This 'I have a read but I won't tell you it yet' seems anti-town. Seems like keeping it unspoken means you can wait to see whether others lean cyrus:town or cyrus:scum so you can then say that's what your read was too.
In post 81, T3 wrote:lol
cyrus is obvscum by meta
he usually townreads his partners for bad reasons early on
so I was waiting for him to out his partners
Not convinced. You could watch and wait without needing to make that earlier "I know what cyrus is but I'm not telling" post.
In post 78, cyrus62 wrote:now i know t3 is scum trying to shade me early knowing im always a easy elimination.
If you "know" T3 is scum why aren't you voting him?
I didn't like your entrance (joining on going mech discussion) as it felt awkward. I didn't like your reasons to scum read t3 (saying he's anti town rather than wolfy, reasons being basically.. confident on Cyruss alignment and holding back his read). The way you play the t3/Cyrus dynamic feels bad (you scum read t3 for being confident on Cyrus, but you only ask Cyrus a wet noodle question when he exhibits the same thing)
Posted: Sun Aug 15, 2021 4:15 am
by imaginality
Those are two different scenarios.
T3 wasn't scum reading cyrus, just saying "I know what he is" without saying which alignment or why.
Since my post, he's clarified it's a scum read and voted cyrus. But would he have clarified that if he hadn't been pushed on that point?
Cyrus was scum reading T3 and saying why, but not voting him. Not voting a scum read is suspicious at first glance, but I want to hear from cyrus before voting him for it.
Cyrus hasn't replied yet. T3 had replied ("won't say") when I voted him.
In post 68, ArcAngel wrote:
So what part of what i said was scummy?.
I said earlier that post was mainly trying to discredit's peoples early reads(such as T3 scum, N_M town e.tc)
I agree with this, at best it seemed like a big post to say essentially nothing (except for the idea that eliminating one investigation target confirms the other, which definitely isn't true in most cases).
why'd this line from t3 make you think he's a wolf then
In post 85, T3 wrote:No I'm not.
Anyways Arc locktown, cyrus is lockscum.
I have a near perfect track record of reading cyrus. Also, town cyrus usually posts longer posts.
What the fuck, how do u lock town Arc, WHY ARE THEY TOWN??
cyrus is scumreading her.
bruh, seems like a lame reason to TR someone
Goats is town based on page 4
we have literally zero posts on page 4 nice lie
The posts below seem like attempting to solve the game, and tryign to progress the game through reads
But actually though, why's that
In post 107, goats wrote:Cyrus NM and some other guy are the wolves I forgot one of their names
I town read hockey fan the most and t3 next most, that other person with the colorful profile picture is alright too
Posted: Sun Aug 15, 2021 4:31 am
by HockeyFan
wait i messed up formatting
Posted: Sun Aug 15, 2021 4:38 am
by goats
irt hockey I town read very strongly pretty immediately for trying to solve NM and coming off with a town read, could be wrong but that's why. One of my hydra partners also liked your Arc read (though I'm not sure myself) and your posts have generally been decent.
This is to say lettuce town team
what do you think of Cyrus, imaginality, and t3
Posted: Sun Aug 15, 2021 4:48 am
by HockeyFan
In post 132, goats wrote:irt hockey I town read very strongly pretty immediately for trying to solve NM and coming off with a town read, could be wrong but that's why. One of my hydra partners also liked your Arc read (though I'm not sure myself) and your posts have generally been decent.
This is to say lettuce town team
what do you think of Cyrus, imaginality, and t3
I havent able to get a read on imagnailty, will try to re read them when i get home, but atm I think cyrus/t3 are different alligments, could be wrong about this tho
T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes
tbh i just want to sppedlim someone so we can get to the mech stuf.
I think this opening is towny as t3 votes/etc 4 people before it which is a bit more disruptive than wolves typically are
Posted: Sun Aug 15, 2021 4:53 am
by goats
In post 81, T3 wrote:lol
cyrus is obvscum by meta
he usually townreads his partners for bad reasons early on
so I was waiting for him to out his partners
In post 82, T3 wrote:[bgladiate cyrus[/b] VOTE: cyrus
He's flipping scum.
not quoting because it's a big post but before this t3 says he knows how to read Cyrus very well
I don't think this is ever a post wolf t3 makes about town Cyrus, as claiming to be able to read someone well then misreading them when you know their alignment is simply not something I see a wolf doing here
especially followed up on with this strong of a push
holding back the read to get spew is an extremely towny thought process btw
so anyways this t3/Cyrus stuff never comes from wolf!t3, town!Cyrus
the only way I think t3 could be a wolf atm is with Cyrus
it's possible but I find t3 towny outside of it so this is why t3 is my second strongest town
Posted: Sun Aug 15, 2021 4:55 am
by goats
outside of this I have arc/zyla as town off tone
that leaves 4 players
Cyrus, imaginality, NM, and the person who hasn't posted except once
I could be wrong on either arc or zyla (my zyla read being stronger) but I liked arcs interactions with Cyrus who I believe is a wolf