Open 769: Venrob's PYP X/Y (Town Wins)

[rb]

Luca are you okay with a skitter lynch? i'm...kinda not?

[Sirfetchd]

If you want the scum leans, we all have Xayah in our top 2/3 The fact that it hit a wall at 5 lends the idea that it either hard scum pushed which not even xayah believes from the read list, or it's on scum.

[Luca Blight]

Ok, I’m willing to compromise on this one.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Xayah

[Sirfetchd]

Or that it'snot suiting a scum agenda, which we can deal with if shit hits the fan I guess. But I really really doubt it will.

[rb]

i'm okay with this

opinion on Billy sirfetchd?

i got townvibes from his opening posts =|

[rb]

is that L-1?

[rb]

if it is, we are speedlynching anyone who quickhammers on day2

count on it

[Luca Blight]

I’m not sold on Skitter being Town but I definitely don’t want that Lynch today.

[Sirfetchd]

i'm okay with this

opinion on Billy sirfetchd?

i got townvibes from his opening posts =|

Honestly ambivalent. I had thoughts on it a little with Luca last page.

[rb]

i mean billy's not exactly a tour de force that i'm worried his lynch will make the town weaker, i just have doubts that he'll flip scum

[rb]

i swear if you read billy's iso just up to like post 321, it's super towny?

[rb]

that or i suk xDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

[Luca Blight]

i'm okay with this

opinion on Billy sirfetchd?

i got townvibes from his opening posts =|

I hate to keep bringing up meta but the reason he was townread in his previous scum game was because he made some jokey opening posts which apparently newbscum wouldn’t make and he passed a reaction test by making out he thought scum had day chat when they didn’t. Apart from that none of how actual work looked Town, same as here.

[Xayah]

"guys look at me, you can't vote me because i haven't done anything objectively scummy, you don't know who my partners are and my reads are fair and consistent throughout the course of the game!"

maria plz

More like you're pointing to things that are 'scummy' when they're really not. But go on, get that ML going see how far it gets ya. Like if you pointed out something that was super scummy I would understand. But the points you made are just...not really points at all

[rb]

man town maria would so be scumreading me rn

[rb]

"guys look at me, you can't vote me because i haven't done anything objectively scummy, you don't know who my partners are and my reads are fair and consistent throughout the course of the game!"

maria plz

More like you're pointing to things that are 'scummy' when they're really not. But go on, get that ML going see how far it gets ya. Like if you pointed out something that was super scummy I would understand. But the points you made are just...not really points at all

i swear you're experienced enough to know that finding scum is not just about finding who does 'scum things' in a game where the entire point of the game is for scum to do their best to avoid doing 'scum things'

not just the fact that you basically only defend yourself, but the things you say are so far gone

[Xayah]

man town maria would so be scumreading me rn

don't say this like you have any idea how I play.
pedit: You're right otherwise the game of mafia would be black and white. Yet you're coming in here saying 'her reads are safe' or 'she's defending herself' like you think town me needs to have a spicy read or town me wouldn't be defending myself here. Do you know how stupid that sounds? Like, you bring up points that aren't even scummy it's basic mafia 101 that's NAI at most

[Xayah]

If you're going to use experience as a viewpoint why does scum me do the things I do right now when I'm one of the better scum players?

[Xayah]

I'm told I need to work on my tone otherwise people think I come off angry or something. I don't think I've got angry once this game. Sure, I'm blunt but I don't try to come off angry so if I do I apologize.

[Sirfetchd]

If you're going to use experience as a viewpoint why does scum me do the things I do right now when I'm one of the better scum players?

This is bs and you know it.

[rb]

i actually think your initial defense was the kind of brute force defense that works an overwhelming majority of the time for scum because of how assuredly it calls people to account

if not for sirfetchd and i being obstinate and continuing to point out the scumminess in your play, you'd likely not be a lynch candidate for today on account of that defense

[rb]

If you're going to use experience as a viewpoint why does scum me do the things I do right now when I'm one of the better scum players?

This is bs and you know it.

or this to put it bluntly

[Xayah]

If you're going to use experience as a viewpoint why does scum me do the things I do right now when I'm one of the better scum players?

This is bs and you know it.

If it's so bs why don't you explain why it's bs instead of just using useless buzzwords

[Xayah]

i actually think your initial defense was the kind of brute force defense that works an overwhelming majority of the time for scum because of how assuredly it calls people to account

if not for sirfetchd and i being obstinate and continuing to point out the scumminess in your play, you'd likely not be a lynch candidate for today on account of that defense

You know what, fair. I can see how you think this. Even if I can't really prove you wrong this is a fair enough view point.

[Sirfetchd]

If you're going to use experience as a viewpoint why does scum me do the things I do right now when I'm one of the better scum players?

This is bs and you know it.

If it's so bs why don't you explain why it's bs instead of just using useless buzzwords

Because it's wifomy.

Like, you assume an answer of i can't be scum bc my scum reputation is too big. (Which is its own fallacy)

The correct answer however, is because you think you can get away with it. Bc you rate your abilities.