Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[RCEnigma]

So let's say the bugbear roleblocked kidamn. But kidamn was motivated so still gets 1 jk. But Dave dies. So A50 was jailkept. But there was also a roleblock somewhere. And also a kill elsewhere.

[EspressoPatronum]

Keep in mind the Bugbear had/has a bookie reward, so that could impact what happened last night.

[EspressoPatronum]

So let's say the bugbear roleblocked kidamn. But kidamn was motivated so still gets 1 jk. But Dave dies. So A50 was jailkept. But there was also a roleblock somewhere. And also a kill elsewhere.

The Bugbear doesn't just roleblock someone.. they STEAL their power.

So the Bugbear stealing the JK ability and using it on KA could have nullified his other use of the power.

[gobbledygook]

If someone is motivated it gives them one additional ability. When BB got his power stolen his second power still went through

[RCEnigma]

When was BB culted and when was his power stolen?

[Cephrir]

So let's say the bugbear roleblocked kidamn. But kidamn was motivated so still gets 1 jk. But Dave dies. So A50 was jailkept. But there was also a roleblock somewhere. And also a kill elsewhere.

a roleblock would block everything KA did anyway

[Cephrir]

but actually that's kind of a good point

can a50 be the bugbear if he was jailed?

we should slow down and try

UNVOTE:

[RCEnigma]

Pinkball has a flavor message pending. I'm still waiting on that to go through.

[Cephrir]

Reasons each player cannot be the bugbear, who i am assuming is a multitasking mafia member

01. Pine
-pretty-much-proven motivator

02. Untrod Tripod
-???

17. xofelf
-has shown up in flavor (would the mod give scum a red herring flavor character like this? if so, since this one is so uninteractive, it could totally work)

19. Pink Ball -- INNOCENT CHILD
-technically, i guess they could be a town bugbear

23. RCEnigma
-proven ability

25. Miss Lynch, who is/replaced Enter
-none?

26. Elements
-flavor suggests otherwise

32. gobbledygook
-is cult

33. Cephrir
-showed up in flavor
-targeted by bugbear in flavor

36. Almost50, who replaced jadesmar
-has been blocked by both KA and cephrir on nights the bugbear acted

38. KidAmn
-?

40. EspressoPatronum
-?

pls feel free to fill this out as i didn't do any research or anything

[gobbledygook]

We have Pine’s flavor name, KA’s flavor name, UT’s flavor name, and ML’s flavor name. Literally the only person who does not have a flavor name known to at least 1 other player is A50. Ergo, he is the bugbear.

Given how awful DEB’s fakeclaim was, I would imagine that the mod did not provide fake claims.

[Pink Ball]

I'm not the bugbear, I'm a little orphan girl. My flavor said something about being like Batman so Im pretty cool

[Pink Ball]

Pinkball has a flavor message pending. I'm still waiting on that to go through.

Yayyyyyyy finally I'm so excited!

[gobbledygook]

When was BB culted and when was his power stolen?

BB was culted after Dave. I think N5. I was culted N6.
BB had his ability stolen N2 iirc

[Pink Ball]

What if the motivator was culted and he motivated the cult leader and we're actually at LyLo or some shit like that and xofelf is actually cult and Pine and gobble and EP and KidAmn and thats why they say they want A50 lynched but don't vote for him omg.

We should lynch gobble and then A50.

[Pink Ball]

Like, we could lynch gobble and that should be it, so we lynch xofelf to confirm

[gobbledygook]

PB my dying wish is that you all kill A50. Then you can all go down your paranoia tunnels

[Cephrir]

What if the motivator was culted and he motivated the cult leader and we're actually at LyLo or some shit like that and xofelf is actually cult and Pine and gobble and EP and KidAmn and thats why they say they want A50 lynched but don't vote for him omg.

We should lynch gobble and then A50.

If this is happening then fuck it we lose. I refuse to play around this kind of silliness.

[EspressoPatronum]

What if the motivator was culted and he motivated the cult leader and we're actually at LyLo or some shit like that and xofelf is actually cult and Pine and gobble and EP and KidAmn and thats why they say they want A50 lynched but don't vote for him omg.

We should lynch gobble and then A50.

Lmao that's some real tinfoil. I just want A50 gone because I don't want him to have the opportunity to use my reward power.

I really don't think ML is a goblin. N1 flavour confirms the existence of a half-dragon this game, we have 2 sources of info on ML's name being Azar Kull (a half-dragon in the lore), and nobody else except maybe A50 or Elements could be a half-dragon.

We need to lynch the Bugbear today because they claimed my bookie power last night.

VOTE: A50

I also voted him a while ago.

[EspressoPatronum]

I can confirm that BB got interrupted by the Bugbear at least a few nights before he got culted.

[EspressoPatronum]

Reasons each player cannot be the bugbear, who i am assuming is a multitasking mafia member

01. Pine
-pretty-much-proven motivator
-Cayden Cailean

02. Untrod Tripod
-Ronan Thomias

17. xofelf
-has shown up in flavor. Guard stuck in his post atop a tower.

19. Pink Ball -- INNOCENT CHILD
-very unlikely to be bugbear

23. RCEnigma
-proven ability
- proven identity as human woman

25. Miss Lynch, who is/replaced Enter
- half-dragon/half-hobgoblin Azarr Kul

26. Elements
-flavor suggests otherwise
-armoured behemoth
-race unclear. Probably a goliath

32. gobbledygook
-is cult
-human hobo before cult

33. Cephrir
-showed up in flavor
-targeted by bugbear in flavor
-dwarf with warhammer

36. Almost50, who replaced jadesmar
-has been blocked by both KA and cephrir on nights the bugbear acted

38. KidAmn
- Grog Strongjaw

40. EspressoPatronum
-Ace Brocolla. Human male. Appeared in flavour.

pls feel free to fill this out as i didn't do any research or anything

Filled things in for you

[EspressoPatronum]

There's a side possibility that Ceph took on all of Zora's role (ie. Roleblocker + scum), but I'd rather deal with the Bugbear, cult, and figure out 3p stuff before tinfoiling about the depths of Ceph's role.

[Cephrir]

If I could take an alignment, I wouldn't have used my ability until it was clear who was going to win

[EspressoPatronum]

If I could take an alignment, I wouldn't have used my ability until it was clear who was going to win

I'm not saying you did, I'm just putting it out there while we're hashing out all the possibilities.

There's another possibility that RCE is secretly scum + his role is the same as last game... but again, that's something to deal with after we get through all the obvious stuff like A50/gobble/Elements/ML

[Cephrir]

I guess the masons probably can't be scum
It really is a masonry right? I dont rly see the connection b/w the characters

[EspressoPatronum]

I guess the masons probably can't be scum
It really is a masonry right? I dont rly see the connection b/w the characters

Correct. And we were also given each other's name and role by the mod, so there's no way any of us are/were the Bugbear.

The flavour story is that my character, the owner of the coliseum, assembled the C.O.P.S. shortly after learning of the attacks on Cobble. He wanted to make sure nobody would blame him for the killings because of his bookie/gambling reputation. If you hadn't noticed in the flavour, he's a bit of a sleazy character, lol.