Mafiascum.net

In post 1245, Flubbernugget wrote:I quoted weird. I am accusing ED of fishing, not urap

"If somebody scum reads them, the fact that they've softed PR should mean nothing until they make an actual claim."

Sounds like ED wanted to keep cinn a viable L1 target either to lynch or to get a fullclaim

oh, okay that makes more sense then

Why hasn't my replacement changed your read, U2? You think I'd replace into a scum slot?

Like, I get that you're presenting as having an obv!town predecessor

but if you're town it would really help the game if you could give some shit for us to read you by, you know?

In post 1251, Shoshin wrote:Why hasn't my replacement changed your read, U2? You think I'd replace into a scum slot?

I have no idea what your replace-in meta is, nor am I willing to work to find out

I never replace into a slot that's scum. See, for example, https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p11021122

I thought you'd know this, U2. You were in a recent game I replaced out of as scum after posting almost nothing substantive.

Shoshin I'm cool with you taking on a bravado perspective as to your slots alignment but please don't imply you have a trust tell or replace tactically as that makes your slot feel icky

In post 1254, Shoshin wrote:I never replace into a slot that's scum. See, for example, https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p11021122

I thought you'd know this, U2. You were in a recent game I replaced out of as scum after posting almost nothing substantive.

I don't know what game you replaced out of as scum off the top of my head, but I remember you playing a lengthy mini as scum and you were well engaged throughout so

Can you talk to me about nom town? I actually was feeling it for most the game, I'm just kinda pinged by 1199 and don't get why she wrote that post that way as town. What makes her a strong townread for you?

but if you're trying to say that you literally do not play as scum, then that's either a lie (because I've seen you do it), or a newly developed trust tell =/

In post 1256, u r a person 2 wrote:

In post 1254, Shoshin wrote:I never replace into a slot that's scum. See, for example, https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p11021122

I thought you'd know this, U2. You were in a recent game I replaced out of as scum after posting almost nothing substantive.

I don't know what game you replaced out of as scum off the top of my head, but I remember you playing a lengthy mini as scum and you were well engaged throughout so

The recent newbie game with the worst. I was replaced after posting nothing substantive. My presence was so minimal that you don't even remember me in the game.

I have never played a lengthy mini as scum. The only mini I played as scum was short. I was lynched early on D1 after a bit of lurking.

My position is that I wouldn't willingly play scum if I had the option not to. If I sign up for game & get stuck with a scum PM, then I'll try. But replacing into a game? Only slots that are clearly town.

Nom's town because there's much deeper thinking than anything they've ever displayed as scum.

I don't care too much about being perceived as "icky," just stating the facts -- my choice to replace into this slot means it's very likely town, so much so that voting me is a bad idea.

In post 1259, Shoshin wrote:The recent newbie game with the worst. I was replaced after posting nothing substantive. My presence was so minimal that you don't even remember me in the game.

I have never played a lengthy mini as scum. The only mini I played as scum was short. I was lynched early on D1 after a bit of lurking.

In that newbie, you were replaced by a mod with a short leash.. You actually posted after being replaced because you didn't realize you had been replaced...

And we played a little mini thing you, me, rc, suadade and michael scott

jingle ran it

you were scum

In post 1261, Shoshin wrote:Nom's town because there's much deeper thinking than anything they've ever displayed as scum.

What games with nom are you thinking of here?

Oh, the BoP game. I felt obligated to play that out.

If you assume I'm town, what're your reads? A question for both Pika & U2.

you've asked a lot of questions, how about answering one of mine first?

how was your predecessor town?

ok well that's an answer i guess

if you're town, and you only replace into obv town slots

then you should probably be able to town case him for me pretty easily

What do you think of the prime suspect slots ( Teach and Flubber )?

In post 1266, Shoshin wrote:If you assume I'm town, what're your reads? A question for both Pika & U2.

idk, I'd probably vote Buj but he's hardly lockscum

let me know if Buj is also town

and even if we take your replace-meta as a given, your read on me doesn't make sense. you say that I should be reading you town because of that meta, but as we just demonstrated this isn't my experience with you.

In fact, the last game you actually flaked out of completely was our first game together - you were town!

so no, I don't see any reason to unvote lol

.

.