In post 120, Hella Jeff wrote:
bumping my response to you here, i didn't see an answer 52
is his stalling a behavior that doesn't deviate from his towngames?
(also, what games are you using? this is probably more important than anything else)
I didn't see a question. The stalling seemed fairly insignificant to me, or perhaps it's just nuanced enough that it's not something I pick up on. So on that point specifically, I don't recall it occurring previously, but if I didn't pick up on what you're talking about here I think I'd be unlikely to pick up on it elsewhere.
As for other games, it's bits and pieces from all of them, but to pick some out, I think Newbie 2078 (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=87518) feels similar to what people are picking on here -- some things with tone, attitude, weird phrasing, a somewhat questionable vote. That one's a pretty quick read, I think just from the first 150 posts or so you get the picture. In Newbie 2082 (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=88098) there's some other similar stuff, and around posts 140-185ish there's a "defensive tunnel". All this to say that his behavior here seems relatively in line with his past town behavior. I'm not townreading him for it, but I don't particularly agree with the suspicion, and the way in which everyone piled onto it looks extremely questionable to me.
I noticed while reading games earlier that you were just recently scum with them in 2252, I'm guessing that's where this opinion is coming from. Can you elaborate?
In post 120, Hella Jeff wrote:
bumping my response to you here, i didn't see an answer 52
is his stalling a behavior that doesn't deviate from his towngames?
(also, what games are you using? this is probably more important than anything else)
I didn't see a question. The stalling seemed fairly insignificant to me, or perhaps it's just nuanced enough that it's not something I pick up on. So on that point specifically, I don't recall it occurring previously, but if I didn't pick up on what you're talking about here I think I'd be unlikely to pick up on it elsewhere.
As for other games, it's bits and pieces from all of them, but to pick some out, I think Newbie 2078 (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=87518) feels similar to what people are picking on here -- some things with tone, attitude, weird phrasing, a somewhat questionable vote. That one's a pretty quick read, I think just from the first 150 posts or so you get the picture. In Newbie 2082 (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=88098) there's some other similar stuff, and around posts 140-185ish there's a "defensive tunnel". All this to say that his behavior here seems relatively in line with his past town behavior. I'm not townreading him for it, but I don't particularly agree with the suspicion, and the way in which everyone piled onto it looks extremely questionable to me.
I noticed while reading games earlier that you were just recently scum with them in 2252, I'm guessing that's where this opinion is coming from. Can you elaborate?
Correct , in direct comparison to that. I felt they came out of the gate much more prepared to lay a foundation of being a solid town read. Much more relaxed to open this game.
i am saying people should ignore me because i am going to spend the rest of today saying we should all skip to Night because day 1 is pointless.
In post 75, geraintm wrote:because day 1 will result in the elimination of townies more often than random. why give scum a head start. skip to the night and come back day 2 when at least some townies will have some info to work with. anyone who says they are great at finding scum on day 1....lets just say i admire their confidence.
gerain is maf
Posted: Tue Jan 18, 2022 3:08 pm
by Andante
VOTE: gerain
haven't read much, but I'm pretty confident on this one
haven't read much, but I'm pretty confident on this one
Heeeey! I don’t know you but I like you from last game!
Ah thanks I'm glad, that game was not my best... we do not discuss that game... lol
yall I was maf with gerain in a game recently, and he's playing the exact same card he did there, so can we just lim gerain and move on?
Fish in the Sea for those who are curious, we endgamed... and gerain did this exact same play
Posted: Tue Jan 18, 2022 4:32 pm
by Hella Jeff
In post 147, Andante wrote:yall I was maf with gerain in a game recently, and he's playing the exact same card he did there, so can we just lim gerain and move on?
Fish in the Sea for those who are curious, we endgamed... and gerain did this exact same play
DUDE
i have my own piece about this, dug deeperbut i do want to hear more about your experience
I was explaining why I think the case on him is bad, and the wagon suspicious. You called out low hanging fruit earlier, do you really not think that this was a case of that?