flake again for another year.
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 9:48 am
by Fuscosco
you need only to join the right games
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 9:49 am
by Fuscosco
Can we move this along tho?
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 9:50 am
by Ankamius
VOTE: Shadowlesscloud
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 9:53 am
by mbaki
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:05 am
by Taly
You're one of my most confident townreads. X_X
You don't have to answer my questions, but help me see your perspective of the game a bit more clearly? Or engage?
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:40 am
by themilkcartonkid
@taly
I dont know what wonderful commentary you want from me here. I'm still in a large part trying to get through the sludge this game and there are a lot of new to me people. I also havent responded to my push because theres nothing to actually respond to. Like this might be the first actual case made against me.
I want to get a read on playstyle esp for the people that seem like they've been here for a while.
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:41 am
by themilkcartonkid
Also, all my reads from last night were from 12am they were just random thoughts as I was reading
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:43 am
by OkaPoka
VOTE: shadowless
ok lets come back here dennis
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:44 am
by OkaPoka
VOTE: tmck
actually lets just lynch this solely for his attempt at rqs at this stage
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:49 am
by themilkcartonkid
In post 1245, OkaPoka wrote:VOTE: tmck
actually lets just lynch this solely for his attempt at rqs at this stage
Oka, I just wanted to start a conversation
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:50 am
by OkaPoka
we are 50 pages in and you wanted to talk about that?
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:52 am
by OkaPoka
if u want to talk
why havent you thrown down a vote yet tmck?
Posted: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:59 am
by themilkcartonkid
In post 1242, themilkcartonkid wrote:@taly
I dont know what wonderful commentary you want from me here. I'm still in a large part trying to get through the sludge this game and there are a lot of new to me people. I also havent responded to my push because theres nothing to actually respond to. Like this might be the first actual case made against me.
I want to get a read on playstyle esp for the people that seem like they've been here for a while.