The town ascetic is going to claim 100 percent of the time though, right?In post 115, Prism wrote:Not really. Aristeia's use is actually valid, point isn't that she gets confirmation point is that it can be used to inadvertantly catch someone hiding.
My first game onsite had two town ascetics, one town one mafia is fine and actually disincentivizes claiming it as mafia if they get beat to it.
Its a false positive for traffic analyst, but not for pt copIn post 117, Enchant wrote:Traffic Analyst checks for "Outside communication".In post 106, skitter30 wrote:I'm p sure mailman doesnt get caught by pt cop
But i think town ascetic could very plausibly be a thing
Also dwlee's reaction to my scumping makes me more sus of them
Mailman is false positive for him. Yeah i misstold about PT Cop tho.
yea that is why I claimedIn post 120, Shuichi Saihara wrote:Novice mailman is a pretty strange role no doubt. Why is a mailman so good it needs to be nerfed?
These pinged me ^In post 54, Dwlee99 wrote:Initial townreads on prism (I will regret this), cephrir
it seems to me like a lot of closed setups have at least one role that on some level is "the mods messing with players who try to setup spec"In post 120, Shuichi Saihara wrote:Novice mailman is a pretty strange role no doubt. Why is a mailman so good it needs to be nerfed?
i hope someone sends me breadsIn post 132, Dwlee99 wrote:Town mailman is a role that depends on the strength of its user. It isn't useless though even without further role mechanics. Consider, for instance, that you can send someone breads on the night you die.
Possible. It seems like a mod trap either way really. If it's not an intentional wild goose chase or red herring, then it's punishing scum for standard play, right? I guess that's why I find myself searching for a third explanation.In post 133, fireisredsir wrote:it seems to me like a lot of closed setups have at least one role that on some level is "the mods messing with players who try to setup spec"In post 120, Shuichi Saihara wrote:Novice mailman is a pretty strange role no doubt. Why is a mailman so good it needs to be nerfed?
Or wait it's the opposite of this maybe? IDK.In post 137, Shuichi Saihara wrote:then it's punishing scum for standard play
Correct, and this could be a built-in "feature" or could be amplified by some degree of Informed. There might in fact not be a second ascetic at all.In post 125, VP Baltar wrote:The town ascetic is going to claim 100 percent of the time though, right?In post 115, Prism wrote:Not really. Aristeia's use is actually valid, point isn't that she gets confirmation point is that it can be used to inadvertantly catch someone hiding.
My first game onsite had two town ascetics, one town one mafia is fine and actually disincentivizes claiming it as mafia if they get beat to it.
Mailman is going to also out like 100 percent of the time.
Fireisred isn't really solving and prism is like idk kinda townie and ceph seems like he doesn't hate his existence right nowIn post 131, skitter30 wrote:These pinged me ^In post 54, Dwlee99 wrote:Initial townreads on prism (I will regret this), cephrir
Can u explain more abt the prism/ceph reads at this time?
Yeah you're rightIn post 140, Aristeia wrote:if Prism is town, it would be punishing town in a 9P for a very logical thing to happen on Day 1
what in the first 52 posts of the game do you think was solvableIn post 143, Dwlee99 wrote:Fireisred isn't really solving and prism is like idk kinda townie and ceph seems like he doesn't hate his existence right now
I gave reads you can tooIn post 146, fireisredsir wrote:what in the first 52 posts of the game do you think was solvableIn post 143, Dwlee99 wrote:Fireisred isn't really solving and prism is like idk kinda townie and ceph seems like he doesn't hate his existence right now