Mafiascum.net

In post 116, goodmorning wrote:

In post 104, TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote:I apologize profusely if I'm doing something incredibly stupid, but I am a Town Ascetic, which the wiki has said to be a burden for town.

OK OK 2 MAYBE, BUT

THREE

????? These cannot possibly all be real.

Well, it is a upick, and also Rach said it may be unbalanced.

In post 116, goodmorning wrote:

In post 106, borkjerfkin wrote:

TWTKEFEWFKEWFKEWF wrote:I apologize profusely if I'm doing something incredibly stupid, but I am a Town Ascetic, which the wiki has said to be a burden for town.
So a Miller, Hated Townie, and Town Ascetic?

This changes things, and I think the hated is the definite legit one out of the three.

Why?

How I see it, it's the time he claimed the role.
[/quote]

In post 119, MC RIDE wrote:Hated scum is truly bastard

My partner lynched me because he didn't realize I was hated scum

before i get another prod, i am catching up today..caught up on weekend. Will put my reads.

Not lynching from ffery/letters/bork today, I don't think.

I agree that PLing MC today is bad, since today is the only day we are guaranteed to have all the townies alive. Obviously dies once there are 5 or 6 people left.

That leaves AS/gm/kdub/aa9. I usually like day 1 miller claims but in a game this small and with this much anti-town claimed I'm a lot less sure. Still, nothing is too much of a red flag there left.

AA9 still needs to catch up, which I think is null. GM and kdub have both been pinging a little bit off, and kdub is third on GM's wagon, so...

VOTE: kdub

In post 125, TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote:How I see it, it's the time he claimed the role.

It is not at all about the timing of it to me and very much about the role itself; I don't see scum fakeclaiming hated period (since they're now a policy lynch), nor do I see them claiming it at all if they're a hated goon (which is kind of a big 'fuck you' to a small scum team in and of itself).

It's not possible WIFOM because there is no route where we say "probably from town therefore leave him alive". Instead we say "probably from town therefore policy lynch him instead of lynching him for other reasons"

AS wrote:and, if anything, Borkie can be town for not leading the PL against the miller, but then again he knows that we are harder to fight over TMT (I believe) so PL'ing him over us would be alot easier so there's that...

This makes absolutely no sense to me. If I thought you were lying from the outset, I'd have wanted to lynch you, regardless of the fact that I'm town.

GM wrote:Even if I could spot your scumgame, which I don't know whether I can, I'm really shit at convincing others to vote with me. The playerlist as a whole would not be likely to lynch you if you were Scum, IMO.

This looks like a way to shirk responsibility for pushing a potential scumread or what are you trying to get at here?

I don't think she is scum. I am qualifying my statement from earlier that if she was scum in this game she wouldn't get lynched.

In post 130, goodmorning wrote:I don't think she is scum. I am qualifying my statement from earlier that if she was scum in this game she wouldn't get lynched.

leaving aside the question of your actual alignment, and mine.

If you believe that scum-me would be difficult to lynch by this player list, you're 1) nuts and 2) ignorant of my meta outside the 4 games that we've played together.

In post 128, BROseidon wrote:AA9 still needs to catch up, which I think is null. GM and kdub have both been pinging a little bit off, and kdub is third on GM's wagon, so...

I don't understand what you're getting at here. Are you voting me because you think it's scummy that I am third on GM's wagon (nevermind that I was on him before I switched to MC, then switched back after the claim), or are you voting me because you don't want to be 4th on GM's wagon?

In post 131, fferyllt wrote:

In post 130, goodmorning wrote:I don't think she is scum. I am qualifying my statement from earlier that if she was scum in this game she wouldn't get lynched.

leaving aside the question of your actual alignment, and mine.

If you believe that scum-me would be difficult to lynch by this player list, you're 1) nuts and 2) ignorant of my meta outside the 4 games that we've played together.

1) I'd like to think I'm not, but you may have me there
2) Not since the first time we played have I even glanced over your meta (except to look for the game AS was referring to), so you definitely have that one right.

AA9 you're making me nervous. Post real stuff plz.

In post 132, Kdub wrote:I don't understand what you're getting at here. Are you voting me because you think it's scummy that I am third on GM's wagon (nevermind that I was on him before I switched to MC, then switched back after the claim), or are you voting me because you don't want to be 4th on GM's wagon?

The former, although I did forget that you were on the wagon before and then jumped off and back on.

I don't see what is scummy about being third on a wagon, especially on a wagon of someone else who you are suspicious of.

In post 134, fferyllt wrote:AA9 you're making me nervous. Post real stuff plz.

I concur.

Also could we have a votecount or something

In post 135, BROseidon wrote:

In post 132, Kdub wrote:I don't understand what you're getting at here. Are you voting me because you think it's scummy that I am third on GM's wagon (nevermind that I was on him before I switched to MC, then switched back after the claim), or are you voting me because you don't want to be 4th on GM's wagon?

The former, although I did forget that you were on the wagon before and then jumped off and back on.

What strikes you as scummy about the wagon position? It sounds like you are thinking that the jump off/on changes things.

Ooohhhhh are we talking about the butter zone phenomenon? FUN

JUST KIDDING, VCA (especially without a flip) IS STUPID

In post 140, goodmorning wrote:Ooohhhhh are we talking about the butter zone phenomenon? FUN

JUST KIDDING, VCA (especially without a flip) IS STUPID

I asked the question of BRO.

Hated scum isn't bastard.

Far from it.

going to do this

VOTE: Ffery

Unofficial VC 2
goodmorning (L-2): bork, fery, kdub
Bork (L-4): MC
Fery (L-4): AS

Not voting: TMT, AA9, GM, BRO

Oh

@to other head: Skype is totally not working. Make a QT or something?

And I'm asking you why you're asking VCA questions like you actually think the answer will be convincing or meaningful at a time like this ffffffff

In post 145, goodmorning wrote:And I'm asking you why you're asking VCA questions like you actually think the answer will be convincing or meaningful at a time like this ffffffff

That's not why I am asking the question.

gm answered it for me. It's a common spot for scum to jump on the wagon, and it's early. Everyone needs to eat some pressure right now.

AS why the vote? I don't see any red flags from her.

In post 147, BROseidon wrote:gm answered it for me. It's a common spot for scum to jump on the wagon, and it's early. Everyone needs to eat some pressure right now.

AS why the vote? I don't see any red flags from her.

Why did you mention the hop on/hop off?

I really like this post. It's a little unsettling having you in my town pile at all, much less on page 4.

It's been a while since I played with solo fery but I can't remember if she was usually generous or salty at giving out townread early.