Mafiascum.net

In post 1248, Flea The Magician wrote:Yeah my townread on Ali rn is based on the fact there's been no AtE or weird aggression lol

In post 1185, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:if reck flips red here it proves our no-elim plan can probly win the game

In post 1183, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i think we need to start eliming in the no room claim pool


we can probly hit bad guys

and if they're townies we were never going to win this game

VOTE: Reck

my tolerance for gamethrowing is gone

In post 1135, MURDERCAT wrote:General thoughts:
- Plan for tonight should be to provide rooms where people should group, if they want to group. I want to group.
- I'm not about to throw someone out of the airlock if they don't claim, I don't think we have enough info to decide either way so people should just do what they want. I think this is better than random because some people want to group. I think scum will get an extra kill off tonight but what can you do.
- I recommend grouping up because my guess is that scum has some ability to combat this, but not enough of an ability that makes grouping up useless (e.g. a limited amount of lights sabotages that lets you kill even if there is a full room). We want scum to have to use these I think.
- No elim is probably right for today. We get a night phase to learn stuff and it balances out what I think is an inevitable (given some people don't want to group) extra kill tonight.
- Because it seems like no elim is the right option to me, I find it hard to do my normal strategy, which mostly involves throwing shit at the wall and seeing what sticks. Which leads to my other strategy, which is basically passively observing.

The good news is that I thought large theme games were too much for me, but it turns out that death curse was just like, really a lot. I agree with whoever said this game was moving at a decent pace.

Spoiler: Reads (generally sorted townie to not so townie)

PookyTheMagicalBear

I think Pooky is true to town form. Based on 2170, I think Pooky is one of those players who doesn't try to perfectly match his town game as scum. I think Pooky is leading town in a good direction, which hopefully is not how I would feel if scum was doing it.

OutWorldER

I don't know what outworlder is like as scum, but he is more town in this game than either of the previous games I played with him, IMO. I actually wouldn't expect 597 or 610 from outworlder scum even though they are somewhat easy to fake, as I assume he'd be fairly new at scum and those posts are scary to make (easy to TMI). I also don't expect new scum to fight against town giving info to earn town cred.

xRECKONERx

Reck scum might be good enough to play the vocal contrarian townie character as scum, but if he is he is doing a good job of it. He hasn't TMIed at all from what I've seen. For example, "scum have an ability to move someone out of a room against their will" is probably not something in the game, so if Reck is scum he is doing a good job of faking mech thoughts from the perspective of someone who doesn't know the mech which is I think hard to do without slipping. Also scum usually TRs me? But maybe I have left myself a bit to open to attack this game.

alisae

Ali isn't dominating the conversation in the way I would expect from Ali scum, though I'm not sure where the SR on me is coming from.

Flea

Flea is doing Flea things, I don't know what scum Flea looks like but I expect I would be able to find scum Flea before I find Bell or Taly scum and I haven't found anything I dislike yet, so fae goes higher on the list.

Bell, Taly

You are both posting vaguely townie things but there is nothing there that I think is never scum from either of you.

Cake

I know I was memeing before about Cake and I totally misinterpreted him, but he was still kinda weirdly defensive when I was posting about him so he still goes down here. There was also this subtle thing where he didn't lead the mech discussion but quickly jumped on board which felt like he wasn't really having his own thoughts about it /shrug.

Blitzo

Blitzo enterance post pinged me, which I know sounds dumb. But "Is there anything in particular anyone would like me to look at?" just sounded fake to me I don't know. 959 feels fake to me too?? Like there is no substance in those reads or even the mech. And stuff like this "I don't understand what MC is doing this game. MC was are your reads?" just feels totally empty to me.

{thegoldenparadox, Haschel Cedricson, DrippingGoofBall, Battle Mage, gamma emerald, titus, Akarin}

These are all people who I have no real thoughts about as of this moment so I am going to go skim their isos now.

TGP had that thing about Blitzo that I thought was a town thing to say, because like how else do you even think of that? Otherwise I don't think there is much there either way right now.

HC could be scum I guess, but mostly I think I just disagree with them about game state. I think Pooky is town and I think taly is ?? and I think Titus is a weird vote.

DG is doing DG things but I don't feel as comfortable in my ability to sort DG doing DG things compared to Flea doing Flea things. I don't really get the strong read on BM.

BM has been suspiciously absent from mech talk?? That's all I've got though, his iso is pretty empty.

Gamma hasn't yelled at anyone yet so I'm not sure if he's town. 1044 kinda pings me??? Spooky

Titus I'm not sure about because I don't really know what I expect from Titus in this setup. I agree with whoever said that we can shelve Titus for now as it will get easier later.

Akarin I should probably have a read on, but I don't. She has posted enough so I don't really have an excuse. I liked 1053, that's probably what I would do if I was trying to convince people to group, which I still think is pro town.

Ew what am I some kind of wall poster now?

In post 1245, Alisae wrote:Murder seems way more townier

In post 1258, SirCakez wrote:Wow these general thoughts sure are unique

In post 1160, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 915, SirCakez wrote:look normally I'd love to murder Battle Mage as fast as possible but he's not scum here

err thanks?

In post 1259, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 1245, Alisae wrote:Murder seems way more townier

I thought you were SRing me though

In post 1183, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i think we need to start eliming in the no room claim pool


we can probly hit bad guys

and if they're townies we were never going to win this game

VOTE: Reck

my tolerance for gamethrowing is gone

In post 1201, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1127, Taly wrote:also who is Blitzo? i demand everybody who reads this post to say "Blitzo is town/scum/?" so I can gauge how many wagons this gamestate actually wants to have...

I'm warily leaning blitzo town

In post 1207, Taly wrote:DGBs ISO is pretty much "kill BM, get people to vote with me or they are scum" etc.

Also I saw someone attach lurksack to BM (I think Cakez and Flea added to this but I don't know the context) and I am floored by this because the game has been going for less than 3 days

In post 1242, Alisae wrote:

In post 1130, SirCakez wrote:@alisae respond to my question about your reads please

nah bro
i just want people to wagon others atm im not gonna play my hand

In post 1260, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 1258, SirCakez wrote:Wow these general thoughts sure are unique

I didn't say they were?

In post 1263, Alisae wrote:Murdercat - I'd say aligned with Reck
Blitzo - Town and I ain't tellin you why until he is in range of dieing.
xRECKONERx - I'd say aligned with Murdercat
thegoldenparadox - probably town
Flea The Magician - I don't think it would be impossible for this to be scum but I can also see it being town tbh
Haschel Cedricson - townlean
DrippingGoofBall - Maybe town
Battle Mage - town
gamma emerald - town
titus - not interested
OutWorldER - Maybe this could just be scum
Taly - maybe town not sure tbh could be anything
SirCakez - town
Akarin - town
PookyTheMagicalBear - not interested
Bell - I think this is town?

In post 1264, SirCakez wrote:Ok but this is not helping me out rn

In post 1266, SirCakez wrote:

In post 1263, Alisae wrote:Murdercat - I'd say aligned with Reck
Blitzo - Town and I ain't tellin you why until he is in range of dieing.
xRECKONERx - I'd say aligned with Murdercat
thegoldenparadox - probably town
Flea The Magician - I don't think it would be impossible for this to be scum but I can also see it being town tbh
Haschel Cedricson - townlean
DrippingGoofBall - Maybe town
Battle Mage - town
gamma emerald - town
titus - not interested
OutWorldER - Maybe this could just be scum
Taly - maybe town not sure tbh could be anything
SirCakez - town
Akarin - town
PookyTheMagicalBear - not interested
Bell - I think this is town?

This readslist is pretty bad Ali you're calling almost everyone town

In post 567, Taly wrote:

murderkitties

, i like your 563 but i feel like your 365 went a bit hard onto a slot relatively early for the games pace

how has your

cakez

read progressed?

In post 565, Flea The Magician wrote: TAAAALLLLLYYYYYYYY!
1) How are you?
2) Who is your worst read at the moment?
3) Is there anything so far you disagree with?
4) Why are you upside down? ( ͜。 ͡ʖ ͜。)

1)

good, bout to get to college work, need to stop letting mafia distract haha

2)

no particular scumreads... need to reread

TGP

because they did not pass the vibe check.

alisae

passed the vibe check but not yet the deepwolf check. i think you are quite fluffy even with your wall, tbh - i want more concrete statements from you.

pooky

feels agenda-y but that doesnt ping me by itself.
i think the amount of times

reck

comes into this thread only to say

"i wont read and i denounce the threads mentality"

is genuine BUT is being used deflectively.
actually did not care for this readslist from

BM

In post 287, Battle Mage wrote:i think it's most likely that Alisae is town and Titus is scum. Akarin town, Pooky town, Cakez town.

felt very early to make reads on these players, at least mostly town-ones.

id rather

BM

just explain these reads. i think

OWER

prodded them at some point but if they replied, the answer wasnt noticeable enough for me to see it.

(maybe OWER prodded murderkitties instead)

3)

disagreement is not the correct word... more cautiously inquisitive. this town did not have a very cohesive start with everything considered.

4)

why i am upside down you ask?
my nails are lavender D:< not as red as my role PM or as green as what id want to brag they be.