Mafia 86: X-Men Mafia GAME OVAH!

[Phoebus]

Scalebane and kleimar, we need your targets from last night.
Night 3 must mean Emma (Gnome) Frost was out of town, right?

The only one who could be (at least, according to my investigations) guilty is either myself or kleimar.

I can't believe you said that Scale. No self respecting townie would. If it weren't for your mentioning your suspicion of Jeep earlier.

I'd go for a no lynch too. We just need to hear about your targets first.
Also,

mod:

4 alive....majority is three isn't it?

[kleimar]

My night chose was Scalebane. I wanted to protect the only cop we have. Unfortunately this still doesn't tell us wether he was protected or blocked.

Also does anyone has an idea who the last evil character could be?

Night 3 must mean Emma (Gnome) Frost was out of town, right?

It was Night 4 if I counted correctly.

[Phoebus]

It will tell us when he says whether he got a result or not.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Night 3 must mean Emma (Gnome) Frost was out of town, right?

I'm not telling. I may be out odd nights, I may be out even nights. I think it best the scum not actually know which. Unless we want to try and arrange some kind of mass test for everyone. Although it's possible the scum already knows.

[Phoebus]

You don't need to. I just assumed odd nights. And as kleimar pointed out...it was night 4 anyways.

Scale: Who was your target?!
And also, of the four of us..who've you not investigated yet?

[Scalebane]

I pinged you, phoebus. And I got back an innocent result. So, the only one out of us who could be scum (if all my results are correct) is kleimar. And the interesting bit is that it almost makes sense. He could just not kill and claim he protected me. I really don't quite know what to think.

[Phoebus]

Scale, what are your results like? Do you get good/evil ; mafia/not mafia?

I've been thinking of some possible scenario for night actions pending a no lynch and this info would help.
As would Gnome telling us which nights (s)he is away. But that info is still optional.
The more info we go into night with, the better off we are...

[Scalebane]

I just get good/evil. The only evil result I've gotten in this game was jeep, and I have gotten a result back every night.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Ok, here's the way I'm seeing this right now. Phoebus and I are as good as cleared. If scalebane's telling the truth then he investigated us and basicaly confirmed our innocence. If he's lying, he's the scum and Phoebus and I are still clear.

So that narrows it down to Scalebane and kleimar. kliemar claims to have targeted Scalebane last night. With no night kill last night there are a number of possibilities.

1) As Scale suggested kleimar's scum and chose not to kill

2) Scale's scum, kleimar targeted him and blocked his kill.

3) The remaining scum has no method of kill (least likely option)

I'm really not sure which of the first two options is more likely. Is kleimar (a relative noob to the site (no offense)) clever enough to have not killed and try to place suspicion on Scale? Or is Scale lying and he was just blocked?

I'm also taking into consideration that there's already a dead cop. (Coolbot, Jean Grey)

That really leaves us with only three options: vote Scale, vote kleimar, vote no lynch.

If we vote for a player and get it wrong, we lose, get it right we win.
If we vote no lynch, assuming the scum player isn't an idiot, either phoebus or I are as good as dead. Most likely phoebus, because they probably wont risk wasting a night trying to kill me. Then Scale and kleimar will point fingers at each other, and it would be down to the remaining player, (again, most likely me) to decide.

[Phoebus]

I'd suggest Scale and kleimar targetting each other.

If I die, we get a result.
If Gnome dies, we still get a result.
If no one dies and Scale returns no result:
A) He's scum.
B) Gnome is (I don't quite subscribe to this but hey! I know only my alignment here)
If no one dies and scale gets a result, hot diggedy dog.
If Scale dies, our choice is pretty much made up I'd say.
If kleimar dies. We have some tough decisions ahead.


Saying all this, I'll

vote:no lynch

2) Scale's scum, kleimar targeted him and blocked his kill.

This does bring interesting dimensions to the game and is quite possible. Notice the deadline was for Sunday and we have dawn within 24 hours....

~sigh~

[kleimar]

Well, this situation is very confusing. I can see but two possibilities.
1) Scalebane is scum.
2) Scalebane is telling the truth but his results sometimes give a good instead of an evil, in which case either Phoebus or Mr_Gnome_It_All is the scum.
The last seems pretty unlikely to me. Well in the end we have little to lose by waiting a day. So:

Vote: no lynch

[Scalebane]

Vote No Lynch

As much as I hate to say it, I just would like to (in defense of my innocence) say that my vote for jeep at the beginning of the day before this could mean two things.
1. I am scum, I simply crossed my fingers and hoped that jeep was the sk (which would be a needlessly silly risk).
2. I am who I claim to be. A cop.

Also notice the apparent contrast between my role and the cop who is dead role. I know this isn't confirmable, but I believe that they were a role cop whereas I am an alignment cop. That seems likely to me and would give a nice symmetry.

[bloojay]

Annnnddd....nobody dies.
Choices due by Wednesday, 5 PM CST.
I'll probably be able to start day before then.

[bloojay]

Institute Weekly

"Villain" Dies

Juggernaut, who could have easily been a villain, would have learned to never forget his helmet to a place with crazy people roaming around. He would have, had he not died.He appeared to be severly beaten up in the head.

Phoebus, Juggernaut (Townie), beaten to death.

It is day, 2 to lynch.

[Scalebane]

well, well, well.

I pinged kleimar last night and got back an evil resut.

Vote kleimar

[kleimar]

Well then, I think that you are lying Scalebane.

So:

vote Scalebane

It seems all depends on Mr. Gnome It All now.

[Phoebus]

My very first bah post!!

Bah! Go town!!

[Scalebane]

What reason could I possibly have had to kill phoebus? And besides, I am simly going to throw this out there again for kleimar to dispute, if he at all possibly can, since he has neglected to so far.

I would just like to say that my vote for jeep at the beginning of the day before this could mean two things.
1. I am scum, I simply crossed my fingers and hoped that jeep was the sk (which would be a needlessly silly risk).
2. I am who I claim to be. A cop.

Also notice the apparent contrast between my role and the cop who is dead role. I know this isn't confirmable, but I believe that they were a role cop whereas I am an alignment cop. That seems likely to me and would give a nice symmetry.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, kleimar seems to be the scummiest right now. He started the wagon on the innocent ID, and would only give his name at first when he claimed. And when he did give his abilities they were ones that made fair sense, but if you look at the roles on the player list, most of them are a little off course from what you would expect, namely Professor X (SK), Juggernaut (townie)

:crosses fingers:

vote kleimar

[kleimar]

So close, so close. What did I do wrong.....

[Scalebane]

Well, you really would've had the game if I hadn't voted for Jeep that one time. That and your rc was a little too much what you would expect from that character.

[bloojay]

Final Vote Count

kleimar-2 (Mr_Gnome_It_All, Scalebane)
Scalebane-1 (kleimar)

A very short discussion ensues, going something like this.
Scalebane-"I investigated you last night and you're evil. DIE SCUM DIE!"
kleimar-"What the crap? DIE YOU DIE!"
MGIA-"Uhhhh...DIE SCUM DIE"
So, the scum dies, but not without a fight.
In a futile attempt, Mystique (kleimar) shapeshifted into Wolverine.
kleimar-"Hah! You can't destroy my adimantium claws!"
So she slices at Emma Frost (MGIA), but Frost hardens into diamond just in time, but it didn't really matter. THe claws wouldn't have done much anyway. So Storm (Scalebane) decides to make a minitornado that will pick up Mystique and carry her into the wormhole generator. The tornado does it's stuff, and Mystique's dying words are:
kleimar-"What'd I do wrong?"

kleimar, Mystique (Mafia), has been lynched.
Mr_Gnome_It_All, Emma Frost (Commuter) and Scalebane, Storm (Cop), have survived the attacks on the university.

CONGRATULATIONS, TOWN!

Role details to come soon.

[Scalebane]

Good game, everyone, really, really good game. I must simply say that kleimar did really well and I simply think the town got pretty lucky, all in all.

Great job on the setup mod.

[bigbenwd]

bah
good game mod
we woulda won if I hadnt screwed up so bad on my rc *smacks self in head*

[Prizm]

wooooo go town...despite my only post being of the bah! variety i still followed the game, good job