Mini 1637- Pokemon Generation I uPick (Game Over)

[Ursaring]

Oak's Notes

Metapod

The Cocoon Pokémon

Bug

Pokédex Information

This Pokémon is vulnerable to attack while its shell is soft, exposing its weak and tender body.

Vote Count 3.04

Flames682(1):

Bert

Bert(0):

vettrock(0):

Seohyun(1):

Flames682

Boonskiies(0):

pieguyn(0):

Formerfish(0):

TierShift(0):

Not Voting(5):

vettrock, Seohyun, Boonskiies, pieguyn, Tiershift

With eight alive, it takes five votes to lynch.

Deadline:

The deadline for Day 3 is in (expired on 2015-03-12 13:20:00).

[Flames682]

The problem with Mafia is I'll say I'll do something then forget to do it. For real I'll reread ISOs sometime in the next 2 days.

[Flames682]

In other news, Boon is as lurky as Wisdom was.

[Bert]

Yep. I'm surprised you offered to do ISOs tbh. Just the act of offering

Here is a recently completed game, an example of Boon replacing late into a townslot.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=60022

He had enthusiasm and dove right in with catch ups.

[pieguyn]

ISO'ing Marquis and combined with vettrock's posts I think vettrock-slot is prob town. I also like Bert based on recent posts.

I could get behind a Boon lynch. I haven't yet read in context (and I'm not sure if I'll ever get around to fully reading the game. probably when I decide I can't get any more reads from not reading the game lolol), but from what I could tell of what Wisdom posted, a lot of his pushes were exceedingly weak.

[Flames682]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=84&t=60264

This game as well.

[Formerfish]

I could get behind a Boon lynch, he replaced wisdom right?

Also, I currently have the flu and have been in bed all day. I may be fucked up on tusin and battling a fever, so I can not be responsible for any posts.

[Seohyun]

Wait what? That still doesn't explain how you would think Not Mafia's description of Psychic would match yours...

It doesn't really, I just was being dumb and assumed the ability description was some sort of connector to my ability. Which is why I was wondering if there were different versions of the same ability earlier. It made sense to me at the time.

Does boonskiies have any games you guys know of where he lurks as scum?

[Bert]

Pie what did you like about the Marquis ISO

[pieguyn]

it looked like typical town lurk

scum Marquis would have looked a lot different from that. his usual MO when scum lurking is to play up the ATE and make long-winded posts that don't actually have any content in them in an appearance to look town. and even though he didn't do anything, it's not like he didn't have a complete lack of stances, either; he at least threw some thoughts out there when he had them. I think he legit just didn't give a shit this game, leading to what happened.

it is possible his play changed since the last time I saw him as scum, but meh

plus I think vettrock's posts look kind of town. I think scum would be slightly less likely to walk in and immediately accept someone as pseudo-conftown. what are your thoughts?

[TierShift]

What did the mod tell you when you tried to use an ability you didn't have?

Seo, answer this.

You're also a bus driver which is a scum role?

[vettrock]

VOTE: Flames

I've explained already my reasoning. I think we need to start putting down some votes, as it makes the VCA easier to follow. It was already pretty difficult coming in to judge the wagons for the first three days due to a lack of vote counts from the mod. Too many not voting.

[Formerfish]

What did the mod tell you when you tried to use an ability you didn't have?

Seo, answer this.

You're also a bus driver which is a scum role?

Wouldn't there need to be a second target?

[Flames682]

Your reasoning is POE on analyzing a lynch

[Seohyun]

What did the mod tell you when you tried to use an ability you didn't have?

Seo, answer this.

You're also a bus driver which is a scum role?

Never, I never tried to use an ability I didn't have. I forgot my role after N1, and I didn't use it N2. If I had used it N2 I probably would have accidentally used the wrong name, and (probably) the mod would have said something. I looked up bus driver right now on the wiki and it says it a predominantly town role, but it's not exactly that cus it only has to do with one target and the other person doesn't matter in the equation.

[vettrock]

Your reasoning is POE on analyzing a lynch

Yes. Give me some reasons why you are town, or why someone else is scum.

[vettrock]

Your reasoning is POE on analyzing a lynch

Yes. Give me some reasons why you are town, or why someone else is scum.

Also, as I said not putting votes down lets scum hide. The lack of vote counts in the past already make the analysis more difficult.

[Boonskiies]

Sorry, I had a busy weekend. I'll get right on catching up and hopefully compiling a reads list by tomorrow.

[Formerfish]

What did the mod tell you when you tried to use an ability you didn't have?

Seo, answer this.

You're also a bus driver which is a scum role?

Never, I never tried to use an ability I didn't have. I forgot my role after N1, and I didn't use it N2. If I had used it N2 I probably would have accidentally used the wrong name, and (probably) the mod would have said something. I looked up bus driver right now on the wiki and it says it a predominantly town role, but it's not exactly that cus it only has to do with one target and the other person doesn't matter in the equation.

Your role makes no sense the way you've put it forth so far. So you target one person and change who they target that night with any actions but you have no control over who the target changes to? Imagine you are town, who redirects the nk, theoretically you could redirect it onto yourself by accident?

[Flames682]

Are you really gonna ask for reasons on why I'm town when throughout this whole site the only response to that is because my role PM says town.

[Flames682]

And if you didn't notice I said:

I'll reread ISOs sometime in the next 2 days

[vettrock]

And if you didn't notice I said:

I'll reread ISOs sometime in the next 2 days

Great, I'll re-evaluate my vote afterwards. I do think others should put down some soft of vote. 4 out of 8 not voting is a lot for this stage of the game.

[Flames682]

vettrock did you even read the game you'll probably say yes but the right answer is no.

[Seohyun]

Your role makes no sense the way you've put it forth so far. So you target one person and change who they target that night with any actions but you have no control over who the target changes to? Imagine you are town, who redirects the nk, theoretically you could redirect it onto yourself by accident?

Sorry, I guess my explanation wasn't that good. According to the wiki, a bus driver switches person x and y so that if an action is performed on x it happens on y instead and vice versa. My role would be getting person x to use their action on another of my choosing, person y. Any action that happens on person x or y or whatever person y does, does not matter unless it's some sort of ability block I guess. I didn't ask but I guess theoretically I could get person x to redirect their action onto me, and if it was a nk, I would die. Or I guess, redirect a scum nk to kill another scum instead (that seems to have a pretty low chance of happening tho)

I'm in the process of reading isos right now as well, so I'll place a vote when I'm done.

[vettrock]

vettrock did you even read the game you'll probably say yes but the right answer is no.

I have read the entire game. Did I grasp everything and remember everything, of course not. It was 45 pages long. About 10 of those pages are complaining about the mod and the long twilight, or asking to be replaced. Can I pick out the scum from the game so far? Nope. Are you my best guess at this point? Yes. I welcome you (and everyone else) to give me a better candidate. Seohyun seems legitimately confused about what role and powers he had, which I'm not sure if that makes him town, but he is doing a horribly unplanned job making a fake claim if he is scum.

So if you are not scum, you (and everyone else) can convince me someone else is a better candidate. You are voting Seohyun, I'm not convinced he is the best candidate, but I can see the issue (Like I said above). I'll give you some credit for actually putting down a vote.