Mafiascum.net

Votecount 1.6

BlueBloodedToffee (3)

- LycanFire, Tiershift, ChaosOmega

[L-2]

Umlaut (2)

- Lowell, Accountant

[L-3]

Accountant (2)

- Umlaut, BlueBloodedToffee

[L-3]

ChaosOmega (1)

- CareyHammer

[L-4]

Tiershift (1)

- pistachi0n

[L-4]

Not Voting (0)

-

Nobody!

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline for Day 1 is Tuesday, August 23rd at 9PM EST.

Mod Notes

BlueBloodedToffee replaces ConManMick.

________________________________________

In post 122, BlueBloodedToffee wrote:I saw that Accountant had the biggest wagon so I joined it!

This guy gets it.

Activity Overview
PM Username First Post Last Post Elapsed Time Posts V/LA Ends
Lowell Aug 10, 07:36am Aug 16, 02:53pm 0 days 2 hours 10
BlueBloodedToffee Aug 16, 10:48am Aug 16, 12:38pm 0 days 4 hours 3
Ümläüt Aug 09, 05:36pm Aug 16, 12:36pm 0 days 4 hours 25
SnarkySnowman Aug 08, 05:39pm Aug 16, 10:46am 0 days 6 hours 6
pistachi0n Aug 09, 06:10pm Aug 16, 10:09am 0 days 6 hours 7
Accountant Aug 09, 06:18pm Aug 15, 06:16pm 0 days 22 hours 29
CareyHammer Aug 09, 10:04pm Aug 15, 03:29pm 1 day 1 hour 7
ChaosOmega Aug 10, 04:48am Aug 15, 06:42am 1 day 10 hours 5
TierShift Aug 09, 09:51pm Aug 15, 03:28am 1 day 13 hours 17
Lycanfire Aug 10, 12:54am Aug 15, 12:48am 1 day 16 hours 10
ConManMick Aug 09, 10:38pm Aug 11, 10:19am 5 days 6 hours 7
PM Selected

I don't trust anyone who posts less than me. Vote for Chaos.

Going for Accountant now looks good. It was a vote on an inactive but for a reason. The Accountant wagon went to a standstill and we had 3 inactives. If Accountant is scum, scum are bound to not support his lynch. If Accountant is town they should be piling on him. I elimmed Pista and Chaos because they weren't as interesting regardless of Accountant's alignment.

VOTE: Lowell

Liking Lycanfire as town.

Lycan - why make an argument supporting my lynch, then vote Lowell? Not that I don't appreciate it of course

because people going inactive looks strange but claiming you're scum as a result is pretty dumb.

Accountant, I'm concerned that you had nothing to say about Lowell calling you a newb. Did you agree with that characterization?

noticeable lack of sheeping going on. the other wagons seemed good enough.

In post 132, Ümläüt wrote:Accountant, I'm concerned that you had nothing to say about Lowell calling you a newb. Did you agree with that characterization?

ehhhh

I don't think of myself as a newb, but I do make the occasional newb mistake. I don't think Lowell's characterization is accurate, but I see where he's coming from.

don't particularly think it's relevant to the game honestly

VOTE: chaosomega

i know I just implied we shouldn't lynch someone due to inactive but i've changed my mind bout this

Alright I did a reread.

In post 90, pistachi0n wrote:

In post 29, TierShift wrote:

In post 26, pistachi0n wrote:Tiershift, was post 13 serious or silly?

Why do you care?

I care because it struck me as overly serious for page 1, which pinged my scum-dar, but I wasn't sure because I didn't think it was a big deal if it really was just silly RVS. The "why do you care?" also strikes me as scummy, like you're trying to figure out how I want you to think.

VOTE: tiershift

Pistachion hugely avoids talking about the accountant wagon here, which is the big thing happening here. I originally read this as town for trying to move the game forward and bringing in new perspectives, but in a reread it looks really awkward and out of place, like pistachi0n does not know how to place himself wrt the accountant wagon.

In post 117, pistachi0n wrote:I think Tier is white-knighting me.

This comment is also totally uncalled for, calling someone town ahd nothing to do with white knighting.

Pistachi0n just starts a wagon without any kind of conviction and just lets it fade instead of looking further or getting people to vote with him.

VOTE: pistachi0n

Come on, sheep. This is my day 1 lynch

*shrug* Baa.

VOTE: pistachi0n

Tier, did you have an ulterior motive calling pist town in 92?

VOTE: Pistachion

L-1.

Will read the game later.

Chaos tell me your scumreads with explanations

In post 139, ChaosOmega wrote:*shrug* Baa.

VOTE: pistachi0n

Tier, did you have an ulterior motive calling pist town in 92?

No

In post 140, BlueBloodedToffee wrote:VOTE: Pistachion

L-1.

Will read the game later.

We are not lynching until you comment on the game

UNVOTE:
Just to be certain

I do scumread pistache

In post 141, Accountant wrote:Chaos tell me your scumreads with explanations

BBT - didn't like 35, looked like he wanted to show he was town by his desire to advance the game, but voted a person with a naked vote as their only post and who wasn't the leading wagon without questioning any player...BBT is voting leading wagons and hasn't really contributed anything yet, doesn't move the needle either way for me

Carey - no real content or effort to figure out the game state (aside from 91), and then the last third of his posts have been a push on me because I'm a lurker, which is easy to push without providing useful content

pist - wasn't on my radar at all until Tier's 137; sheeping the read with no other insights on my end

---

Who's your biggest scumread so far, Accountant?

umlaut. tier makes a fairly good case on pist too, which is why I'm sheeping him

you're somewhere in third place, below umlaut but I voted you over him earlier beacuse I was hoping to prod you into generating content(asking questions isn't content, imo, unless you're going to show town the thought process of you analyzing the question answers)

In post 135, Accountant wrote:don't particularly think it's relevant to the game honestly

It's a tell I was caught on in a recent game, actually.

I don't think a player who's been here a year especially likes being called a newbie. As such the natural reaction would be to respond with either "that's not accurate" or "that's sort of accurate, but <face-saving commentary>."

However, in this case Lowell used it to support a townread, or at least negate a scumread; and a scum player would be far more worried about being seen as scum than about being seen as newbish. So the natural reaction for scum would be to leave it alone for fear of disturbing Lowell's townread.

Accountant wrote:umlaut [is my top scumread].

Feel like elaborating on that? I'd like to know where this came from because I'm usually pretty good at towntelling.

-----

I also like the case on pist, but the makeup of the wagon (beyond Tier himself) is just awful: a scumread, a lurker, and a lurker-replacement who openly says he hasn't read yet.

In post 142, TierShift wrote: We are not lynching until you comment on the game

Do i have to?

Thats such a dumb tell though Umlaut, like why would I give a shit if another player thinks I'm a newb as long as they aren't being a dick/disregarding my points because of it

It worked well enough on me.