In post 1241, Tayl0r Swift wrote:i dont like that youre so hesitant to take a stance on me here glitch.
If I took a stance on you I would be voting you right now but Literally every game I have scumread you you end up town so my unwillingness to commit to that should be a town tell more than anything. Scum me would eagerly jump on you because it's easy for me to just SR right off the bat. Im still trying to figure out why :p
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 12:27 am
by Glitch
I have to go in tk work in 5 minutes so I'm rapid posting in the parking lot and quotes are rough from my phone. This response is @pete
In post 1160, Marashu wrote:Actually, Nos continually insisting that all 3 of them were town is interesting. Like, if either Plus or DGB flipped town (as we know Plus did), then he still distanced himself, whereas if he's scum, that would only be revealed by a flip so he wouldn't be caught in the lie. So it's almost like hedging bets.
These posts ping me as off and DGB pings me as town even though I don't agree with all his arguments. In basing this off of just since I replaced in so I'm open to your arguments on DGB but if I'm picking between the two my preference in the Nos slot right now
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 1:23 am
by Pickaxe Pete
Eh... I think I agree with Nosferatu there. I'm not sure what Mara is on about. I'll see if I can go through dgb's iso. I think I did that on an earlier post to a certain extent.
In post 1209, Glitch wrote:I'm pretty sure I'm 0/2 for mislynching Taylor so I won't start there. She's super hard for me to sort. I always tend to SR her and be wrong so I'm laying off that one for now. But your lockdown is based on something that sounds really weak. "She didn't pocket me?" That's such a bad argument. I just don't think it's AI.
Let's start here. VOTE: Nosferatu
It is a bad argument, although I think Noraa is town.
I want to lean that way on tayl0r, but I'm not really confident on that. The effort she's putting in is a good look for her, although I believe I recall tayl0r saying high effort is NAI and low effort for her is only town.
this is true. im not sure i would call this high effort from me, but it isnt low-effort to the point where im a disengaged townie either.
That's fair, although you're high effort relative to the rest of us at least.
In post 1185, Noraa wrote:The fact that no ones really tried to solve me, sus me, or pocket me is honestly a weird feeling.
real weird :/
not sure what to think about everything considering only one slot has really interacted with me at all so far
I like your slot now
..............................
In post 1249, Vecna wrote:oh right, the pob long slot was nk'd - in before im trying to force a townslip.
the way this post was worded definitely feels like a very forced townslip.
In post 1241, Tayl0r Swift wrote:i dont like that youre so hesitant to take a stance on me here glitch.
If I took a stance on you I would be voting you right now but Literally every game I have scumread you you end up town so my unwillingness to commit to that should be a town tell more than anything. Scum me would eagerly jump on you because it's easy for me to just SR right off the bat. Im still trying to figure out why :p
this just doesn't make any sense. Taylor is basically universally TRed or null here. Why in the world would scum jump on her? That vanity wagon would do nothing but make them look antitown :/
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 6:13 am
by Glitch
In post 1253, Noraa wrote:this just doesn't make any sense. Taylor is basically universally TRed or null here. Why in the world would scum jump on her? That vanity wagon would do nothing but make them look antitown :/
That's cool but my reads are not based on what everyone else is reading but based on my own observations. I've already explained that from replacing in until now my read on Taylor goes one way but I understand my read on Taylor is usually bad so I'm not acting on it at this point. Why is that weird?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 6:18 am
by Noraa
Scum you wouldn't jump on her. Town you wouldn't either. Jumping on her is not AI so don't use it to say ur town.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 6:36 am
by Titus
@Taylor, I already told you why Mara is scum. Coasting, a lack of content, and beatle juice.
@Glitch, You feel different than last game but I can't put my finger on it. It could be because I am not trying to pocket you though. Are you usually defensive with a wagon on you?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:03 am
by Marashu
In post 1163, Titus wrote:Oh wow look who shows up like beetlejuice.
In post 1174, Titus wrote:
Also Mara has the beetlejuice tell. His recent postings after being called out do nothing to move the game forward.
In post 1256, Titus wrote:@Taylor, I already told you why Mara is scum. Coasting, a lack of content, and beatle juice.
Just saying something doesn't make it true (even if you do say that name three times...) I'm not even sure where/why you think this. My usual habit is to try posting after work when I'm able - which is why most of my posts are between 4:30 and 8:30PM my time. I sometimes try to reply before bed as well, but that's when I'm most active during the week. The post you seem to be "calling out" is no different? So I'm really confused where you're coming from with that.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:03 am
by Marashu
In post 1202, Noraa wrote:Taylor is my lock town rn and imma sheep her reads for now
cuz ur the Eddie replacement and Taylor thinks ur scum and I'll have a case on u soon after I ISO dive u
I'm not a fan of this, both because it's making it so that you don't need to defend your case, and because it feels like, for all your talk of not getting pocketed by TS, like you are trying to pocket TS.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:08 am
by Noraa
^I like the analysis. I have nothing to say since that's basically how it is. Im not too sure who to sus here and I just can't tell who is scum rn so I'm just clinging onto Taylor. I'm not pocketing. Taylor had a TR on me since before I would assume so there's not much a need to pocket.
However for this analysis, I'm adding u to the townblock.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:10 am
by Gypyx
Also Glitch, you have any idea why Eddie (the slot you replaced in) has asked the entire playerlist who would they shoot if they had a gun? (I'm wondering if there is trial stuff basically)
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:15 am
by Gypyx
So... i basically skimmed through the thread, not much of importance happened? Anyways pretty sure glitch is town for the nos vote
Also i've seen a few of those, but no activity cases can't really be a thing in the current gamestate, like yeah those are susp, but half the playerlist is guilty of this to some extent (myself included)
VOTE: nosferatu trying to make my vote useful
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:54 am
by Tayl0r Swift
i had really convinced myself that eddie was scum, but im definitely getting townpings from glitch here i think.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 11:03 am
by Not Known 15
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 2:31 pm
by Pickaxe Pete
In post 1261, Gypyx wrote:So... i basically skimmed through the thread, not much of importance happened? Anyways pretty sure glitch is town for the nos vote
Huh?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 2:43 pm
by DrippingGoofball
In post 1260, Gypyx wrote:Also Glitch, you have any idea why Eddie (the slot you replaced in) has asked the entire playerlist who would they shoot if they had a gun? (I'm wondering if there is trial stuff basically)
...asked everyone who they'd shoot... and never followed through on the question.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 3:01 pm
by Pickaxe Pete
UNVOTE:
I need to re-evaluate. Things aren't making sense. Looking at it without the gladiate mechanic, I get pings from titus, marashu and EddieFenix. Glitch, though, appears to be redeeming that slot. Titus bringing up beetlejuice, eh maybe I can see it with marashu, marashu beetlejuicing, eh maybe I can see it.
I don't understand the Nosferatu wagon. It's the same damn thing as last time. A lack of content. There's not anything there to scum read him for or to town read him for.
Gypyx reminds me of the Silence. I always seem to forget about him.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 3:10 pm
by Pickaxe Pete
In post 1020, Noraa wrote:I won't lie. I don't like Vecna's look this game. My scum radar pinged a lot reading that iso
Have you ISO'd anyone other than DGB, Nos, Plusjoy and Vecna?
You shared some thoughts on the other three when you entered, but you've been scum reading Vecna since you entered and haven't really said why other than an occasional "that's a bad look" or something. What is it about Vecna that you scum read?
In post 1261, Gypyx wrote:So... i basically skimmed through the thread, not much of importance happened? Anyways pretty sure glitch is town for the nos vote
Huh?
Specifically asking about the glitch is town for the nos vote statement.
cuz ur the Eddie replacement and Taylor thinks ur scum and I'll have a case on u soon after I ISO dive u
So you're suspecting him first, and coming up with the reasons to suspect him later. Yeah.. that usually isn't a good way to make a case. If you start with the conclusion and are looking for evidence to match it, you will find what you are searching for.
cuz ur the Eddie replacement and Taylor thinks ur scum and I'll have a case on u soon after I ISO dive u
I'm not a fan of this, both because it's making it so that you don't need to defend your case, and because it feels like, for all your talk of not getting pocketed by TS, like you are trying to pocket TS.
In post 1020, Noraa wrote:I won't lie. I don't like Vecna's look this game. My scum radar pinged a lot reading that iso
Have you ISO'd anyone other than DGB, Nos, Plusjoy and Vecna?
You shared some thoughts on the other three when you entered, but you've been scum reading Vecna since you entered and haven't really said why other than an occasional "that's a bad look" or something. What is it about Vecna that you scum read?
no I have not. Vecna's very inconsistent and fence sitty. Reminds me of my first scum game where I was both of those. Inconsistency can often come from a buddy whispering to you in the pt.
cuz ur the Eddie replacement and Taylor thinks ur scum and I'll have a case on u soon after I ISO dive u
So you're suspecting him first, and coming up with the reasons to suspect him later. Yeah.. that usually isn't a good way to make a case. If you start with the conclusion and are looking for evidence to match it, you will find what you are searching for.
cuz ur the Eddie replacement and Taylor thinks ur scum and I'll have a case on u soon after I ISO dive u
I'm not a fan of this, both because it's making it so that you don't need to defend your case, and because it feels like, for all your talk of not getting pocketed by TS, like you are trying to pocket TS.
Both of these posts are good.
this is shading me in a very indirect way. Not sure what to think here.
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 3:57 pm
by Pickaxe Pete
Not so much shading as pointing out suspicious activity that I hadn't caught myself. I especially like the concept of projection pocketing. Both of these posts make me want to examine you more closely.
In post 1020, Noraa wrote:I won't lie. I don't like Vecna's look this game. My scum radar pinged a lot reading that iso
Have you ISO'd anyone other than DGB, Nos, Plusjoy and Vecna?
You shared some thoughts on the other three when you entered, but you've been scum reading Vecna since you entered and haven't really said why other than an occasional "that's a bad look" or something. What is it about Vecna that you scum read?
no I have not. Vecna's very inconsistent and fence sitty. Reminds me of my first scum game where I was both of those. Inconsistency can often come from a buddy whispering to you in the pt.
What do you think about what DGB said about inconsistent play being townie?
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 4:01 pm
by Noraa
In post 1272, Pickaxe Pete wrote:Not so much shading as pointing out suspicious activity that I hadn't caught myself. I especially like the concept of projection pocketing. Both of these posts make me want to examine you more closely.
then examine me instead of shading me by giving people towncred for slightly Fosing me. If ur gonna Fos, then Fos. Don't hide behind other people and Fos.
In post 1020, Noraa wrote:I won't lie. I don't like Vecna's look this game. My scum radar pinged a lot reading that iso
Have you ISO'd anyone other than DGB, Nos, Plusjoy and Vecna?
You shared some thoughts on the other three when you entered, but you've been scum reading Vecna since you entered and haven't really said why other than an occasional "that's a bad look" or something. What is it about Vecna that you scum read?
no I have not. Vecna's very inconsistent and fence sitty. Reminds me of my first scum game where I was both of those. Inconsistency can often come from a buddy whispering to you in the pt.
What do you think about what DGB said about inconsistent play being townie?
