Eragon's post has got me thinking... Scum would be more bothered about associations/looking suspicious/being scared of being scum read.
Perhaps my interpretation of LabRat is completely wrong.
Question: why doesn't Eragon have more town credit right now? They apparently shared a 10,000 word thesis on why Creature was town when they entered the thread...?) Eragon was also off-wagon..? Asking these questions to myself right now...
What I'm trying to determine is how many scum were on Creature's wagon. As I said before I definitely don't think there were zero scum on Creature's wagon, but I also think it's unlikely that all three scum were on his wagon. I'm torn between there being one or two scum on Creature's wagon, but I definitely feel like I really need to look at Eragon's slot. I was previously pretty skeptical of his Creature townread (I didn't understand how he came to his conclusions about Creature), but now that Creature has flipped town it's more plausible that Eragon simply picked up on town pings from Creature that most of us missed.
Keyser, are you saying here you suspect the scumteam is Irrelephant/TW/Labrat?
What I'm trying to determine is how many scum were on Creature's wagon. As I said before I definitely don't think there were zero scum on Creature's wagon, but I also think it's unlikely that all three scum were on his wagon. I'm torn between there being one or two scum on Creature's wagon, but I definitely feel like I really need to look at Eragon's slot. I was previously pretty skeptical of his Creature townread (I didn't understand how he came to his conclusions about Creature), but now that Creature has flipped town it's more plausible that Eragon simply picked up on town pings from Creature that most of us missed.
Keyser, are you saying here you suspect the scumteam is Irrelephant/TW/Labrat?
Yes, been sitting on this theory since D1, but TW's/Irrelphants/LabRats D2 posts just confirmed it in my head.
What I'm trying to determine is how many scum were on Creature's wagon. As I said before I definitely don't think there were zero scum on Creature's wagon, but I also think it's unlikely that all three scum were on his wagon. I'm torn between there being one or two scum on Creature's wagon, but I definitely feel like I really need to look at Eragon's slot. I was previously pretty skeptical of his Creature townread (I didn't understand how he came to his conclusions about Creature), but now that Creature has flipped town it's more plausible that Eragon simply picked up on town pings from Creature that most of us missed.
Keyser, are you saying here you suspect the scumteam is Irrelephant/TW/Labrat?
Yes, been sitting on this theory since D1, but TW's/Irrelphants/LabRats D2 posts just confirmed it in my head.
I'll explain it D3.
So you would be OK with also sending Eragon to Heaven today then? At the moment I'm leaning towards sending Dr. J or Eragon to Heaven.
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:09 pm
by Keyser Söze
Yes, Dr J firm favourite.
Eragon after you, but yes, Eragon deserves to go to heaven (they should have just followed their reads D1 and not be misled by 'the mob').
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:17 pm
by volxen
In post 1258, Keyser Söze wrote:Yes, Dr J firm favourite.
Eragon after you, but yes, Eragon deserves to go to heaven (they should have just followed their reads D1 and not be misled by 'the mob').
Alright then, I'm OK with sending Dr. J to Heaven. He was the first person I townread on day one, and the fact that he townreads you makes me feel better about your slot.
VOTE: Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:22 pm
by Keyser Söze
What's been going on is alot of distancing/anti distancing attempts, chainlinking players with their scum teammates, scumslips, forced town reads, discrediting and false bravado.
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:33 pm
by Eragon
dont mind me pondering the most important question of the universe...
TL;DR sorry i've been active, doing thingies soon
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:34 pm
by volxen
In post 1260, Keyser Söze wrote:What's been going on is alot of distancing/anti distancing attempts, chainlinking players with their scum teammates, scumslips, forced town reads, discrediting and false bravado.
One thing that has concerned about me TW and Irrelephant, actually, is how easily and quickly they came to townread me this game. I am town, but in the one game where TW and I were town together (Newbie 1888), he was
extremely
critical of my slot and it took him a long time to come to around to townreading me, after heavily scumreading me first. And likewise, in the one game where Irrelephant and I were town together (Newbie 1894), it took a while for Irrelephant to townread me as well, and he definitely considered the possibility of me being scum in that game. In this game, they both quite quickly and easily came to the conclusion that I am town based on meta reasons, which is somewhat odd considering they both have quite critically scrutinized my slot in our previous games together.
Whereas with Eragon, he came to townread me pretty quickly as well, but he gave very detailed reasons as to why and it was based entirely on this game rather than meta reasons.
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:36 pm
by Keyser Söze
Yes, forced TMI town reads.
Plus, you town read them both... until now(?)
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:41 pm
by Keyser Söze
Something is up if a player is being white knighted for saying "there is one scum in player a, b, c, d, e, f" in a 9 player game x
I'm still townreading Dr. J, and he townreads you, so that makes you at least a townlean for me, and I feel a lot better about your slot compared to day one. And I'm pretty sure Eragon is town, his townread of both me and Creature feels genuine as opposed to manufactured.
{Dr. J, Keyser, Eragon} is my town pile for the time being.
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:46 pm
by volxen
In post 1261, Eragon wrote:dont mind me pondering the most important question of the universe...
In post 1173, Irrelephant11 wrote:scumteam and rarely has two scum (though if I were scum here I’d try my best to make that happen) so if I can find a solid town out of those three I *might* prefer that over volxen
I probably agree but Labby is always the solid town outta these 3. regardless... volxen is like hard town and is always a good heaven candidate
DrJ is subject to current inquisition because they've done a couple of little gross cheeky things I'm wondering if they thought they could get away with.
In post 1193, Keyser Söze wrote:Does anyone have any of these players in their PoE/bottom 3 reads:
Dr J
Irrellphant
LabRat
Volxen
bottom three...
maybe?
i think irrel and lab are both towards the bottom
In post 1206, Keyser Söze wrote:That’s why I said DrJ or LabRat. That’s more interesting in terms of associations, my mixed feelings on them throughout their game (currently both town).
A meta-town read on Volxen’s 20 or so posts tells us nothing. We’re just banking on Relly and you... where Ausuka is challenging that meta now.
I wouldn't be against sending one of Doc J/Lab (IMO doc)
In post 1212, Keyser Söze wrote:Still don’t trust Irrelphant (and don’t like you both nearly had the exact reads yesterday) but still a player we can work with.
Not t/reading Eragon - if town they need to find scum outside of Ausuka/DR J/LabRat IMO
except... thats not my PoE?
i think doc J is town...
i have mixed signals on Lab
Ausuka i need to read
i still am thinking irrel scum
im less sure on TW being town
Im thinking you might be scum
In post 1221, Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde wrote:ah, is it just me or has labrat literally not posted since day start?
yep, no posts since nov 15
that coupled with lack of voting, wait a minute, let me check
*sing*
Life is a thing
*end sing*
In post 1222, Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde wrote:yeah, apart from his early RVS votes and a push on tw, he unvoted in 347, then didn't vote again till he voted on keyser in 954.
I want to lynch him today. I still don’t like his interactions with Creature and the way he was going about TW the whole game was just weird imo.
he made a good case on keyser (i.e. a strong case - not a typical scum weak push) in that post though
I'm confused
his voting pattern is scummy, but I'm tring what he posts when he does post
people can have weird voting patterns as town too...
In post 1261, Eragon wrote:dont mind me pondering the most important question of the universe...
TL;DR sorry i've been active, doing thingies soon
How do you feel about sending Dr. J to Heaven?
happy with it.
as long as they get their catch-up done and leave their mark on this game and feel confident leaving it, i think they are def town
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:49 pm
by Eragon
In post 1264, Keyser Söze wrote:Something is up if a player is being white knighted for saying "there is one scum in player a, b, c, d, e, f" in a 9 player game x
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:50 pm
by Eragon
In post 1261, Eragon wrote:dont mind me pondering the most important question of the universe...
TL;DR sorry i've been active, doing thingies soon
btw the question in question is...
Spoiler: be prepared for the depth of the importance
Is... The Worst... actually... A DUCK?????
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:53 pm
by Keyser Söze
In post 1058, Irrelephant11 wrote:ew keyser what
what is the AtE on this and last page
do you *want* to get lynched
honestly right now the case labrat is making on keyser is all basically true about eragon except eragon has basically none of the towny moments keyser has, and I think there are worlds here where keyser is town
feels like eragon is only itt when asked, and hoping to just gather little enough attention to survive the day phase.
idk keyser is not my strongest scumread and if lab+creature are the wagon I think I'll probably pass for now
creature has done next to nothing all day, still fine with his lynch
DrJ where's your head at
Ausuka you should place a vote
But if I’m your strongest scum read, then ok then. My playstyle doesn’t work on this site anymore.
Bye guys been fun last few games. See you in couple years
ugghhhh Keyser why
He is a mafia duck.
A self appointed leader.
His reign of terror is over.
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:55 pm
by Keyser Söze
Eragon, you responded and reacted correctly.
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:56 pm
by Keyser Söze
All Rats Don't Go To Heaven
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 1:56 pm
by the worst
I'm really not townreading Eragon and not seeing why anyone isn't townreading me here.
pedit: I can't read all of this yet but you're literally looking at a smear campaign. I'm waiting for a fucking coward to talk to me about why they think I'm ever scum here.
If I'm not, look into {Eragon, Keyser} for your wolf. This is blatant baseless discrediting, and anybody who's falling for it needs to check themselves and come out with an actual reason.
x
