Newbie 1345: Mafia in a Bind (Game Over)

[Xiao Long]

That's not a hammer, Xeg was already voting for Mutley. That being said DON'T HAMMER HIM YET. Let him state his case. Honestly, if he continues to just act a prick, I say we ask the mod to replace him.

[Equinox]

Vote Count 1.05

Mutleyddmc (4) - Voodoo Lady, Didi, Xiao Long, Xegarus

Xiao Long (3) - MP5, FSnake, theslimer3
MP5 (1) - KingPin96
Voodoo Lady (1) - Mutleyddmc

Not Voting (0)

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

The deadline is Tuesday, April 2, 2013, at 12:37 AM EDT (UTC-4).[/area]

Mod Notes

Xegarus is V/LA until March 17.
FSnake is V/LA until March 18.

[KingPin96]

Even if Mutley's not scum he wasnt being useful to town in the slightest, just being a distraction, so i wouldnt mind a mutley lynch.

[Voodoo Lady]

Xeg: Why so quick to hammer? Give Mutley a chance to explain himself first; if he continues posting in the manner he has been, a lynch makes perfect sense.

Mutley: What are your reads right now? You think Didi and I are town if your last post is any indication, but I'm curious who you think among us is scum.

[theslimer3]

That's not a hammer, Xeg was already voting for Mutley. That being said DON'T HAMMER HIM YET. Let him state his case. Honestly, if he continues to just act a prick, I say we ask the mod to replace him.

From what I can tell, Mutely is causing a rucus and is being a total newbis. In a real game, he would be lynched for his trouble. He has his choice to replace out if he so desires, but if he needs to be ynched for disruption, then we lynch him. Point blank.

But that's an outside point of view since I'm phone posting and only had enough eye/time to skim. I want to announce v/la but I have a feeling ill have more time free soon. But between life, work, other projects, and managing something else, my time has been spent up lately, sorry for that xD

But blah, here you go.
I am V/LA for now.
This is a haiku

[Mutleyddmc]

How am I causing a ruckus? Because I didn't feel that the questions were worthwhile because they could have been answered by anyone with a brain and didnt need a clarification? If I was scum surely I'd have been defending myself to stay alive. Yet I haven't I don't mind being the first one gone. Someone always has to be. No voodoo at the time I thought you and xeg were more town. But not so sure on xeg now. Kingpin too. You and didi likely town.

I don't have any massive reads of course as its day one and only a few posts really. You learn more from a lynch and a night. That's when you can get your reads sorted as such. So as I say go ahead an lynch me you might learn something. In fact even if you don't lynch me I'm sure ill be killed tonight.

[Xegarus]

I'm sure ill be killed tonight.

Why do you think that?
No offence but you aren't exactly a strong town.

[Mutleyddmc]

I put something out there straight away. Knowing it would be picked up on, but not said out loud. Which would mean the mafia wasted a kill if they picked up on it (therefore I have slightly helped the town) or this would happen they would pick up on it and be happy to get me lynched. You seem very eager for it so I'd happily say you were mafia now.

[Xegarus]

You seem very eager for it so I'd happily say you were mafia now.

Fail to see this.
I haven't pushed your lynch at all.

[Mutleyddmc]

You didnt stary but you sure as hell thought you ended it. With your lets end this shit or whatever it was.

[Xegarus]

You didnt stary but you sure as hell thought you ended it. With your lets end this shit or whatever it was.

lol what?
You don't understand do you?
Since you don't, i think i will leave you in the dark for a bit.

[Mutleyddmc]

You thought you had ended it, you didn't realise your vote was already on me. You thought you had taken a power role out first day mr mafia.

[KingPin96]

You thought you had ended it, you didn't realise your vote was already on me. You thought you had taken a power role out first day mr mafia.

A power role would have had more motivation to defend themselves and scumhunt. You have pretty much done neither.

[Xiao Long]

From what I can tell, Mutely is causing a rucus and is being a total newbis. In a real game, he would be lynched for his trouble. He has his choice to replace out if he so desires, but if he needs to be ynched for disruption, then we lynch him. Point blank.

Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't mind lynching him. But to be perfectly honest, I'd rather have him replaced with someone who will actually play the game if he continues not to play it.
Also, nice haiku. =]


Xeg: You actually did push his lynch because you thought you were hammering him.

Mutley: Just because you think a question isn't worthwhile and that anyone could come up with the answer for it, doesn't mean you should just NOT answer the question. All this does is make you look like a scummy piece of shit. It's quite evident that you don't mind being the first one gone as you've done nothing pro town since the game has started. So far you have 8 people against you which does nothing but make it harder for us townies to find who is scum.

I put something out there straight away. Knowing it would be picked up on, but not said out loud. Which would mean the mafia wasted a kill if they picked up on it

What are you talking about? What did you put out there? What would be picked up? The only thing I've picked up from your posts is that you're content with trolling until we lynch you. And what do you mean mafia wastes a kill? If you're not scum, you're practically a free kill for mafia because everyone is against you (with the exception of MP5 and Snake as they haven't really posted much about this).

Quote tags fixed. (Equinox)

[Xiao Long]

Whoops, fucked up the quote tags, sorry.

[Mutleyddmc]

You thought you had ended it, you didn't realise your vote was already on me. You thought you had taken a power role out first day mr mafia.

A power role would have had more motivation to defend themselves and scumhunt. You have pretty much done neither.

I'm not a power role. I said he thought he had taken one out. also in previous games when being a power role surely scumhunting too much early on is more likely to make you a kill target and therefore you would be killed and losing the town a big weapon.

[Mutleyddmc]

From what I can tell, Mutely is causing a rucus and is being a total newbis. In a real game, he would be lynched for his trouble. He has his choice to replace out if he so desires, but if he needs to be ynched for disruption, then we lynch him. Point blank.

Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't mind lynching him. But to be perfectly honest, I'd rather have him replaced with someone who will actually play the game if he continues not to play it.
Also, nice haiku. =]


Xeg: You actually did push his lynch because you thought you were hammering him.

Mutley: Just because you think a question isn't worthwhile and that anyone could come up with the answer for it, doesn't mean you should just NOT answer the question. All this does is make you look like a scummy piece of shit. It's quite evident that you don't mind being the first one gone as you've done nothing pro town since the game has started. So far you have 8 people against you which does nothing but make it harder for us townies to find who is scum.

I put something out there straight away. Knowing it would be picked up on, but not said out loud. Which would mean the mafia wasted a kill if they picked up on it

What are you talking about? What did you put out there? What would be picked up? The only thing I've picked up from your posts is that you're content with trolling until we lynch you. And what do you mean mafia wastes a kill? If you're not scum, you're practically a free kill for mafia because everyone is against you (with the exception of MP5 and Snake as they haven't really posted much about this).

The tag fucking up is making it hard to read but I will try. What has anyone done that is really pro town? it is day one surely everyone really comes across pro town thats the point of the game? We don't learn anything until day 2 anyway. Its all waffle and shit on day 1. By waste a kille I mean the use a kill on a vanilla thinking it was a power role. Rather than having a shot at one of the power roles.

Quote tags fixed. (Equinox)

[Mutleyddmc]

Bloody tags‼

[Xegarus]

You thought you had ended it, you didn't realise your vote was already on me. You thought you had taken a power role out first day mr mafia.

Xeg: You actually did push his lynch because you thought you were hammering him.

I guess you don't understand either. I was wondering why you ruined my plan by telling people that my 'hammer' didnt count.

It was an INTENTIONAL fake hammer.
A reaction test. Do you honestly think i would not notice? And could you not tell the total change in personality?
And i must say, i don't like Mutley's reaction to it at all. His confidence that he has contributed by making a vague point and then the arrogance to go and say that he will likely be NK'd.
Mut, i do think you are scum.
I want a claim from you.

[Mutleyddmc]

Surely someone who came donw so happily with the hammer (even though it wasn't the hammer) is seen as more scummy? So you can say I haven't helped the town, but in a way I have because I've drawn people out who thought they were getting a nice easy day 1 lynch but fucked it up and is now saying that they weren't pushing for me (having to defend their actions a bit now?)

[Mutleyddmc]

why do you want a claim from me?

[Xiao Long]

The tag fucking up is making it hard to read but I will try. What has anyone done that is really pro town? it is day one surely everyone really comes across pro town thats the point of the game? We don't learn anything until day 2 anyway. Its all waffle and shit on day 1. By waste a kille I mean the use a kill on a vanilla thinking it was a power role. Rather than having a shot at one of the power roles.

Most players seem to be doing some pretty pro-town things so far with the exception, in my opinion, of MP5 and Snake. However, there's a difference between doing things that are not pro-town and doing things that are very anti-town. You've been quite anti-town the whole time. Whether you're a power role or not, it's not a waste for mafia to kill you. If they kill you, it's one less town we have which gets us closer to losing.

I disagree we don't learn anything on day 1. While yes, we learn more on day 2, it's better we have a decent foundation to work with going into day 2. You causing us to be so close to hammering so early in day 1 takes away any town advantage going into day 2.

You thought you had ended it, you didn't realise your vote was already on me. You thought you had taken a power role out first day mr mafia.

Xeg: You actually did push his lynch because you thought you were hammering him.

I guess you don't understand either. I was wondering why you ruined my plan by telling people that my 'hammer' didnt count.

It was an INTENTIONAL fake hammer.
A reaction test. Do you honestly think i would not notice? And could you not tell the total change in personality?
And i must say, i don't like Mutley's reaction to it at all. His confidence that he has contributed by making a vague point and then the arrogance to go and say that he will likely be NK'd.
Mut, i do think you are scum.
I want a claim from you.

I had assumed afterwards that you must have been fake hammering, but I'm not sure Mutley would be dumb enough to fall for it seeing as how both of your votes were on the same page. Also, Equi posting the votes immediately after my post didn't help your plan, lol.

[Xegarus]

Surely someone who came donw so happily with the hammer (even though it wasn't the hammer) is seen as more scummy? So you can say I haven't helped the town, but in a way I have because I've drawn people out who thought they were getting a nice easy day 1 lynch but fucked it up and is now saying that they weren't pushing for me (having to defend their actions a bit now?)

Didnt fuck up, infact it worked really well.
I haven't pushed your lynch prior to reaction test.

why do you want a claim from me?

Cause i think you are scum.
Cause you are on L-1.

[Xiao Long]

why do you want a claim from me?

Because you're at L-1 and someone who is not voting for you has already said they don't mind hammering you.

[Mutleyddmc]

Why would I claim something though? I would only be helping the mafia by possibly getting town roles out in the open on day 1, how would that help? I'd like to clarify what I mean by not learn anything, I mean nothing can be set it stone day 1. It is only till day 2 that we can possibly try and confirm what we think we learnt or throw it out. I don't mind being the first guy gone. It will hopefully as I say help you learn more for day 2. Ie look more into yours and xegs posts here. (don't think both are mafia) I'm sure when the day ends, 1 mafia will be voting me and 1 won't.